Aerodynamics
See how HPR Sim computes drag, normal force, center of pressure and roll from canted fins, subsonic and, less certainly, supersonic.
In short
-
What it models: the air’s forces on a rocket. The normal force is the sideways push at an angle to the airflow, and the center of pressure is where it acts. Both run from Mach 0 to 5, as do drag, the rolling moment from canted fins and the roll rate. A flight can use another program’s drag, or its normal force and center of pressure, instead of HPR Sim’s (The normal force from RASAero II).
-
Sources: Barrowman’s 1966 report, 1967 thesis and Centuri TIR-33 (1970), the basis of Barrowman’s method. Supersonic linear theory for fins past Mach 1. For drag, mainly Niskanen’s 2009 OpenRocket thesis. Stoney’s 1961 NASA measurements of noses through Mach 1 and MIL-HDBK-762 (1990) for boattails faster than sound add to it. For tube fins, Weissinger’s ring-wing formula and Fletcher’s 1957 NACA measurements.
-
How well it is validated:
-
Faster than sound, drag is only partly validated, and it misses both ways. It reads high against a wind tunnel, most of all for thin, sharp fins. The body alone reads a little low against a handbook’s worked example. A rocket with a short, steep boattail reads 5% to 15% low against RASAero II. Treat a supersonic flight’s drag, and its apogee, as rough.
-
Against OpenRocket, faster than sound, HPR Sim’s supersonic pressure drag (mostly wave drag) is about twice OpenRocket’s on the one supersonic flight compared. The comparison was read from OpenRocket’s per-component output, not kept as a record. Which is right is open (#222, a supersonic flight). For the nose alone a public probe keeps a record: at Mach 1.3, 1.5 and 2, OpenRocket 24.12 gives a tangent ogive of fineness ratio 3 under 1% of the pressure drag its own documented method gives. That is a confirmed defect in OpenRocket 24.12. Whether HPR Sim’s value matches a measured nose stays open (a tangent ogive past Mach 1).
-
Base drag under power is checked against one measured flight, and HPR Sim’s reads low. HPR Sim takes the burning motor case’s area off the base (Niskanen); OpenRocket keeps the whole base. On a NACA missile model’s flight below Mach 0.8, whose motor case is wider than its base, HPR Sim’s rule leaves no base drag under power: too little drag, so too high an apogee (which error flatters). The whole base reads high, and the jet raised the base drag where either rule lowers or keeps it (Base drag under power against the Hermes A-3A’s flight). No hobby rocket’s has been measured (evidence row G14). On one private supersonic flight the choice moves the apogee by about 24 percentage points (#222, Drag).
-
A boattail’s own drag faster than sound against 58 readings of 20 measured boattails of 3° to 10°, Mach 1.2 to 3.12: −21.9% to +28.3%. It is within 0.0123 in drag coefficient. Through Mach 1 it reads low, and under Niskanen’s subsonic rule long boattails get almost nothing. Steeper ones in a thick boundary layer read high: +26.4% to +54.2% for 16°. The drag of the base behind a boattail is within 0.0102 of 12 measured bases. Behind a small base, that difference can be 40% of the base’s own drag (Boattails faster than sound).
-
Drag reads high against a wind tunnel. NASA’s wind-tunnel tests of the Arcas Robin sounding rocket, Mach 0.6 to 4.63, measured the forebody only (the models’ bases sat on a sting). Against them every reading is high, and 2 of 44 are within 10%, both at Mach 1.0 with the fins on. With the fins on, from Mach 1.5 up, HPR Sim reads +39.4% to +154.0% high: the fins take a blunt edge’s formula. With the fins off it reads +13.5% to +24.1% from Mach 1.5 and +12.0% to +54.1% below. Most of that fins-off excess is the models’ 15° boattail. HPR Sim over-predicts that boattail’s drag in a boundary layer thicker than the boattail is deep. HPR Sim’s base drag behind a plain cylinder has been checked against no measurement faster than Mach 0.3 (Drag against the Arcas Robin wind tunnel).
-
Drag reads low against RASAero II past Mach 1.6, missing M1.8’s 10% there. The curves labeled RASAero in RocketPy’s example rockets don’t record their fins or surface finish, so HPR Sim uses stated guesses. Against Calisto’s, the one real RASAero II export, HPR Sim is within 10% at every Mach number up to 0.8. It is within 10% at 5 of the 7 between and at 8 of 17 from 1.2 to 2.0. There it reads −14.9% to −5.1%, lowest at Mach 2 (evidence row G26). Other plausible fins bring 14 to 17 of the 17 within 10%, though none puts every row of every band within it. Before HPR Sim modeled the boattail’s wave drag, it read −29.8% to −24.4% there (Drag against RASAero II through Mach 2).
-
Drag at Mach 0.3 against the same curves: two of seven cases within 10%; two boattailed ones fell just outside when the base behind a boattail was relieved (ADR-362). Cavour under power (motor burning) is −18.3%, cause open, and Valetudo’s table is 1.44 times its own OpenRocket export.
-
Against MIL-HDBK-762’s worked example, a rocket whose drag the U.S. Army’s handbook calculates term by term with every input known. With the fins left out, HPR Sim is within 10% at 6 of 12 Mach numbers. It reads +12.3% to +31.9% from Mach 0.9 to 1.2 (the nose and the base). From Mach 1.6 it reads −6.0% to −9.6% (friction and the base) (Drag against MIL-HDBK-762’s sample calculation).
-
The normal force and center of pressure at Mach 0 against Barrowman’s worked examples (rockets he calculated by hand). Every center of pressure agrees within 1%, and so does every normal-force slope but his six-fin Recruiter’s. It is +2.87% high for the rocket and +3.42% for its fins, mostly from a different six-fin rule. Against the same wind tunnel, Mach 0.6 to 4.63, from Mach 1.5: slope within +9.4% to −3.3% and center of pressure within 0.53 calibers. The long model misses the half-caliber target at Mach 1.8 and 2.3, where its body reads high. From Mach 0.8 to 1.2 the short model misses a target at four of five rows. The long one misses at all three from 0.9 (Normal force through Mach 1).
-
On a second measured body, the Basic Finner, free flights in a Canadian range from Mach 1.08 to 3.15 show HPR Sim’s slope 9.3% to 24.9% low and its center of pressure 0.03 to 0.34 calibers forward, the side that understates stability. The cause is not found (The Basic Finner’s normal force against DREV’s range). Against the same flights, with its wedge fins’ drag modeled from published figures, HPR Sim’s zero-lift drag reads 16.5% to 21.3% low from Mach 1.83 to 3.15, cause not found. Its pitch damping reads 24.7% to 39.6% low there, and 25.4% high at Mach 1.077 (The Basic Finner’s drag and pitch damping).
-
The body faster than sound, by the method a flight blends in over 0.3 in Mach from Mach 1.2 at the earliest. On the bodies it covers, against its report’s wind-tunnel measurements of 120 cone- and ogive-cylinders from Mach 3 to 6.28. There, 117 slopes are within ±0.2 per radian and 109 centers of pressure within 0.2 calibers. The method is checked against the Arcas Robin wind tunnel’s body alone (its two lengths, the short model and the long). The nose is a pointed one fitted to its shape, and the lip behind its boattail is left off (Checking the shock-expansion method):
- Like for like, fitted at the tunnel’s angles with the body lift a flight adds, the body with its boattail reads +3.4% to +41.0%. It is within 15% from Mach 3.96. Before M1.8e6 sized body lift and the boattail’s share, it read 14.9% to 73.2% high. At its 62 angles from 5.5° to 21.7°, 48 are within 15%.
- The method alone at against the tunnel’s line, which includes crossflow. The nose and cylinder of the short model: within 5% from Mach 1.8 to 2.96, and −15.0% and −18.7% past Mach 3. The long model: −13.7% to −26.4% throughout.
HPR Sim’s committed Arcas Robin designs fly that method to their base since M1.8e8. Like for like, the short model’s body reads 3.02 to 3.95 per radian from Mach 1.5. From Mach 1.5 the tunnel reads 2.19 to 4.15 (Normal force through Mach 1).
-
In whole flights in wind, body lift, which RocketPy leaves out, is the largest reason a slow rocket’s drift differs from RocketPy’s (ADR-026). Nothing against a real flight.
-
Roll: the spin that canted fins give, against NASA’s measured roll effectiveness (the rolling moment per degree of cant). Within 5.3% at all 8 readings from Mach 2.3 to 4.63, and 14.3% to 47.8% high at Mach 1.5 and 1.8. The roll damping reads 11.7% to 27.5% high from Mach 1.53 to 2.76 against the US Naval Ordnance Laboratory’s (NOL’s) wind tunnel, and 8.8% high on average in the core band and 5.0% in the extended band against Canada’s DREV free-flight range, both on the Basic Finner, a standard finned test body (Roll against the Arcas Robin and the Basic Finner).
-
Another program’s normal force, read from RASAero II’s export: every row of Calisto’s export comes back from HPR Sim’s table. A flight on a table swings in pitch as the equations predict. No real export has flown faster than Mach 0.75 (The normal force from RASAero II).
-
Pods take each pod’s parts on Barrowman’s rules, once per pod. They are checked against hand-worked numbers, and against OpenRocket on six probe designs, within 0.92% of its apogee below Mach 0.81. No measured flight checks them. Both codes leave out the pods’ and the body’s effect on each other’s flow, and HPR Sim a single pod’s off-axis moments (Pods).
-
Tube fins, each tube a ring wing below Mach 0.8: the slope is within 3% of five rings measured in a wind tunnel. No tube fin rocket has been checked against a measurement. On OpenRocket’s example, HPR Sim’s apogee is 6.95% higher, a net gap in the drag. OpenRocket’s tube-fin drag was refined against real flights, so HPR Sim’s probably reads low. The center of pressure rests on a judgment that moves that example’s margin from 0.29 to 0.79 calibers, against OpenRocket’s 1.87. The gap to OpenRocket is measured on 14 probe designs and pinned by a test; nothing measured says which code is nearer (Tube fins, #228).
-
-
What it leaves out: large angles and stall, though a flight uses these models at every angle. Faster than sound (transonic and supersonic):
- A steep boattail’s drag in a thick boundary layer reads high, and nothing corrects for it.
- The fins’ drag takes a blunt edge’s formula, which reads far high for thin, sharp fins.
- Nothing models a thin fin’s own wave drag or the drag where fins meet the body.
- A flight takes a pointed nose and its cylinder from the shock-expansion method, which marches along the body and adds the cylinder’s lift.
- A boattail behind them comes from a measured correlation of boattails of 4° to 9.5°, an extrapolation for steeper ones. HPR Sim stops reading it past the angle where the flow separates (The body faster than sound in a flight).
A nose with a vertical tip (power-series, Haack, elliptical) takes a Newtonian cap ahead of the method, checked on a sphere-cone only (Blunt tips). A lip inside a boattail’s wake carries nothing (A lip in a boattail’s wake). A conical flare flush with the tube ahead of it flies the method too, last in its run, while its corner’s shock stays attached. Checked against one measured flare, it reads −1.9% and +7.0% at Mach 1.9 and 2.3 and +13.4% at 2.96. It reads +51.5% and +50.4% at 3.95 and 4.63 (What a marched flare is worth). A flare shallow enough to turn the flow almost not at all is read by an older, rougher method instead. Nothing measures it (A near-flat flare). A rocket with any other widening shape, or any step, behind the nose keeps slender-body theory for its whole body at every speed. A motor retainer behind a step down counts: the step ends the run. That theory reads low past Mach 3 (A step in radius: −8.65% and 1.03 calibers at the threshold). Body lift leaves out the fall in crossflow drag past the critical crossflow Reynolds number (Body lift). It reads too large at the few degrees a slope is fitted over. The body alone misses the 15% target the milestone set on six of eleven wind-tunnel rows, by +37.7% at worst. It is within 5% at Mach 3.96 and 4.63 (The body alone, against the 15% target). There are no damping coefficients for pitch and yaw: a flight takes that damping from each part’s own local flow. The roll forcing near Mach 1.5 reads high, the roll damping reads high faster than sound, and no committed comparison checks roll below Mach 1.5 (Roll: forcing and damping).
Code and conventions
Where the code and its sources are, the symbols the page uses, and how the parts’ forces add up to your rocket’s center of pressure.
Code and sources
Code:
hpr_aero::body(bodies of revolution)hpr_aero::crossflow(body lift)hpr_aero::fins(fin sets)hpr_aero::nose_drag(noses’ drag through Mach 1)hpr_aero::afterbody(boattails faster than sound)hpr_aero::shock_expansion(the body faster than sound)hpr_aero::blunt_tip(a blunt tip’s cap and its handover)hpr_aero::table(tables from other programs)hpr_aero::tube_fins(tube fins)hpr_aero::model(a whole rocket’s terms, built from itsLayout)
Decisions: ADR-008 (normal force and center of pressure) and ADR-009 (drag). The milestones:
- M1.5a: the subsonic normal force and center of pressure
- M1.5b: the subsonic drag and override tables
- M1.8a: the normal force through Mach 1 (ADR-027)
- M1.8b1: the drag through Mach 1 (ADR-028)
- M1.8b3: boattails faster than sound (ADR-030)
- M1.8c: roll (ADR-031)
- M1.8d: the normal force from RASAero II (ADR-032)
- M1.8e1: the body faster than sound
(
hpr_aero::shock_expansion, ADR-033), flown from M1.8e2 - M1.8e4: the boattail’s share of the body faster than sound
- M1.8e6: body lift’s size at every speed and the boattail’s
measured share
(
hpr_aero::supersonic_boattail, ADR-037)
The rest of transonic and supersonic flow arrives with the rest of M1.8, the supersonic aerodynamics milestone.
A Loft lesson is something learned from Loft, the project that came before FusionSpace HPR: usually a mistake it made, sometimes a check worth keeping. This page names the ones on aerodynamics and the test that covers each.
Sources:
- [B66] J. S. and J. A. Barrowman. The Theoretical Prediction of the Center of Pressure,
NARAM-8, 1966 (
barrowman-1966-naram8-nakka; the Apogee copy lacks pp. 39–50). - [B67] J. S. Barrowman. The Practical Calculation of the Aerodynamic Characteristics of Slender Finned Vehicles, MS thesis, 1967 (NASA/TM-2001-209983).
- [TIR] J. S. Barrowman. Calculating the Center of Pressure of a Model Rocket, Centuri TIR-33, 1970.
- [N09] S. Niskanen. Development of an Open Source model rocket simulation software, MSc thesis, 2009, chapter 3.
- [TD] OpenRocket technical documentation 13.05 (the thesis revised; a document, not code).
- [G] R. Galejs. Wind Instability: What Barrowman Left Out, Sentinel 39.
- [762] MIL-HDBK-762(MI). Design of Aerodynamically Stabilized Free Rockets, 1990.
- [TN2114] S. M. Harmon and I. Jeffreys. Theoretical Lift and Damping in Roll of Thin Wings with Arbitrary Sweep and Taper at Supersonic Speeds: Supersonic Leading and Trailing Edges. NACA TN 2114, 1950.
- [D4013] J. C. Ferris. Static Stability Investigation of a Single-Stage Sounding Rocket at Mach Numbers from 0.60 to 1.20, NASA TN D-4013, 1967.
- [D4014] C. D. Babb and D. E. Fuller. Static Stability Investigation of a Sounding-Rocket Vehicle at Mach Numbers from 1.50 to 4.63, NASA TN D-4014, 1967.
- [N6652] F. J. Regan. Roll Damping Moment Measurements for the Basic Finner at Subsonic and Supersonic Speeds, NAVORD Report 6652, US Naval Ordnance Laboratory, 1964 (DTIC AD0600975).
- [DREV] A. D. Dupuis and W. Hathaway. Aeroballistic Range Tests of the Basic Finner Reference Projectile at Supersonic Velocities, DREV-TM-9703, DREV (Valcartier, Canada), 1997 (DTIC ADA636861).
- [S61] W. E. Stoney. Collection of Zero-Lift Drag Data on Bodies of Revolution from
Free-Flight Investigations, NASA TR R-100, 1961 (
nasa-tr-r-100-stoney-1961); p. 11, the base drag of a conical afterbody. - [J53] J. R. Jack. Theoretical Pressure Distributions and Wave Drags for Conical Boattails, NACA TN 2972, 1953.
- [CS51] E. M. Cortright Jr. and A. H. Schroeder. Investigation at Mach Number 1.91 of Side and Base Pressure Distributions over Conical Boattails without and with Jet Flow Issuing from Base. NACA RM E51F26, 1951.
- [DN54] C. A. de Moraes and A. M. Nowitzky. Experimental Effects of Propulsive Jets and Afterbody Configurations on the Zero-Lift Drag of Bodies of Revolution at a Mach Number of 1.59. NACA RM L54C16, 1954.
- [MJ54] B. Moskowitz and J. R. Jack. Aerodynamics of Slender Bodies at Mach Number of 3.12 … V: Aerodynamic Load Distributions for a Series of Four Boattailed Bodies, NACA RM E54B11, 1954.
- [C57] J. M. Cubbage Jr., Jet Effects on the Drag of Conical Afterbodies for Mach Numbers of 0.6 to 1.28, NACA RM L57B21, 1957.
- [Love57] E. S. Love. Base Pressure at Supersonic Speeds on Two-Dimensional Airfoils and on Bodies of Revolution with and without Fins Having Turbulent Boundary Layers, NACA TN 3819, 1957.
- [C72] W. B. Compton III. Jet Effects on the Drag of Conical Afterbodies at Supersonic Speeds, NASA TN D-6789, 1972.
- [R1135] Ames Research Staff. Equations, Tables, and Charts for Compressible Flow, NACA Report 1135, 1953.
- [SD56] C. A. Syvertson and D. H. Dennis. A Second-Order Shock-Expansion Method Applicable
to Bodies of Revolution Near Zero Lift, NACA TN 3527, 1956 (also NACA Report 1328;
naca-tn-3527-syvertson-dennis-1956). - [S64] J. L. Sims. Tables for Supersonic Flow Around Right Circular Cones at Small Angle of
Attack, NASA SP-3007, 1964 (
nasa-sp-3007-sims-1964-cones-small-alpha). - [J77] L. H. Jorgensen. Prediction of Static Aerodynamic Characteristics for Slender Bodies
Alone and With Lifting Surfaces to Very High Angles of Attack, NASA TR R-474, 1977
(
nasa-tr-r-474-jorgensen-1977). - [WP68] W. D. Washington and W. Pettis Jr., Boattail Effects on Static Stability at Small
Angles of Attack. U.S. Army Missile Command report RD-TM-68-5, 1968
(
washington-pettis-1968-rd-tm-68-5). - [J68] C. M. Jackson Jr., W. C. Sawyer and R. S. Smith. A Method for Determining Surface
Pressures on Blunt Bodies of Revolution at Small Angles of Attack in Supersonic Flow, NASA TN
D-4865, 1968 (
nasa-tn-d-4865-jackson-1968). - [S62] A. Seiff. Secondary Flow Fields Embedded in Hypersonic Shock Layers, NASA TN D-1304,
1962 (
nasa-tn-d-1304-seiff-1962). - [R22] C. E. Rogers. RASAero II Comparisons with ARCAS Center of Pressure (CP) and Drag Coefficient (CD) Wind Tunnel Data, Rogers Aeroscience, 2022 (slides).
- [RAS] C. E. Rogers and D. Cooper. Rogers Aeroscience RASAero II Aerodynamic Analysis and Flight Simulation Program Users Manual, version 1.0.2.0, 2019.
- [F57] H. S. Fletcher. Experimental Investigation of Lift, Drag, and Pitching Moment of Five
Annular Airfoils, NACA TN 4117, 1957 (
naca-tn-4117-fletcher-1957-annular-airfoils). - [H65] S. F. Hoerner. Fluid-Dynamic Drag, 1965, p. 7-13, Ring Foil; p. 3-12,
Fig. 20, the forebody pressure drag of blunt heads; and p. 3-20, eq. 35, the subsonic base
drag of a body of revolution (
hoerner-1965-fluid-dynamic-drag). - [HB85] S. F. Hoerner and H. V. Borst. Fluid-Dynamic Lift, 1985, p. 19-16, Ducted Body
(
hoerner-borst-1985-fluid-dynamic-lift). - [W21] N. Wagner. Theoretical and Experimental Investigation into the Flight of an X-Zylo,
arXiv:2102.02647, 2021, eq. 15, quoting J. Weissinger, Zur Aerodynamik des Ringflügels, 1955
(
arxiv-2102.02647-x-zylo-ring-wing). - [PNK57] W. C. Pitts, J. N. Nielsen and G. E. Kaattari. Lift and Center of Pressure of
Wing-Body-Tail Combinations at Subsonic, Transonic, and Supersonic Speeds, NACA Report 1307,
1957 (
naca-report-1307-pitts-nielsen-kaattari-1957-wing-body-tail-lift).
Conventions
An aerodynamic coefficient is a force divided by the dynamic pressure and by the reference area. is the pressure of the oncoming air, , with the air’s density and the airspeed. A coefficient has no units, so one number describes a small rocket and a large one of the same shape. These are the page’s symbols; each section also defines its own.
| symbol | meaning | unit |
|---|---|---|
| , | the reference diameter, and the reference area that every coefficient here is divided by | m, m² |
| station, | a station: a position along the rocket, in meters aft of the nose tip (Frames, Design tree) | m |
| , , | the axes of the body frame, fixed to the rocket: along its axis toward the nose, the direction around the body that fins are placed from, and square to both | none |
| the Mach number: airspeed divided by the speed of sound | none | |
| the total angle of attack: the angle between the nose direction and the rocket’s velocity relative to the air, from 0 to (Frames). The oncoming air flows the opposite way, so at it meets the nose head-on | rad | |
| the flow roll: which way around the body the air crosses it, measured from toward (Frames) | rad | |
| the coefficient of the normal force: the sideways push, square to the axis, in the plane that holds the axis and the airflow | none | |
| the normal-force slope: how fast grows with . It is for , and the derivative at ([N09] eq. 3.8) | per rad | |
| the side-force coefficient: a sideways push across that plane, along × the direction the air crosses in. Only sets of one or two fins produce it | none | |
| CP | the center of pressure: the station where the normal force acts | m |
The rocket’s CP is the average of its components’ CPs , each weighted by that component’s slope ([B66] p. 38; [N09] eq. 3.29):
The components are the nose cones, transitions, body tubes and fin sets; a body tube’s own slope is 0 (Bodies of revolution, below). A rocket whose slopes add up to zero has no CP.
In code, the page uses these names:
| name | what it is |
|---|---|
Layout | a design resolved into placed parts, from Rocket::layout; it holds the reference diameter (reference_diameter_m) |
AeroModel | a rocket’s aerodynamic terms, built from its Layout |
Flow | the conditions a model is evaluated at: , and |
NormalForce | the result, for the whole rocket or one component: (coefficient), (slope_per_rad), the CP (cp_station_m, None when there is none) and (side_coefficient) |
NormalForce::moment_m | the normal force’s turning effect about the nose tip, divided by and : , in meters. At an angle of attack the CP is moment_m / ; unlike the CP, moment_m is defined even when the forces cancel |
Your rocket’s center of pressure
HPR Sim works out the CP from the rocket’s shape alone, the way Barrowman’s method does by hand. Each nose, transition and fin set gets its own slope and CP (the next two sections). Your own rocket prints the CP, the center of gravity and the stability margin of an example rocket.
To get it in code:
- Take the rocket’s
AeroModelfrom a simulation withSimulation::aero, or build one from a design withRocket::layoutandAeroModel::new. - Call
AeroModel::normal_forcewithFlow::axial(mach): the air straight along the axis, at a Mach number below 5. The result’scp_station_mis the CP, in meters aft of the nose tip, and itsslope_per_radis the rocket’s . AeroModel::components, at the same flow, lists each component’s share, which shows what moves the CP.
What changes it:
-
Speed. Below Mach 1.2 only the fins’ terms change with Mach number; past it the bodies’ can too (The body faster than sound in a flight). Up to Mach 0.8 the fins’ slope grows through the Prandtl-Glauert factor, the classic correction for the air’s compressibility. Its effect grows as the speed nears that of sound (Prandtl-Glauert, under Fins). How much a fin set gains depends on its span, area and sweep. So as the rocket speeds up, the CP moves toward its fins:
- With fins only at the tail, it moves aft.
- With canards (a second fin set near the nose) as well, both sets gain. The CP can move either way, depending on each set’s shape and place.
- Up to Mach 0.8 HPR Sim keeps each fin set’s own CP a quarter of the way along its mean aerodynamic chord (MAC). The MAC is a weighted average of its chords. From there the CP moves aft. The fins’ slope grows up to where supersonic theory starts, Mach 1.2 or later, and falls past it (Fins through Mach 1). So a fast rocket’s CP moves forward again.
Flow::axial(0.0)gives the low-speed CP that Barrowman’s method gives by hand. -
Angle.
Flow::axialgives the small-angle CP. At an angle of attack, body lift adds a force at each body’s side-view centroid (the center of its outline seen from the side). The CP moves with it (Bodies of revolution, below). -
Stability. A rocket is statically stable when its CP is aft of its center of gravity (CG).
Assembly::mass_propertiesgives the rocket’s mass, CG and inertia seconds after ignition. A simulation’s assembly comes fromSimulation::assembly.- Its
cg_mis the CG in body axes, so the CG’s station is−cg_m.z. - The CP’s station less the CG’s, divided by , is the stability margin in calibers.
- Flight metrics gives the margin from the rail exit to apogee or the first deployment, with the air along the axis. It gives the margin at Mach 0 (the static margin) and at the flight’s Mach number (the flight margin). It gives none where the slopes all but cancel.
Bodies of revolution
Nose cones, transitions and body tubes, from the outer profile. A shoulder (the sleeve of a nose or transition that slides into the next tube) is inside the body and adds nothing. For one component:
| symbol | meaning | unit |
|---|---|---|
| its length | m | |
| its cross-section area aft of its fore end; at the fore end, at the aft end | m² | |
| its volume | m³ | |
| its CP, aft of its own fore end (not the body axis ) | m | |
| its planform area: the area of its outline seen from the side. Body lift acts at its centroid, the center of that area | m² |
Body lift is the extra push of the air crossing the body at larger angles of attack. It grows with , so it adds nothing to the slope at . Its size is in Body lift, below.
The slope ([B66] eq. 10, [B67] eq. 3-65, [N09] eq. 3.19):
The CP, aft of the fore end ([B66] eq. 28, [B67] eq. 3-89, [N09] eq. 3.28):
The moment slope ([N09] eq. 3.25):
Body lift, at the planform centroid (Body lift; [J77] eq. 2.12):
- A nose with a sharp tip has slope 2. A cylinder has 0 and no CP. A boattail has a negative slope. The CP formula for a frustum (a cone with its tip cut off), [B66] eq. 44, still holds for a boattail ([B66] p. 21).
- Radius steps (an extrapolation). A step where one body component meets the next adds
at the joint. This is the limit of a transition whose length goes
to zero. So the body’s total slope is [B66] eq. 10 over the whole body. [B67] p. 18 assumes no
discontinuities, so this goes beyond the source. Leaving the step out would silently drop its slope (a 27 mm (1.1 in) nose base on
a 29 mm (1.1 in) tube loses 13%). It is reported with the aft component (
BodyAero::step_area_m2). A blunt front face gets no term, as eq. 10 gives. The design checks warn about steps (radius_step). The real flow separates there, and the drag buildup counts it as a zero-length shoulder or boattail (Steps in radius, under Drag). - and the planform come from integrating the real profile (
hpr_design::revolve), so ogive, power, parabolic and Haack transitions (Shapes) get their own CP. Loft used the conical transition’s CP formula for every shape (Loft lesson L9). [B66] puts a tangent ogive nose’s CP at instead, with the nose’s length: 0.2–0.9% different at fineness 2.8–5. - Slender-body theory’s slope has no Mach term. [B67] p. 18 leaves body compressibility out as a conservative choice. [N09] p. 22 takes the body’s normal force as the same at all speeds. Faster than Mach 1.2 a flight can use another method (The body faster than sound in a flight).
- Body lift is zero at , so Barrowman’s worked examples don’t test it.
Body lift
Changed in M1.8e6 (ADR-037): until then HPR Sim used Galejs’s constant, with at every speed.
That slope was fitted from −4° to +4°, and below Mach 1 body lift adds a little to it. The air crosses the body faster than sound from crossflow Mach 0.95. With Galejs’s constant, 34 of the 62 angles are within 15%, and the body reads 41% high at Mach 0.6, against the same poorly determined readings.
At an angle of attack the air meets the body partly from the side, at . Behind a long cylinder in a cross-wind the air separates, and the drag of that separated flow pushes the body sideways. Jorgensen sizes body lift from that drag through two factors. is the drag coefficient of an infinitely long circular cylinder in the crossflow. is the ratio of a finite cylinder’s to an infinite one’s. Both depend on the crossflow Mach number , the Mach number of the air crossing the body. also depends on the body’s fineness , its length over its largest diameter.
| term | formula or value | source |
|---|---|---|
| body lift | , at each part’s planform centroid | [J77] eq. 2.12, p. 10 |
| crossflow Mach number | [J77] eq. 2.3, p. 8 | |
| 1.20 up to 0.2, rising to 1.334 at 0.5 and 1.985 at 1.0, then falling to 1.266 by 4.8 | [J77] Fig. 1, p. 75 | |
| at low , | 0.577 at = 2, 0.685 at 10, 0.753 at 20, 0.815 at 40 | [J77] Fig. 4, p. 77 |
| with , | 0.69 at 0; 0.717, 0.804, 0.815, 0.845, 0.994, 0.979, 0.769, 0.910 and 0.937 at 0.4 to 1.2 in steps of 0.1; 0.985 at 1.4; 0.984 at 1.6 | [J77] Fig. 6, p. 78 |
| for fineness | the equation below, the most has reached up to that | HPR Sim’s, a judgment |
- is Jorgensen’s value below the critical crossflow Reynolds number, where the air separates from a smooth cylinder early: “” at low speed (p. 15). From 0.6 to 1.2 HPR Sim takes the points Jorgensen marks as extrapolated from NASA Ames wind-tunnel data. From 1.4 it takes his curve through the supersonic experiments.
- . (Jorgensen’s; the shock-expansion method below uses for something else.) Fig. 4 gives against length for cylinders measured only at low speed. Fig. 6 gives how grows toward 1 as the crossflow speeds up, but only for the two bodies it was computed from. Jorgensen divided the those bodies’ (fineness 10 and 12) measured normal force gives (his Fig. 5) by Fig. 1’s . For any other fineness HPR Sim scales Fig. 6’s by how much Fig. 4 changes it for the body’s length. It lets that scaling fade by the share Fig. 6 has risen toward 1. The share it uses, , never falls back. Fig. 6 dips at only because Jorgensen divided by Fig. 1’s peak there, not because length counts again. Below 0.8, where Fig. 6 only rises, this is ; past 0.8 every fineness takes Fig. 5’s to within 0.3%. That rule is HPR Sim’s; it gives Fig. 6 back for a body of fineness about 10.6 and stays below 1.
- Sampled, not smoothed. Near Fig. 1’s peaks and Fig. 6’s dips, each
steeply. HPR Sim reads both at the eleven crossflow Mach numbers Jorgensen computed Fig. 6 at and
interpolates between them. So their product is his own there: within 3% of his Fig.
5 at all ten points from 0.5 to 1.6 (test
the_product_follows_figure_5).
A worked example. NASA’s short Arcas Robin model without fins, fineness 18.18, has a planform of 20.79 times its cross-section. At Mach 2.3 and , . Fig. 4 gives ; Fig. 6 gives , so
With , , and body lift is
Adding the attached-flow part (the method’s slope at small angles, without crossflow), HPR Sim’s body gives 1.632 there; the tunnel measured 1.630. This point happens to agree closely; across the 62 points the spread is −22.3% to +31.7% (table below).
What changes in a flight. At the low crossflow speeds of most flights is : 0.82 at fineness 10, 0.90 at 20, 0.95 at 30, against Galejs’s 1.1. A slow rocket leaving the rail in wind feels it most (Validity and open questions). The tunnel points where HPR Sim reads high, the air crossing the body faster than sound, are at 12° to 21° from Mach 2.96 up. A flight meets such angles that fast only if it is unstable or hit by a strong gust.
How it was checked. The Arcas Robin wind tunnel measured the body alone from −5° to 21° at six
Mach numbers (TN D-4014). The points above +4° were read for this milestone
into
arcas-robin-high-alpha.json).
arcas-robin-crossflow.json
compares HPR Sim’s body at each point, with the pointed nose fitted to the tunnel’s and the lip left
off (Checking the shock-expansion method):
| crossflow Mach number | points | HPR Sim’s against the tunnel’s | with Galejs’s |
|---|---|---|---|
| under 0.45 | 21 | −6.9% to +31.7% | +1.9% to +61.4% |
| 0.45 to 0.95 | 25 | −22.3% to +13.0% | −21.1% to +17.0% |
| 0.95 and over | 16 | +0.8% to +16.5% | −21.7% to −7.1% |
At the lowest crossflow speeds the readings can’t split what is left between body lift and the slope at (Checking the shock-expansion method). Where the air crosses faster than sound, HPR Sim’s (1.45 to 1.61) is above what the tunnel’s points need (1.26 to 1.54). Jorgensen’s was worked out from measured normal force less his own attached-flow term, . HPR Sim pairs it with its own, times its slope. That term is 8% larger at 20°. Faster than sound it carries the method’s slope for the nose and cylinder, 2.55 to 3.40 against slender-body theory’s 2. Two cautions from Jorgensen: his comes from cylinders measured “only at very low subsonic Mach numbers” (p. 17). The other: the tunnel tripped its boundary layer. That can move the flow past the critical crossflow Reynolds number, where falls to “between about 0.15 and 0.30” (p. 15).
What it leaves out. HPR Sim omits that fall past the critical crossflow Reynolds number (about
, [J77] Fig. 2), which Jorgensen computes only for illustration. It omits roughness
and fins’ effect on the body’s crossflow. It also omits Jorgensen’s own attached-flow term,
, in place of HPR Sim’s .
Galejs’s constant stays available for comparison
(BodyLift::Galejs, with
AeroModel::with_body_model):
[G] cites Hoerner’s 1.1 to 1.5 and fitted 1.0 to his own data.
Bodies faster than sound
Flown faster than sound for a pointed nose and its cylinder (The body faster than sound in a flight, below). This is M1.8e1’s method, the second-order shock-expansion method as a tested library model. Against its report’s wind-tunnel data, 117 of 120 slopes are within 0.2 per radian. On the Arcas Robin’s body it reads from 16% high at Mach 1.5 to 26% low past Mach 3 at . That comparison leaves out the body lift a flight adds. Compared the way the tunnel measures, the body reads high (Checking the shock-expansion method, under Verification). It needs a pointed tip; a blunt or vertical one (power-series, elliptical and Haack noses) takes a Newtonian cap ahead of it (Blunt tips, below).
Slender-body theory, above, gives a pointed nose a slope of 2 and a cylinder none, at any speed. Faster than sound that is too little. The air speeds up around the shoulder where the nose meets the cylinder, and its pressure then recovers along the cylinder toward the free stream’s. At an angle of attack it recovers unevenly around the body, so the cylinder carries lift too, more the longer it is. NASA measured the Arcas Robin’s body alone at 3.9 per radian at Mach 3.96, where slender-body theory gives 2 for its nose.
HPR Sim computes that lift by Syvertson and Dennis’s second-order shock-expansion method ([SD56]). It does so for a body with a pointed tip and supersonic flow everywhere on it, as the slope at small angles of attack (). The older generalized shock-expansion method holds the pressure constant along each straight piece of the profile. The second-order method also carries the pressure’s rate of change across each corner, so the pressure can recover along a piece:
- The tangent body. The profile becomes straight elements, each tangent to it. The first is at the tip. The rest are at equal steps along a curved nose (ten per curved piece, the report’s own choice), one per cone or cylinder. Where two elements meet is a corner.
- The tip is a cone, so its flow is exactly a cone’s. The Taylor-Maccoll equation, the exact equation of supersonic flow over a cone, is integrated from the shock to the surface ([R1135] eq. 177). The shock must be attached, touching the tip, which holds up to a half-angle that grows with the Mach number. For cones under 0.03°, where that equation can’t be integrated, HPR Sim takes slender-cone linear theory, blended in up to 0.06°.
- Around each corner the flow turns by a Prandtl-Meyer expansion.
- Along each element the pressure relaxes from its value behind the corner toward the pressure on the element’s tangent cone. It is the cone, pointed into the oncoming flow, whose surface has the body’s local slope there. The lift per unit length relaxes the same way, toward that cone’s.
- The slope and CP follow by adding the lift over the body.
The pressure along an element ([SD56] eqs. 8, 9):
The gradient behind a corner ([SD56] eqs. 4, 6):
The gradient at an element’s end ([SD56] eq. 10):
The lift per unit length ([SD56] eqs. 5, 19):
The slope and CP ([SD56] eqs. 14, 21):
is an element’s angle to the axis, and the pressure over the free stream’s (the
undisturbed air ahead of the rocket). is the Mach number at the surface, and the radius at
the corner. is how much a thin tube of flowing air widens as its Mach number rises. It
is the tube’s area over its area at Mach 1 ([SD56] eq. 7). is the Mach angle .
is the slope of the tangent cone, digitized by hand
from the report’s Fig. 2 into a table. It is continued past that chart’s 24° to 30° by Sims’s own
tables of the same theory (ADR-042,
cone_normal_force_slope).
For a worked example with numbers, see
Checking the shock-expansion method.
- A cylinder’s tangent cone is the free stream, so its lift decays to nothing along it.
- A boattail has no tangent cone. The report’s footnote 8 takes the free stream’s pressure and a slope of 2, “reasonable results for bodies having moderate amounts of boattail”. The method does the same, but a measurement says it takes too little lift off. Since M1.8e6 a flight gives a boattail a measured share instead (The body faster than sound in a flight).
- Where the method stops. The relaxation holds only where the gradient behind a corner points toward the tangent cone’s pressure (, [SD56] p. 13). The report states that as a condition and doesn’t say how it went on where it fails, near a sharp tip at high Mach number. HPR Sim’s own reading is to reduce such an element to the older generalized method, which the report says the equations become at . There the pressure stays as it is along the element and no gradient passes to the next corner. On the report’s fineness-3 ogive at Mach 5.05 that departs from its values (issue #81: the method’s limit near a sharp tip). HPR Sim reads an element that way wherever it has a tangent cone of its own, behind the nose or on it (A near-flat flare). A cylinder’s tangent cone is the free stream and a boattail’s is footnote 8’s. So neither is a solution of that element’s own flow. One of those that would need reducing is refused instead. The whole body then keeps slender-body theory (issue #123: a cylinder’s or a boattail’s reduced element).
- Mach number over nose fineness. The report states the method for 0.4 to 2, and HPR Sim doesn’t enforce it. A nose of fineness is below the range up to Mach : a 5:1 nose up to Mach 2.0, a 6:1 nose up to Mach 2.4. A flight starts using the method between Mach 1.2 and 1.5, so such a nose spends most of the way to Mach 2.5 below the range. One measured row sits there, the short Arcas Robin at Mach 1.5, at 0.36. Its body alone reads 4% above the tunnel at , inside the measurement’s ±0.32 per radian. On the slope fitted at the plotted angles it reads 37.7% above (The body alone, against the 15% target). On that row the whole rocket’s center of pressure, fins on, reads 0.25 calibers aft of the tunnel’s, the side that makes the margin look larger (Normal force through Mach 1). The report’s own Mach 6.28 rows sit above the range, at 2.09.
- Its range. The report states the method for Mach number over nose fineness from 0.4 to 2, within ±0.2 per radian and ±0.2 calibers of its measurements. Fig. 2 covers Mach 3 to 10; below Mach 3 HPR Sim holds the Mach 3 curve, an assumption. The tip’s shock must be attached, and the profile continuous. Tangent cones run to 30°: to 24° from Fig. 2, and from there to 30° from NASA SP-3007’s tables of the same theory. They agree with the chart to 0.0021 per radian where both cover the same angle (ADR-042). A cone steeper than 30° is refused, and the whole body then keeps slender-body theory.
- What it leaves out: the crossflow lift that grows with (Body lift, above), and anything viscous. It is the slope at small angles only.
The body faster than sound in a flight
The fastest validation flight is Prometheus: see its max_mach rows in the validation report.
What is extrapolated. A transition that isn’t conical takes the same correlation from its length and radii. Past 16° the flow separates, and HPR Sim holds the correlation at its 16° reading (the 16° rule, issue #90: how steep a boattail the correlation should cover). A tube behind the boattail takes the method’s decay of its expansion, which no measurement here checks. A blunt or vertical nose tip takes a Newtonian cap ahead of the method (Blunt tips), an extrapolation from spherical caps. A conical flare flush with the part ahead of it flies the method while its corner’s shock is attached. One measured flare has been put beside it (What a marched flare is worth). Where the shock is not attached, the flare is read drawn out, and that half still has none. Any other widening shape, or any step, keeps slender-body theory, which on the Arcas Robin’s body reads 15% to 50% below the tunnel faster than sound.
Which model your rocket gets. Every body takes body lift at every speed. Past Mach 1.2, a rocket takes the method below for its nose, tubes and boattails when its first body is a nose. That nose is pointed, or has a blunt or vertical tip that the cap covers. The method applies only when nothing but tubes of its radius and boattails (and tubes behind those) follows the nose. A lip wholly inside a boattail’s wake rides along, carrying nothing (A lip in a boattail’s wake). A lip only partly in the wake gets the method in the wake’s own proportion, and slender-body theory for the rest. A conical flare flush with the part ahead of it joins the run as well, and ends it (A flare through the method). A widening part behind a boattail is a lip, not a flare, and keeps the lip’s rule. Anything else keeps slender-body theory for its whole body at every speed. Examples are a step, a widening shape other than a cone, and a nose steeper than the cap’s handover all the way to its base. A motor retainer behind a step down is another, since the step ends the run.
Where that choice still jumps. It is one choice for the whole body. So a rocket either side of any threshold it turns on gets two different models. The difference is the whole body’s, not the part that changed. At Mach 3 and 4°, each remaining threshold is worth
this much. The first four rows use two test bodies. The flare behind a boattail is on a finless body, so its share is of a body’s normal force alone. The other three are on the tests’ straight rocket, which keeps its four fins, so the two kinds of share don’t compare. The last column says who owns it. Open is an issue with no milestone behind it. Queued is a milestone on the roadmap. No longer a switch is a threshold since removed, kept here because its size is the measured cost of the model it replaced. The tests pin the rows: issue_87s_switches_are_this_big the first four, a_lip_in_a_boattails_wake_carries_nothing the lip’s two, and a_near_flat_flare_marches_every_row_and_the_fallback_is_still_measured the last:
| drawing this | normal force | center of pressure | who owns it |
|---|---|---|---|
| a step in radius, past a billionth of the local radius | −8.65% | 1.03 calibers | queued: M1.14d: supersonic accuracy, these switches first, and M1.14h above Mach 2.5; issue #87: a step has no model of its own |
| a flare behind a boattail and too long for its wake, however small | −27.5% | 0.29 calibers | queued, as the first row; issue #120: a lip longer than its wake |
| a pointed tip steeper than the cone tables’ 30° | −7.7% | 0.81 calibers | queued, as the first row; issue #121: a tip past the cone tables |
| a vertical tip steeper than the cap’s handover to its base | −7.0% | 0.64 calibers | queued, as the first row |
| a lip leaving its boattail’s wake by rising or by sitting back | −29 to −34% | 0.93 to 1.97 calibers | no longer a switch: the rise is weighed, ADR-041 |
| a lip longer than its boattail’s drop in diameter, however little it rises | −33.0% | 1.77 calibers, forward | queued: M1.14d: supersonic accuracy, after the four switches above, since it reads less stable; issue #120: a lip longer than its wake |
| a near-flat flare, 0.03816° to 0.05882° at the table’s top rows, which the march used to refuse | −8.3% | 1.16 calibers | no longer a switch: the element is read by the generalized method, ADR-050 |
In the first four rows the center of pressure moves aft when the method is lost. So a rocket that trips one reads more stable than one that doesn’t. The near-flat-flare row goes the same way: its test pins the center of pressure 1.16 calibers aft on slender-body theory. The two lip rows go the other way. Their tails take lift off in a boattail’s wake. There slender-body theory puts the center of pressure forward of the method’s, so losing the method there reads less stable. Which way it goes depends on the body; what is reliable is the size.
The lip row about length is a switch the wake’s grading does not cover. The length limit is a threshold, not a ramp. It is the one this page’s measurements use to take a rocket off the method without changing a radius or an angle.
The first lip row is no longer a switch: it is spread over the band the wake grades, as above. The second still is one. Nor is the last. Since M1.8e19 the march reads that flare’s element rather than refusing it. What is left where it used to switch is the loading’s step at the corner’s crossing: +0.129% and 0.0051 calibers on this rocket. The step is larger on other bodies and on longer flares (A near-flat flare). The two tips moved rather than went. A pointed tip’s edge is the cone tables’ 30° since M1.8e11. A vertical tip’s edge is the handover’s cap, which stands at 24° for the reason in What the cap is worth.
The flare went (M1.8e17, ADR-047): a conical flare in the free stream now flies the method. Nothing jumps across the boundary where its shock detaches; see A flare through the method below. The second row is what is left of it, a flare behind a boattail. That is a lip in the boattail’s wake rather than a flare in the free stream, and it keeps its own rule. The last row is what that milestone turned up on the way: a band of near-flat flares, a third of a millimeter tall, whose one element the march reduces to the generalized method. M1.8e19 closed it.
The step stayed, and M1.8e15 says why. The march needs a profile without a jump in it. So a step needs a model of its own, not a decision about an existing one. The obvious fix turned out to cost more than it saved. What that milestone did measure is in A step in radius below. Its threshold is a billionth of the radius, a few hundredths of a nanometer on a 54 mm (2.1 in) body. Any step a person would draw is past it. A rocket whose shape sits near one of these thresholds is worth checking on both sides.
What a flight takes. The method covers the nose, when it is the first body (a blunt or vertical tip behind its Newtonian cap). Body tubes straight behind it at the same radius are covered. So are boattails (transitions that narrow toward the tail) and tubes behind those, with no step between them (M1.8e4). A conical flare is covered too, and ends the run (M1.8e17). It flies only if nothing else behind them changes the radius: no step, and no widening shape but that flare. Mixing the method’s nose and cylinder with slender-body theory’s boattail would put the center of pressure further off than slender-body theory alone. So the boattail takes a supersonic share too, measured (below). Each covered part gets its own share, so the flight’s pitch damping still comes from each part’s own local flow. That flow is taken at one station per part; the part’s force and its moment about the nose tip are the method’s either way. A nose or cylinder takes that station at its share’s own center of pressure. A boattail’s share is usually negative, and so is a tube’s behind it. The method carries the boattail’s expansion down the tube, where it fades out over several calibers. So a long tube can lose as much as the short boattail. On the tests’ finned rocket (hand-measured, not pinned), a 5.7° boattail 0.05 m (0.16 ft) long takes 0.284 per radian off at Mach 2. Footnote 8 took 0.117 there. The 0.3 m (0.98 ft) tube behind the boattail takes 0.210 per radian off at Mach 2. Such a share could cross zero as the Mach number changes, sending its center of pressure off to infinity. So these parts take their local flow where slender-body theory does, on the part. A boattail takes it at its slender-body center of pressure, a tube at its body-lift station. Only the damping feels this. On the test rocket at Mach 2 the tube’s share acts at 1.040 m (3.41 ft). Its flow is taken at about 1.15 m (3.8 ft). With the center of mass near 0.7 m (2.3 ft), that part’s (negative) damping reads about 30% large. Body lift, the term, is unchanged.
The boattail, measured. Washington and Pettis ([WP68]) mounted the aft section of a wind-tunnel model on its own balance. They measured it with a conical boattail and as a plain cylinder of the same length, Mach 1.75 to 4.5. They also measured a whole model with and without a boattail from Mach 0.8 to 1.5. The boattail’s increment in slope, per degree on the cylinder’s area, collapses onto one curve:
with the diameter ahead of the boattail, its base diameter and its length. The slope is read by hand from [WP68] Fig. 5, p. 8, into
WP_SLOPE_PER_DEG to about ±0.02 per radian. The increment acts about halfway along the boattail, from 43% of its length at
Mach 2 to 64% at 4.5 ([WP68] Fig. 6, p. 9). A flight gives a boattail the share the method gives
a cylinder of the boattail’s length and fore diameter in its place. The increment is added at its own center of pressure (test the_boattail_takes_washington_and_pettis_increment). Slender-body theory
gives the same boattail at every speed, which is Fig. 5’s own subsonic line. Faster than sound the measured increment is less than half of that line at the Arcas Robin’s speeds (0.24 to 0.47), footnote 8’s less again. The curve is not always below that line. Across Fig. 5 it runs from 0.23 to 1.58 times the line, passing it at an argument of 0.635, near Mach 1.
A steep boattail reads the correlation no steeper than 16°. Washington and Pettis measured
boattails of 4° to 9.5°, where the flow follows the surface. Past about 16° it doesn’t: the drag
buildup already treats a boattail as separating from there
(Boattails faster than sound, Cubbage’s steepest attached
boattail). Nothing measures what a separated boattail’s normal force then does. So HPR Sim reads the correlation at the steepest angle where the flow is still attached. A boattail past 16° takes the increment of one of the same radii drawn out to 16°. Its center of pressure stays on the real boattail (ADR-040,
issue #90: how steep a boattail the correlation should cover).
The Arcas Robin’s 15° boattail is untouched; Calisto’s 18.4° reads its correlation as a 16° one.
The increment is continuous in the angle, so a rocket doesn’t jump as its boattail is drawn
steeper (test a_separating_boattail_reads_the_correlation_at_its_steepest_measured_angle).
Why hold it rather than let it fade. The two honest limits for a separated boattail are the correlation held at 16° and nothing at all. Nothing at all means the body behaves as though the boattail were a cylinder, since a separated surface no longer turns the flow. HPR Sim takes the first. The increment is negative, so it takes lift off the tail. Holding it keeps the center of pressure forward. Letting it fade to zero would move the center of pressure aft and make a steep boattail look more stable than anything measured. The tests’ rocket has an ogive nose, a tube and a 30° boattail. Its body’s center of pressure sits this much further aft if the increment fades away than if it is held:
| Mach | between the two rules, calibers |
|---|---|
| 1.5 | 1.35 |
| 2 | 0.91 |
| 3 | 0.75 |
| 4.63 | 0.67 |
That is the size of the doubt, and it is largest where a hobby rocket spends its supersonic flight. A boattail steeper than 16° is worth two thirds of a caliber at Mach 4.63. At Mach 1.5 it is worth a third of a caliber more than one. HPR Sim takes the forward end of that range (test
a_separating_boattail_reads_the_correlation_at_its_steepest_measured_angle pins both ends).
One more bound is on the holding, not the measurement. Reading a longer boattail
walks the correlation’s argument toward zero. There Fig. 5’s curve comes from the report’s lowest supersonic runs and rises past Munk’s slender-body line. The report plots that line there for comparison at subsonic speeds (p. 3). HPR Sim does not invent a length and then
read that branch, so the extra the holding takes off stops at potential flow’s
(holding_the_correlation_stops_at_potential_flow).
A boattail’s read at its own length is never clipped, wherever it sits. That is the correlation as published. A genuinely long boattail reads the same near-Mach-1 branch with no bound at all. A 4° boattail to 0.6 of the radius reads 1.29 times Munk’s line at Mach 1.5, and HPR Sim flies it. Only the length the 16° hold invents is capped. The bound bites when the aft radius is under about of the fore radius. That is two fifths at Mach 1.2, a quarter at 1.3, a twentieth at 1.45, and nothing much above Mach 1.49. It bites only where the method’s table has started, which on such shapes it barely has.
How much that is worth is measured. A sweep takes boattails of 16° to 53.6° narrowing to between a thousandth and three tenths of the fore radius. It reads their shares back out of the table (what_the_potential_flow_bound_reaches).
- At the table’s rows a boattail never takes off more lift than potential flow, except in the sliver described below. In that sliver a boattail’s own read already passes potential flow, and the bound never clips that.
- The bound moves a printed coefficient by about 0.060 per radian at most, at 53.5° narrowing to a thousandth of the radius. That is the printed number, after the join’s weight. The holdback on the boattail’s own cross-section is up to about six times larger near the join, where the join is barely open. 53.5° is the steepest boattail the sweep found the method willing to table at all. The method refuses 53.6°, and refuses shallower angles than that where the boattail narrows less.
No committed design comes near. The steepest is Calisto’s 18.4°. Its aft radius is 0.685 of its fore radius, where the bound would need under 0.40 even at Mach 1.2.
Two caveats, both small but real. The bound applies where the shares are computed, at the table’s rows. Between rows the table interpolates, so a printed value beside a row of the next kind can sit past potential flow. It can do so by up to about 0.003 per radian on the shapes swept. And there is a sliver just above the hold’s own angle (the sweep finds it at 16°, 16.5°, 17° and 17.25°). In it, a boattail is deep enough that its own read already passes potential flow. The bound never clips a boattail’s own length, so the hold does nothing there, and the rocket flies an extrapolation nothing measured checks. That window runs a few hundredths of a Mach from where the table starts, so the join is barely open across it. The window closes as the angle or speed rises, not at a fixed angle.
The two models draw opposite consequences from the same angle. Separation lowers a boattail’s pressure drag toward the base value. Here it holds the lift the boattail takes off instead of letting it shrink. The argument for that is the stability one above, not a flow one. The angle is also read on each narrowing part’s own chord angle. The drag merges adjacent narrowing parts into one cone before grading. So a boattail drawn in several parts can be graded differently by the two.
A worked example. The Arcas Robin’s boattail narrows from 2.25 in to 1.308 in over 1.757 in, so and . At Mach 2.3, and Fig. 5’s argument is 2.071/0.781 = 2.652. There the curve reads −0.01263 per degree, −0.7237 per radian. Times 0.662, that is −0.479 per radian on the body’s cross-section. Slender-body theory gives −1.324, footnote 8 −0.103. Across the tunnel’s Mach numbers:
| Mach | Washington and Pettis, per rad | footnote 8, per rad | slender-body theory, per rad |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | −0.622 | −0.177 | −1.324 |
| 1.8 | −0.554 | −0.144 | −1.324 |
| 2.3 | −0.479 | −0.103 | −1.324 |
| 2.96 | −0.409 | −0.068 | −1.324 |
| 3.96 | −0.340 | −0.038 | −1.324 |
| 4.63 | −0.314 | −0.026 | −1.324 |
Their models were conical boattails of 4° to 9.5°, 0.82 to 1.18 diameters long, narrowing to 0.72
to 0.86 of the diameter. The Arcas Robin’s is steeper (15°), shorter (0.78) and narrower (0.58),
so its row is an extrapolation. Their points scatter about the curve by up to about 15%. Past the
curve’s end (an argument of 6.1: a short boattail at a high Mach number) HPR Sim holds its last
value. BodyModel keeps footnote 8 for comparison.
A table. One run of the method takes a few milliseconds, too slow for every step of a flight. So the first time a flow faster than Mach 1.2 needs it, HPR Sim runs the method every 0.05 in Mach from Mach 5 down. It stops at the lowest Mach at which the method holds, and keeps the results. Between those Mach numbers it interpolates in a straight line. That took about 0.3 s once per rocket in a debug build on the development Mac. The time was measured by hand, for a body the method takes from Mach 1.2. A body whose join starts higher adds about 48 runs for the bisection below. A rocket that never passes Mach 1.2 never pays it.
The join. Write SB for slender-body theory, SE for the shock-expansion method, and for where the join starts. That is Mach 1.2, or the lowest Mach at which the method holds if that is higher. HPR Sim narrows that Mach down between two rows of the table by halving the gap (bisection). It stops when no smaller step exists in the computer’s numbers. It then runs the method at that Mach and adds the result as an extra row. The start must be that exact. There the method’s shares climb from zero like the square root of the distance in Mach. So a start off by puts -sized shares in that row. So the start moves smoothly with the nose’s shape instead of in 0.05 steps. A cone with a 20° half-angle (the angle between its side and its axis) joins from Mach 1.341910. Each 0.1° steeper, up to 20.5°, moves the start about 0.0027 later, to 1.355500. From to , each covered part’s slope, moment and station move linearly from SB’s to SE’s, with clamped to 0 to 1:
Every piece is a straight line in Mach, so nothing jumps. The test
the_supersonic_join_has_no_jump looks at ±1e-9 in Mach on each side of the join’s ends, of table rows, between rows and at Mach 4.999. a_blunter_cone_joins_where_the_method_starts_to_hold does the same for the 20° cone, whose join starts higher.
the_joins_start_moves_with_the_nose_not_in_steps pins that cone’s start and the 20.5° cone’s to 1e-6. It checks the start is off the grid, and that the cylinder’s share at the start is under 1e-5 per radian (about 1e-7). It also checks the start moves by less than 1e-7 when the cone steepens by a
millionth of a degree (2.7e-8). a_boattailed_body_flies_the_method_without_a_jump does the same
±1e-9 probe for the finned rocket with its boattail and tail tube. Mach 1.2 to 1.5 is a judgment. Below Mach 1.2 the flow over the nose is transonic, which the method doesn’t cover. Mach 1.5 is the lowest Mach of NASA’s supersonic tests of the Arcas Robin, in TN D-4014
(ADR-034,
the decision behind it). Small changes in shape can still switch a body between the two models. An example is a nose so steep that the method never holds at any Mach up to 5. The rocket then keeps slender-body theory throughout
(issue #87).
A worked example: the Arcas Robin’s body. NASA measured the Arcas Robin’s body without fins in a wind tunnel (TN D-4014). The secant-ogive nose (a tangent ogive’s cousin, its arc larger) is fitted to the report’s coordinates, and the boattail is left off. Flown through a flight’s own code, the nose and cylinder give the method’s own values. They are equal on the table’s rows (Mach 1.5, 1.8, 2.3), and within 1e-4 between them.
With the boattail on (the lip behind it off, a flare the method doesn’t take), the boattail takes its measured share. That is 0.31 to 0.62 per radian off, most at Mach 1.5 (footnote 8 took 0.03 to 0.18). At the short model reads 12.0% to 26.2% below the measured line and the long model 29.7% to 33.3% below it. That line is fitted over the plotted angles, so it carries crossflow lift. These columns leave body lift out; fitted the same way with the body lift a flight adds, the same body reads 3.4% to 41.0% high (Checking the shock-expansion method).
HPR Sim’s committed Arcas Robin design flies the method to its base since Blunt tips and A lip in a boattail’s wake. The last two columns are the method’s own values for its power-series nose, cylinder and boattail, with the lip carrying nothing. Slopes are on the body’s cross-section, at . The measured slope is fitted over the plotted angles with the boattail and lip on. So it also carries some crossflow lift and their share, which is why every column reads below it here.
| model | Mach | measured, per rad | method, per rad | flight, nose and cylinder, per rad | flight vs measured | flight, with boattail, per rad | with boattail vs measured | design as committed, per rad | committed vs measured |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| short | 1.5 | 2.192 | 2.552 | 2.552 | +16.4% | 1.930 | −12.0% | 1.852 | −15.5% |
| short | 1.8 | 2.613 | 2.724 | 2.724 | +4.3% | 2.171 | −16.9% | 2.143 | −18.0% |
| short | 2.3 | 3.078 | 2.931 | 2.931 | −4.8% | 2.452 | −20.3% | 2.394 | −22.2% |
| short | 2.96 | 3.284 | 3.124 | 3.124 | −4.9% | 2.716 | −17.3% | 2.612 | −20.5% |
| short | 3.96 | 3.884 | 3.300 | 3.300 | −15.0% | 2.963 | −23.7% | 2.735 | −29.6% |
| short | 4.63 | 4.149 | 3.371 | 3.371 | −18.7% | 3.063 | −26.2% | 2.718 | −34.5% |
| long | 1.8 | 3.159 | 2.724 | 2.724 | −13.7% | 2.171 | −31.3% | 2.143 | −32.1% |
| long | 2.3 | 3.525 | 2.932 | 2.932 | −16.8% | 2.453 | −30.4% | 2.394 | −32.1% |
| long | 2.96 | 3.868 | 3.127 | 3.127 | −19.2% | 2.718 | −29.7% | 2.614 | −32.4% |
| long | 3.96 | 4.455 | 3.313 | 3.313 | −25.6% | 2.974 | −33.3% | 2.740 | −38.5% |
| long | 4.63 | 4.615 | 3.395 | 3.395 | −26.4% | 3.082 | −33.2% | 2.724 | −41.0% |
The rows are in
validation/fixtures/aero/shock-expansion.json
(arcas_robin: nose_and_cylinder, in_flight, in_flight_with_boattail and as_designed), written by cargo xtask aero. No test re-reads the flight columns, so they are regenerated by hand.
What it leaves out. Steps, and widening shapes that are not cones, as above. A conical flare has its own section (A flare through the method). A blunt or vertical tip takes the cap of Blunt tips, below. The method itself has no crossflow lift; a flight adds body lift on top.
A lip in a boattail’s wake
What this covers: a short flare at the very base, behind a boattail, like the reflex lip of NASA’s Arcas Robin models.
The rule. A lip that sits wholly in a boattail’s wake carries no potential-flow slope from the Mach number where the method takes over. Below the join it keeps slender-body theory’s , and the join blends the two, so nothing jumps. HPR Sim takes the shelter’s share from its drag model (ADR-030, which takes the same lip’s drag away). The lip is wholly in the wake up to a rise of a quarter of the boattail’s drop in diameter. From a rise of half that drop it is not in the wake at all. The wake fades over any tube between them. On top of that fraction the normal force asks one thing the drag model doesn’t. The lip must be no longer than the boattail’s drop in diameter, the wake’s own scale. Otherwise it grows out of the wake however little it rises. ADR-039, the lip’s decision record, sets out the readings behind the share itself.
A lip part way out of the wake. Where the wake covers the lip only partly, the drag model has always graded it so. Since M1.8e10 the normal force reads the same number as a weight. The method’s share counts for the wake’s share of the lip, slender-body theory for the rest, exactly as they blend across the Mach join (ADR-041). It is the whole wake fraction, not the rise alone. The shelter fades with the lip’s rise, with any tube between it and the boattail, and with anything else in the way.
The jump is gone. A lip drawn a hair taller no longer switches the whole body between the two models. On the tests’ rocket at Mach 3 that switch was worth a third of the normal force and 1.77 calibers of center of pressure. The sensitivity is not gone; it is spread over the band. On that rocket, at Mach 3 and 4°:
| drawn from | to | normal force | center of pressure |
|---|---|---|---|
| a lip rising a quarter of the boattail’s drop | rising a half (2.5 mm (0.098 in) of radius) | −29.1% | 0.93 calibers |
| a lip flush behind the boattail | one a boattail’s drop in diameter behind it (10 mm (0.39 in)) | −33.8% | 1.97 calibers |
That table is a design sensitivity: how the printed answer moves as you draw the lip differently. It is not how far apart the two models are, which is what a lip in the band is uncertain by. At one fixed shape (a lip rising a quarter of the drop) the two models differ by 33.0% of the normal force and 1.77 calibers. Nothing measured says which is right for a part-sheltered lip. That number has not changed; what changed is that a rocket can no longer cross it in a ten-thousandth of its geometry.
Why nothing. Three readings point the same way.
- The tunnel itself. TN D-4014 ([D4014] p. 6) traces an odd chamber axial force at Mach 1.50 and 1.80, fins off, to the reflex lip. The report says the effect is “masked” once separation runs over the boattail at higher Mach numbers or the fins thicken the boundary layer. It says the longer model shows none of it, “probably because of the thicker boundary layer at the model base”. So the lip does something at those two speeds, and those are the very rows whose moment implies a negative share below. What it does there isn’t a normal force this model can carry.
- Seiff’s own limits. His embedded Newtonian flare method holds for “thin shock layers when the flow is not extensively separated” ([S62] p. 13). He notes that “a 90° ramp will invariably separate the flow” (p. 4). The Arcas lip’s face stands about 57° to the axis, behind a 15° expansion.
- The size, at most. Taken anyway as an upper bound (eq. 9, p. 12), Seiff’s method gives 0.044 per radian at Mach 1.5, falling to 0.014 at 4.63. Slender-body theory gives 0.178 at every speed. For a conical flare at one dynamic pressure, eq. 9 is . Here is the flow that has expanded through the boattail’s turn. Seiff measures from the local stream. Here it is taken to the axis, 56.8°, the looser of the two.
What the moment says, and what it can’t. For each fins-off row, there is a share at the lip’s station that would put HPR Sim’s center of pressure on the measured one. It runs from −0.256 ± 0.068 per radian (short model, Mach 1.5) to +0.229 ± 0.084 (long, Mach 3.96). It changes sign with Mach number and with the model’s length. Fitting one share:
| rows | share, per radian | per degree of freedom | from zero | from slender-body theory’s 0.178 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| all eleven | +0.021 ± 0.019 | 4.5 | 1.1 σ | 8.4 σ |
| the short model’s six | −0.016 ± 0.022 | 6.4 | 0.7 σ | 8.7 σ |
| the long model’s five | +0.108 ± 0.034 | 0.9 | 3.2 σ | 2.1 σ |
A per degree of freedom of 1 means rows agreeing within their own error bars. The short model’s 6.4 means its rows disagree among themselves. The long model’s 0.9 means its five agree, on a share of +0.108. That is five times Seiff’s bound at that speed and three standard errors above zero, yet still two below slender-body theory’s.
So the moment does not settle the lip, and the model doesn’t rest on it. Each row’s share blames the lip for every miss in the center of pressure. HPR Sim’s body alone reads 15% to 19% high on the long model at Mach 1.8 and 2.3. That shifts its center of pressure by far more than any lip. The short model’s own fit comes out negative, which no flare can produce. What the moment does say is that slender-body theory’s 0.178 at the base is too much. It is eight standard errors out on the short model, two on the long.
How it was checked. The committed designs, fins off, through a flight’s path, fitted at the tunnel’s plotted angles as Checking the shock-expansion method fits them. Slopes are on the body’s cross-section; centers of pressure are aft of the nose tip. The last column is where HPR Sim’s whole-body center of pressure would sit if the lip carried slender-body theory’s share instead of nothing. HPR Sim’s slopes here are fitted over the tunnel’s angles, so they carry body lift. The same bodies’ slopes at , in Checking the shock-expansion method’s table, are lower.
| model | Mach | measured, per rad | HPR Sim, as committed, per rad | vs measured | measured CP, calibers | HPR Sim’s CP, calibers | HPR Sim’s CP with the lip at slender-body theory’s share, calibers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| short | 1.5 | 2.192 | 3.017 | +37.7% | 1.00 | 2.46 | 3.33 |
| short | 1.8 | 2.613 | 3.290 | +25.9% | 2.36 | 3.06 | 3.84 |
| short | 2.3 | 3.078 | 3.598 | +16.9% | 3.56 | 3.69 | 4.37 |
| short | 2.96 | 3.284 | 3.838 | +16.9% | 3.21 | 3.75 | 4.43 |
| short | 3.96 | 3.884 | 3.946 | +1.6% | 4.88 | 4.57 | 5.16 |
| short | 4.63 | 4.149 | 3.950 | −4.8% | 5.05 | 4.72 | 5.30 |
| long | 1.8 | 3.159 | 3.770 | +19.4% | 4.61 | 4.31 | 5.19 |
| long | 2.3 | 3.525 | 4.071 | +15.5% | 5.04 | 4.89 | 5.68 |
| long | 2.96 | 3.868 | 4.400 | +13.7% | 5.33 | 4.64 | 5.47 |
| long | 3.96 | 4.455 | 4.428 | −0.6% | 6.19 | 5.20 | 5.98 |
| long | 4.63 | 4.615 | 4.425 | −4.1% | 6.40 | 5.96 | 6.65 |
The rows are in
validation/fixtures/aero/arcas-robin-lip.json,
written by cargo xtask aero, and a test holds this table to it cell by cell. With the lip left off entirely the same bodies read within 0.05 percentage points of these rows at ten of the eleven. The other row, Mach 1.5 on the short model, is within 0.5 percentage points. So the lip changes little but which parts of the body the
method may cover.
What it means for a rocket. Most rockets have no lip, and nothing changes for them. For one that does, the rule decides whether the whole body flies the method or slender-body theory. That is worth more than the lip itself. On the Arcas Robin’s short model at Mach 2.96 the body’s slope goes from 2.08 per radian to 3.84. The whole rocket’s slope goes from −16.3% against the tunnel to +3.7% (Normal force through Mach 1). The extra lift sits on the body, ahead of the fins, so the center of pressure moves forward by 0.22 calibers there. That is a little less stability margin, and a good deal more restoring force.
What it leaves out. The lip still has drag, and its own wake rule there (ADR-030). Nothing here measures a lip’s lift directly: the tunnel gives forces for the whole body, and the moment bounds the share rather than measuring it. The shelter used to be a switch in shape, of the family issue #87 tracks. It was a large one, because it decides whether the whole body flies the method. Since M1.8e10 the rise no longer switches it. On the test rocket at Mach 3 and 4°, lips rising 0.2499 and 0.2501 of the boattail’s drop now agree to a ten-thousandth. What is left is how far apart the models are at one shape. That is 33.0% of the normal force, and the center of pressure 1.77 calibers forward on slender-body theory. The difference is spread over the band the wake grades (above). A narrowing part behind the run is a boattail the method hasn’t covered, not a lip, and keeps slender-body theory’s share. A widening part behind a boattail that is too long for the wake stays a lip as well. It still takes the whole body off the method. The flow reaching its corner is the wake’s, which the march does not compute, so A flare through the method does not apply to it.
Where a flare’s march stops
In short: a flare is a transition that widens toward the tail. The method will march one, but only up to a limit, and that limit is not where the flare’s shock detaches. The limit is where the corner’s turn would take the flow to Mach 1. That is a property of HPR Sim’s method rather than of the air, and it depends on the whole body ahead of the flare. On the body measured below it falls short of a wedge’s detachment angle at Mach 1.5 and runs past it at Mach 2. Taking the tube away moves it past the wedge at both. From Mach 2.13 to Mach 5, the highest checked, the limit is neither: it is the 30° where the cone tables end. The flare’s own detachment angle is not known here: the wedge’s is a conservative stand-in for it. This section is the measurement. It is why the attachment test a flight uses had to be chosen rather than read off the march’s refusal (ADR-045). The next section, A flare through the method, covers what a flight does with a flare. The one after it, What a marched flare is worth, covers how close that comes to a measured flare. Neither this section’s edge nor the drawn-out reading past it is compared with a measurement.
Second-order shock-expansion turns every corner isentropically (no entropy rise, so no shock) with the Prandtl-Meyer angle ([SD56]) eq. 3. A flare is a compression corner, so the turn spends . Whether a shock stands attached to that corner is a separate question. It decides whether the march is modeling the real flow at all.
The table below sweeps the flare’s angle on a fixed body (a pointed 2.75° cone, five calibers of
tube, and a conical flare). The sweep bisects the steepest flare the march accepts, until the two angles are adjacent double-precision numbers. The two angles are NASA TN D-4865 model 2’s; the layout is not. That model is blunt-nosed and has no tube at all. The edge depends on what is
ahead of the flare, because that is what sets the flow reaching it. Angles are quoted to seven
decimals so the differences add up. The detachment column is taken at the free-stream Mach
number. The flow reaching the flare is a little faster, which would move the wedge’s angle by about
0.02°. Both tests are in
shock_expansion.rs:
a_flare_marches_to_the_isentropic_turn_not_to_detachment and
past_mach_2_13_the_flare_stops_where_the_cone_tables_do.
| free stream | the march accepts a flare to | a wedge’s shock detaches at | so the march is |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mach 1.5 | 11.9312175° | 12.1126689° | 0.1814514° short of it |
| Mach 1.547787962528 | 13.346819° | 13.346819° | exactly on it |
| Mach 2 | 26.4714031° | 22.9735318° | 3.4978713° past it |
| Mach 2.5 | 30° (the tables) | 29.7974° | 0.20° past it |
| Mach 3 | 30° (the tables) | 34.0734° | 4.07° short of it |
How much of that is the tube. A great deal, and it is the point rather than a caveat. What the march has left to spend is of the flow arriving at the corner, and the body ahead sets that flow. Keeping the same cone and flare and changing only the tube’s length:
| tube | the march accepts a flare to, Mach 1.5 | at Mach 2 |
|---|---|---|
| none (the report’s own layout) | 14.194333° | 28.509856° |
| 1 caliber | 12.821811° | 27.500078° |
| 2.5 calibers | 12.144405° | 26.815015° |
| 5 calibers (the table above) | 11.9312175° | 26.4714031° |
So the first row of the first table is a property of that five-caliber body, not of the method. The march stops there short of a wedge’s detachment. On the report’s own tube-less layout the Mach 1.5 edge is 14.19°, two degrees past the wedge’s limit. What does not depend on the body is the conclusion. The march’s edge is set by the corner’s isentropic turn. It lands on both sides of a wedge’s detachment angle depending on nothing more than how long the tube is.
The detachment angles are a wedge’s largest deflection ([R1135], through
wedge_detachment_angle_rad, which
lives with the blunt-tip cap because that cap uses the same relation). A cone’s shock holds to
steeper angles than a wedge’s, and a conical flare on a cylinder sits between the two. Only the rows where the
march stops below the wedge’s angle prove anything about attachment. Where the march runs past
it, the flare’s own limit may still be higher. Which boundary a flight uses is
the next section’s subject. The table shows that the march’s edge
lands on both sides of any such boundary. From HPR Sim returning an answer, you cannot tell that
the flow it modeled is the flow that would be there.
The last two rows of the first table are a different limit altogether. Each element’s tangent cone is looked up in NASA SP-3007 Table 2, whose slopes stop at 30°. The milestone that took them there from 24° is M1.8e11 (ADR-042). So from Mach 2.129702032593 to Mach 5, the highest checked, every Mach number gives the same edge. The reference data runs out before the flow does, and the last column then says nothing about attachment.
An 18.5° flare, the report’s angle, on the 2.75°-cone body above (not the next section’s flared rocket, whose numbers are close but not these). The march accepts it from Mach 1.721760; a wedge’s shock reaches 18.5° only at Mach 1.767575. Between the two, HPR Sim returns a number for a flare whose shock is, on that reckoning, detached. That is a bow shock standing ahead of the juncture with a pocket of subsonic flow behind it. An isentropic corner turn does not describe it. TN D-4865’s lowest run, Mach 1.50, is below both, and there the march refuses outright, as the report itself says it should. On a shorter body those two Mach numbers move, as the table above shows.
What it leaves out. These digits pin what this program does, not what air does. Every one of them comes from bisecting HPR Sim’s own refusal, and the 30° rows come from where a lookup table ends. A band of very shallow flares is not marched by the second-order law at all. The pressure behind such a corner moves away from its tangent cone’s rather than toward it. So its one element is reduced to the older generalized method. Since M1.8e19 that method is read rather than refused (A near-flat flare). Where that band sits is a property of the body ahead of the corner, and it moves by orders of magnitude. It is 0.773° to 0.823° at Mach 3 on this 2.5-caliber body. At the same Mach number on the flared rocket of A near-flat flare it is 0.0066° to 0.0081°. The whole edge is inviscid, too. From Mach 2.96 up TN D-4865 records the boundary layer separating ahead of the flare and reattaching on it. That moves the pressure rise downstream of where a tangent body puts it, and nothing here models that. And below Mach 1.5 nothing here was measured, although a flight uses the method from Mach 1.2.
A flare through the method
In short: since M1.8e17 a rocket with a flare flies the shock-expansion method rather than dropping to slender-body theory the moment one is drawn. The method marches through the flare’s corner while the shock there stays attached. A steeper flare is read as one of the same radii drawn out to the steepest attached angle. That keeps the answer from jumping as a shape or a speed crosses that boundary.
What qualifies is narrow. The flare must be conical, flush with the part ahead of it and not in a boattail’s wake. There must be nothing behind it that carries lift of its own. A boattail then a flare is a lip in a wake and keeps that rule; any other widening shape still ends the run. The decision record is ADR-047.
Why a test had to be picked. The march will return a number for a flare whose shock has long since detached (the section above measures exactly that). So “the method answered” is not evidence the flow it modeled is the flow that would be there. Something independent has to say where the corner’s shock detaches.
The test. A flare’s shock springs from a circular corner, not from a point apex. Where the
shock forms, the flow is two-dimensional. The body’s radius is the scale over which the
axisymmetric relief acts, and at the corner itself none of it has happened yet. So HPR Sim uses
NACA Report 1135’s ([R1135]) largest deflection behind an attached plane oblique shock (eq. 168 into
eq. 138). TN D-4865 ([J68]) p. 5 uses the same relation to hand a blunt tip’s cap over to this method. HPR Sim’s blunt-tip cap and this flare test call one function, wedge_detachment_angle_rad.
Two details matter.
- It is read at the flow reaching the corner, not at the free stream. The body ahead has
already changed the air, and which way depends on what that body is. The ogive nose and tube of
the tests’ flared rocket leave it a little slower than the free stream. The 2.75° cone
and tube of the section above leave it a little faster. The
march knows by how much
(
aft_flow). On the tests’ flared rocket a Mach 2.0 free stream reaches the corner at Mach 1.9998. The limit is then 22.9698° and not the free stream’s 22.9735°. The march is downstream-only, so the flare cannot change the flow arriving at its own corner. That lets the limit be worked out before the flare is drawn. - The cone tables cap it at 30°, because past that the march has no tangent cone to relax toward (tangent cone, ADR-042). That bounds the flare’s surface angle, while the shock bounds the turn at its corner, so each caps its own quantity. On a flare behind a cylinder, where the surface ahead is at 0°, the two are the same number. There the cap binds from Mach 2.5192034260 of the flow reaching the corner up; a faster flow buys nothing above that.
The shock’s bound is on the turn and not on the flare’s angle. So a flare put straight onto an ogive nose (no tube between them) is read differently from the same flare behind a tube. The corner there turns the flow by the flare’s angle less the nose’s base slope, so the limit bites at a steeper flare. The tests’ flared rocket has an ogive nose 0.25 m (0.82 ft) long on a 27 mm (1.1 in) radius. A 0.7 m (2.3 ft) tube of that radius follows. On this rocket the surface ahead is at 0° and the turn and the angle are one number:
| free stream | the flow reaching the corner | the corner is read to |
|---|---|---|
| Mach 1.5 | Mach 1.4999688 | 12.1118502° |
| Mach 2.0 | Mach 1.9997809 | 22.9697612° |
| Mach 2.5 | Mach 2.4989548 | 29.7863106° |
| Mach 3.0 | Mach 2.9965267 | 30° (the tables) |
| Mach 4.95 | Mach 4.8922987 | 30° (the tables) |
A cone’s shock holds to steeper angles than a wedge’s. So if a conical flare on a cylinder does sit between the two, this errs one way only. It stops reading some flares whose shock is in fact still attached, and reads none whose shock is not. Nothing here measures where a flare’s own boundary is. So that “if” is an argument, not a result, and erring low is not the same as erring safely. A flare just past the limit is not left unread; it is read as a different flare, and how different nothing here measures either.
Past the limit, the flare is drawn out. A flare steeper than the limit is read as a flare of the same radii stretched to the limiting angle, longer and shallower. It turns the same air through a corner the shock can hold. Its center of pressure is put back on the real flare, at the same fraction along it. Because the radii are kept and the angle is not, every flare steeper than the limit reads the same force, held at the limit. There is no bound on how far that goes, and it under-reads badly at the extreme. At Mach 2 a 75° flare reads 1.638 per radian against slender-body theory’s 2.010. The flare is an annular face a detached bow shock would stand in front of. The truth is above both. The method reads a steep flare as less stabilizing than it is. That is the safe direction for a stability margin and the wrong one for a load. This is the boattail rule turned around. A boattail past 16° reads the correlation of one of the same radii drawn out to 16° (ADR-040, A boattail faster than sound). The radii are what set how much air the flare turns, and they are never changed.
That makes the answer continuous, by construction rather than by tuning. At the
limit the drawn-out flare is the real flare, so the two readings are the same body. The test
nothing_jumps_where_the_flares_shock_detaches probes either side of the boundary. At Mach 2.0
(a row of the table, so the reading is that row’s and not an interpolation) the boundary is a flare
of 22.969761173077°:
| probe, in the flare’s angle | change in the normal-force slope (fraction) |
|---|---|
| ±1e-9° | 4.527e-11 |
| ±1e-7° | 4.527e-9 |
| ±1e-5° | 4.527e-7 |
A hundredfold smaller probe moves the answer a hundredfold less. So what the probe finds is a
slope and not a step: the reading is continuous across the boundary. Its slope is not, and
nothing here claims otherwise. A cap makes a kink, because below the boundary the flare’s angle
moves the body the march sees and above it only the radii do. Measured at the same place,
changes by −31.4% across the boundary on the whole rocket. On the flare’s
own share it changes by −141.6%, changing sign. The marched branch is not smooth in the angle either: the same
probe at 20°, away from any boundary, finds +3.5% and +41.1%
(the_cap_makes_a_kink_in_the_slope_even_though_the_reading_holds). Probing the
Mach number instead gives 3.622e-10, 3.622e-8 and 3.622e-6 for the same
three probes. This is at the 18.5° of TN D-4865’s model 2, whose shock holds on the tests’
flared rocket from Mach 1.767666917849. That half is taken on the table’s own rows rather than on a reading between them.
The crossing falls inside the Mach 1.75 to 1.80 interval. There the reading is a straight line
between rows and would look continuous whatever the two branches did.
What it is worth. The tests’ flared rocket has a 10° conical flare 0.3 m (0.98 ft) long behind that tube, opening to a 79.9 mm (3.1 in) radius. A 0.2 m (0.66 ft) tail tube follows the flare, and the rocket has four fins. Its reference is the largest diameter, 0.1598 m (0.524 ft), and the numbers are at a small angle of attack. The method reads less normal force than slender-body theory and puts the center of pressure forward of it. So this rocket now reads less stable rather than more:
| the method | slender-body theory | the method’s center of pressure | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mach 2.0 | 3.5371 per rad, at 7.365 calibers | 3.7153 per rad | 0.089 calibers forward |
| Mach 3.0 | 2.8899 per rad, at 7.015 calibers | 3.0815 per rad | 0.169 calibers forward |
| Mach 4.95 | 2.4880 per rad, at 6.681 calibers | 2.6431 per rad | 0.238 calibers forward |
So for a flare of this size the stability margin drops by a tenth to a quarter of a caliber,
growing with Mach number. a_flared_body_flies_the_method pins every figure in the table.
The old behavior is still selectable, for comparing:
BodyModel::with_supersonic_flare(SupersonicFlare::SlenderBody) in Rust, or
{"supersonic_flare": "slender_body"} in the body model’s JSON, reproduces every number from
before this milestone. Which to fly is not settled here. Neither column has been compared with
a measured flare. The method is the default because the rest of the body
already uses it faster than sound, not because it is known to be closer.
What it leaves out.
- The one measured flare is not this flare. What a marched flare is worth compares an 18.5° flare on a 2.75° cone, at six speeds, three of them with its boundary layer separated. The 10° flare in the table above is not that body. So the size of the difference it shows is still a change of model rather than a measured correction.
- The flare’s own detachment angle is still the wedge’s. A conical flare on a cylinder sits between a wedge and a cone, and nothing here measures where it is.
- Below about Mach 1.5552 the method has no reading for an 18.5° flare on the tests’ rocket at all. The corner’s isentropic turn runs out before its shock detaches (the section above). So the body’s table of the method’s shares starts there, and the join carries the reading up from slender-body theory’s over 0.3 Mach. That is continuous (a ±1e-9 probe at the join’s start moves the slope 8.5e-10 of itself). But it means a flare’s march is not used at all at the low end of what a flight uses.
- A near-flat flare is read by the older, rougher method. Between about 0.0004° and 0.059° on the tests’ rocket, depending on the Mach number, a flare’s single element is reduced. The pressure behind its corner sits just past its tangent cone’s while the gradient the tube delivers still pushes it away. So HPR Sim reads that element by the generalized shock-expansion method instead. The same reading applies on a nose (issue #81: the method’s limit near a sharp tip). Until M1.8e19: the near-flat flare the march refused such an element behind the nose. The whole body then fell back to slender-body theory at every Mach number, a switch worth −8.3% and 1.16 calibers. A near-flat flare below solves for where the region is at each Mach number and says what the change was worth. It also gives the one step that is left: +0.129% and 0.0051 calibers on this rocket. On a body with a short shoulder the step is up to +4.3% and 0.19 calibers.
- The march ends at the flare, and nothing behind it may carry lift. Anything behind the flare takes slender-body theory’s share, which for a tube is nothing. But a part that carries a share of its own, such as a small tail cone, takes the whole rocket off the method again. It does so at every Mach number, exactly as a second flare would. A flare followed by a plain tube and fins is the layout that flies. Where it does fly, the relaxation the method would give the tube behind the flare is left out. That reads a little less stable, not more.
- Everything here is inviscid. From Mach 2.96 up TN D-4865 records the boundary layer separating ahead of the juncture and reattaching on the flare. This moves the pressure rise downstream of where a tangent body puts it. Nothing here models that.
What a marched flare is worth
In short: A flare through the method says what HPR Sim does with a flare. It marches the shock-expansion method through the flare’s corner while the shock there stays attached. This section says how close that comes to a measured flare, which nothing had before M1.8e18, the milestone that did this work.
One flared body in the sources has its normal force and pitching moment printed. It is NASA TN D-4865’s model 2 ([J68]), a blunt 2.75° cone with an 18.5° flare. It was tested in the Langley Unitary Plan tunnel from Mach 1.50 to 4.63. Against it HPR Sim reads the normal-force slope −1.9% at Mach 1.90, +7.0% at 2.30 and +13.4% at 2.96. At 3.95 and 4.63 it reads +51.5% and +50.4%. The center of pressure is within 0.05 calibers through Mach 2.96 and within 0.088 at 3.95. The report’s own shadowgraphs show that flare’s boundary layer separated ahead of the juncture from Mach 2.96 up. The cost only shows in the two fastest rows, and why is not settled here. Below Mach 1.5289 there is no reading at all, and a flared body falls back to slender-body theory instead.
One body, one flare angle, six speeds, three of them separated: that is the whole of the evidence. It is not enough to call the model right, only enough to say where it is not obviously wrong. The decision record is ADR-048.
The body. Two things about it bear on the comparison. Its nose is blunter and more compound than model 1’s. So HPR Sim had to learn to hand a blunt tip’s cap over on a later piece of a nose. The report’s own drawing also does not quite close, so which printed numbers to keep had to be chosen. Neither is worth much (the closure is worth 0.76 points at most, measured three ways), but both are choices.
Fig. 3(b) (printed p. 91) draws model 2 in base diameters, = 0.583 ft (0.178 m). Its nose is not a sphere-cone. It is a 0.257 sphere from the tip, then a second arc of 0.429 whose center sits 0.135 below the axis. Then come the 2.75° cone and the 18.5° flare. Those three printed radii fix everything else. The two arcs are internally tangent, so their centers are 0.429 − 0.257 = 0.172 apart. With the 0.135 offset, that puts the second center 0.3635786 aft of the tip. Its tangent to the 2.75° cone then falls at 0.3429960 aft of the tip, matching the drawing’s printed 0.343 to four figures. That tangent is at diameter 0.5870, which misses its printed 0.586 by 0.001 of a diameter. A fourth printed dimension checks the same derivation from the other end. The 0.722 runs from the arc’s center to the flare juncture, and 0.3635786 + 0.722 = 1.08558 against 0.343 + 0.743 = 1.08600, a residual of 0.0004. HPR Sim draws that blend arc as a circular arc (the tangent ogive’s shape with its radius ratio solved for a 0.429 arc). The profile it builds misses the drawn circle by 8.3e−17 of a diameter.
The printed dimensions do not quite close, and the gap is the flare’s. Nose, cone and flare come to 0.3429960 + 0.743 + 0.523 = 1.6090, the printed length exactly. The cone closes on its own numbers too:
against the printed 0.657. The flare does not:
against a base that is 1.000 by definition, and 1.0084 with the nose taken from its three radii rather than from its printed 0.586. So either the flare is shorter than 0.523, or it is shallower than 18.5°.
HPR Sim keeps both half-angles, because they are the report’s text and not only its drawing. Its text reads “a blunted cone with a 2.75° half-angle and a flare afterbody having an 18.500° half-angle” (printed p. 8). It states them to three decimals, along with the nose, the length 1.609 and the base 1.000. These are the numbers the measured coefficients are divided by. What gives is the split of the length between the cone and the flare: a 0.7576199 cone and a 0.5083841 flare. That puts the juncture 0.0146 diameters aft of the printed one, at diameter 0.6598 against 0.657.
Two other closures are computed and published beside it, so the choice can be checked. Keeping the printed lengths and scaling the whole body to a 1.000 base moves the error by −0.12 to −0.17 points. Points here and below are percentage points of error. Keeping the printed lengths and the base, and giving up the flare’s stated angle instead (18.5° becomes 18.0864°), moves it by +0.06 to +0.64 points. Over all three the spread is 0.76 points or less in the slope and 0.0043 calibers or less in the center of pressure. Mach 1.50 is refused in every one of them, so nothing below turns on which closure is flown.
What it is compared with. Fig. 8(b) (printed p. 102) plots normal force , pitching moment and axial force against . The angles are 0°, 4°, 8° and 12°, for each of six Mach numbers. All three are coefficients, about the nose tip on the body’s own length. The circles are the report’s experiment: the surface pressures of its tables VII to XII integrated over the forebody (printed p. 12). No base pressure is in them. Every circle was read off the page’s 300-ppi scan by pixel analysis, the method written for model 1 in M1.8e7. The circles come out at −0.0039 to +0.0043 where they should read 0, which is what the plotting itself is worth. is not read, because HPR Sim’s supersonic drag is a separate model this comparison does not touch. HPR Sim’s slope and center of pressure are fitted the way that section fits model 1. A straight line is fitted through HPR Sim’s own at those same four angles, body lift included. So the two sides are the same quantity.
| Mach | measured , per radian | HPR Sim, per radian | HPR Sim’s error | measured CP, calibers aft of the tip | HPR Sim CP, calibers | HPR Sim − measured, calibers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | 1.650 | none | none | 0.810 | none | none |
| 1.9 | 1.800 | 1.766 | −1.9% | 0.888 | 0.934 | 0.046 |
| 2.3 | 1.667 | 1.784 | +7.0% | 0.921 | 0.926 | 0.005 |
| 2.96 | 1.594 | 1.807 | +13.4% | 0.948 | 0.935 | −0.013 |
| 3.95 | 1.270 | 1.923 | +51.5% | 1.046 | 0.958 | −0.088 |
| 4.63 | 1.303 | 1.960 | +50.4% | 0.998 | 0.975 | −0.023 |
A positive number in the last column means HPR Sim puts the center of pressure further aft than the tunnel did. That reads as more stable than the rocket is. A negative one reads as less stable. The half-caliber the rest of this page uses as a target is the scale to hold them against.
The flare is most of what is being compared. Its own share of the body’s slope is 52.1% at Mach 1.90 and 60.8% at 4.63, and never below 51.5% (at Mach 2.30) in between. That share acts 1.382 to 1.390 calibers aft of the tip, on the flare itself, which runs from 1.101 to 1.609. So this is a test of the flare and not of a body that happens to have one.
How much of the miss is the flare’s. The same report, the same tunnel, the same figure and the same reading and fit also give model 1, a sphere-cone with no flare. Blunt tips already checks that body. Putting the two side by side separates what the flare costs from what the rest of the body costs:
| Mach | HPR Sim’s error, model 1 (no flare) | HPR Sim’s error, model 2 (flared) | the flare adds | the report’s own method, model 1 | the report’s own method, model 2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | −1.2% | none | none | −3.3% | +28.6% |
| 1.9 | +0.0% | −1.9% | −1.9 points | +2.0% | +24.8% |
| 2.3 | +7.5% | +7.0% | −0.5 points | +8.5% | +31.6% |
| 2.96 | +12.5% | +13.4% | +0.9 points | +5.2% | +12.1% |
| 3.95 | +29.7% | +51.5% | +21.7 points | +11.3% | +28.8% |
| 4.63 | +32.1% | +50.4% | +18.3 points | +13.6% | +20.3% |
They are not one body with and without a flare. Model 1 is an 11.5° cone on a 0.175-diameter nose radius, 1.755 diameters long. Model 2 is a 2.75° cone on a 0.257-diameter one, 1.609 long. So the flare adds column bounds what the flare costs rather than measuring it. Read it as a signed difference and nothing more: it is not a verdict on which body HPR Sim reads better. At Mach 1.90 the unflared model 1 is almost exact (+0.011%), while the flared one is 1.9% low. So in size of error the flare is the worse row, not the better one.
Taken that way, the column still says something clear. Through Mach 2.96 the flare moves the error by −1.9 to +0.9 points. That is less than the rest of the body already misses by. At Mach 3.95 and 4.63 the flare moves it by 21.7 and 18.3 points, an order of magnitude more. There the measured itself falls away (from 1.594 at Mach 2.96 to 1.270 at 3.95). By contrast, both attached-flow methods on the figure, the report’s own and HPR Sim’s, stay between 1.57 and 1.96.
The obvious explanation is the flow. From Mach 2.96 the report’s shadowgraphs show the laminar boundary layer separating ahead of the juncture and reattaching behind it (printed p. 10). Nothing in an attached-flow method describes that. The report blames the separated flow for its own method’s disagreement with the measured pressures at the high Mach numbers (printed p. 10). It blames the same flow for its over-prediction of axial force (printed p. 12). It says nothing about what separation does to the normal force or the pitching moment. Nor does its method carry a separation signature on this body. It reads +24.8% at Mach 1.90 and +31.6% at 2.30, both attached rows, against +12.1%, +28.8% and +20.3% at the three separated ones. The report’s method is uniformly high on model 2 and near the tunnel on model 1. This is a large offset this milestone has not explained. So read the separation as consistent with the two fast rows rather than measured by them. Nothing here settles why separation costs 0.9 points at Mach 2.96, where the report says it has already begun, or twenty times that at 3.95.
Where the method has no reading. At Mach 1.50 HPR Sim refuses model 2 outright. The refusal is worth following, because it is not the rule the section above describes. Two limits decide what the march does with a flare’s corner. One is the steepest surface angle whose shock stays attached there, which is the rule that section sets. The other is the steepest the march itself can turn the flow through. Both are in the table below as surface angles of the flare, so they can be read against its 18.5° and against each other:
| Mach | the flow reaching the corner | the steepest angle its shock holds | the steepest the march takes | the flare is read |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | Mach 1.5241 | 15.4885° | 15.3647° | drawn out, then refused |
| 1.9 | Mach 1.9354 | 24.5773° | 27.3345° | as drawn |
| 2.3 | Mach 2.3072 | 30.0000° | ≥ 30° (the tables) | as drawn |
| 2.96 | Mach 2.8966 | 30.0000° | ≥ 30° (the tables) | as drawn |
| 3.95 | Mach 3.6913 | 30.0000° | ≥ 30° (the tables) | as drawn |
| 4.63 | Mach 4.1636 | 30.0000° | ≥ 30° (the tables) | as drawn |
The turn the corner makes is each of those angles less the 2.75° of the cone ahead. From
Mach 2.3 up the third column is clipped at the cone tables’ 30° (past that an element has no
tangent cone to relax toward). The search behind the fourth column
stops at the same place. Neither is a measured edge there, and the fourth says so rather than
printing the cap as though it were one. At Mach 1.50 the flare is steeper than the 15.4885° its
corner’s shock holds, so ADR-047’s rule draws it out to 15.4885°. The march then refuses
that body too, because the steepest flare it can march there is 15.3647°, a tenth of a degree
shallower. The two limits are different things. One is where the corner’s shock detaches, the other
where the corner’s isentropic turn runs out (Where a flare’s march
stops, ADR-045). Which is the tighter one changes with
speed. Below where they cross, drawing a flare out to the shock’s limit lands past what the march
can do. Swept every 0.005 Mach from 1.05 to 4.63, the reading turns on exactly once. Bisecting that
one crossing to f64 resolution puts HPR Sim’s first reading of model 2 at Mach 1.5288696.
Just below it the two limits agree to five parts in 1e14, both 16.2844275°, so the reading begins
exactly where they cross. (The fixture keeps the whole f64. Seven figures are printed because those
are what the three operating systems CI runs agree on. Each regenerates the bisection to within a
part in 1e12 of the others.) That is a different number from the Mach 1.5552
the section above quotes for the same 18.5° flare, and it should
differ. The body ahead of the corner is different, so the flow it delivers there is different, and
the crossing moves with that flow. Below that a flared body takes slender-body
theory instead, carried up over 0.3 Mach by the
join. The join is continuous, but it means the method is not used at
the low end of what a flight flies. The report says the same about its own method: “at , the shock wave produced by the flare is not theoretically attached”
(printed p. 10). Its method reads +28.6% there against −3.3% on model 1.
The rows above are in
validation/fixtures/aero/marched-flare.json,
written by cargo xtask aero; the readings in
tn-d-4865-flared-cone.json,
with how each circle was read. A test holds every table here to the fixture, cell by cell. The
reading is HPR Sim’s own rule and not a second copy of it. hpr-design has no spherical-cap nose,
so model 2 cannot be flown through a Rocket. The test the_flare_is_read_as_the_model_reads_it
pins the fixture’s reading against the model’s own shares, share by share, to a part in 1e12. It runs on another flared body, one the design route can express, at angles the corner’s shock holds and at angles it does not. That pins the arithmetic, not the physics: an error in the
rule itself would be in both and pass.
What it leaves out.
- Three of the six rows are a separated flare. From Mach 2.96 the report’s shadowgraphs show the boundary layer separating ahead of the juncture. Nothing in HPR Sim models that. The +51.5% and +50.4% at Mach 3.95 and 4.63 are what those rows cost on this body. The report’s own words make that consistent with separation rather than caused by it, since it never says what separation does to the normal force. No source here says how a separated flare scales with the flare’s angle, its length or the boundary layer’s thickness. So those two numbers do not transfer to another flare.
- One body and one flare angle. 18.5°, on a 2.75° cone, at six speeds. Nothing here measures a shallow flare, a steep one, a flare behind a cylinder rather than a cone, or a flare on a pointed nose. A reader with a different flare has no measured error to apply. What this section supports is that HPR Sim’s flare is not obviously wrong where the flow stays attached. It does not support calling it good to 7% on some other body.
- The drawn-out reading past the limit is measured against nothing at all. The one row where it would have applied is the row the march then refused. So the rule above the corner’s limit is still a construction chosen for continuity.
- The measurement is the forebody only. Its and are integrated surface pressures with no base term, which is what HPR Sim’s body model computes too. It also means the tunnel’s own balance never weighed this body. A reading error of about 0.004 in sits under every circle.
- is not compared. The same figure plots axial force, and the report notes its own method reads it high where the flare separates. HPR Sim’s supersonic drag is a different model with its own checks; this milestone did not touch it.
- The drawing is 1% inconsistent and one closure had to be chosen. The spread over the three closures is small (0.76 points, 0.0043 calibers), and the flare’s own angle is inside it. It is the drawing’s disagreement with itself, not an error bar on the measurement.
- No target was set, and none is met or missed here. M1.8e18 asked what a marched flare is worth, not that it reach a number. The tables above are the answer.
A near-flat flare
In short: a very shallow flare turns the flow so little that the second-order shock-expansion method’s own pressure curve has nothing left to describe. The march then falls back on the older generalized method for that one element. Until M1.8e19: the near-flat flare HPR Sim refused to read such an element at all behind the nose. That took a rocket with a flare of about a third of a millimeter’s rise off the method entirely. It now reads it. This section says which flares those are, what the change was worth, and the one small step that is left. The two angles that bound them are solved from two equations about the corner’s own flow, not found by bisecting the model’s refusal.
That body is a pointed 2.75° cone and five calibers of tube, whose radius is nearly four times as large.
What a flare that small does to the method. The march is the walk along the tangent body’s straight elements, from the nose tip aft, that the method makes. It fixes the pressure just behind each corner from the Prandtl-Meyer turn there. It then lets the pressure relax along the element toward the pressure on that element’s tangent cone, as
(NACA TN 3527 eqs. 8 and 9), where is the distance back from the corner. The same exponent written as a rate per meter is the of What a crossing is, and what it costs. The symbols are the method’s own, listed under Bodies faster than sound. is an element’s angle to the axis, the pressure over the free stream’s and distance along the surface. is the radius at the corner, a stream tube’s widening and . Below, is the flare’s own turn through its corner. Subscript 1 is the state the body ahead delivers, and 2 the state just behind the corner.
That is a curve that starts at and walks one way, toward . It can only do that if the gradient just behind the corner points at . The report keeps the form only for (p. 13). At , it says, “all equations reduce to those given by the generalized shock-expansion method”, whose pressure is constant along the element.
On a near-flat flare the two disagree. The flow arrives at the flare along a long tube. There the pressure is still climbing back toward the free stream’s after the nose let it down. It is below the free stream and rising. The flare’s corner compresses it a little. Turn far enough and the pressure lands well above the tiny cone’s, and the gradient behind the corner turns downward with it. So everything agrees and the method runs. Turn less and the pressure stays below the cone’s, still rising toward it, so again everything agrees. In between there is a band where the compression has already carried the pressure just past its cone’s value. There the tube’s own climb still pushes it further away. It has to rise, overshoot and come back, and one exponential cannot rise and fall. So is negative there. The element is reduced to the generalized method (issue #81: the method’s limit near a sharp tip is the same reading on a nose).
The region’s two edges are solved from the corner, not searched for. Each of the two quantities whose signs must agree is a smooth function of the flare’s turn. On every corner state checked here each has a single zero. So the signs disagree on the open interval between those two zeros and nowhere else:
| the turn | what is zero there | what it means |
|---|---|---|
| the crossing | the compression lands the pressure exactly on its tangent cone’s, and has a pole | |
| the balance | the corner’s own compression exactly cancels the climb the tube delivers, and is zero |
Single zero is not a promise, and a corner that breaks it exists. On a 25° cone with 20 mm (0.79 in) of tube behind it at Mach 7, the pressure meets its tangent cone’s three times. The crossings
are at about 0.91°, 7.3° and 24°. A flare there is reduced from 0.91° to 3.88° and again from
7.3° to 24°. flare_reduction_turns_rad sweeps the widening turns at a hundred stations before it
brackets. So it reports that corner rather than handing back whichever of the three roots it
walked to (a_corner_whose_gap_has_three_zeros_is_refused_rather_than_guessed_at). A pair of roots
inside one station would still slip through and be reported as one band when they are two.
Which of the two is the shallower is not fixed either. On this rocket the crossing is below the balance from Mach 1.5 up, and below that the order swaps.
Both are properties of the flow the body hands to the corner. Those are its Mach number, its
pressure, the gradient it carries, the radius there, the angle ahead and the free stream it was
read in. flare_reduction_turns_rad takes exactly that and nothing else. The balance is TN 3527’s
eq. 4 set to zero and rearranged,
which iterates on itself. The crossing is : an isentropic turn on one side, a cone solution on the other. It is bracketed over the turns a widening corner can make at all. The range runs from a surface lying along the axis up to the isentropic turn running out or the cone tables’ 30°, whichever comes first. The root is then found by false position from the turn that would bring the pressure back to the free stream’s.
On the tests’ flared rocket they are these:
| Mach | crossing | balance | a flare between them rises, over 0.3 m (0.98 ft), by |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.00 | 0.000403337° | 0.000454464° | 2.1 to 2.4 µm |
| 2.20 | 0.000901825° | 0.001041403° | 4.7 to 5.5 µm |
| 3.00 | 0.006619249° | 0.008121929° | 35 to 43 µm |
| 4.00 | 0.023088893° | 0.029499725° | 0.12 to 0.15 mm (0.0047 to 0.0059 in) |
| 4.70 | 0.038161270° | 0.049811274° | 0.20 to 0.26 mm (0.0079 to 0.010 in) |
| 5.00 | 0.044649637° | 0.058820517° | 0.23 to 0.31 mm (0.0091 to 0.012 in) |
The test the_turns_a_reduced_element_lies_between_come_from_the_corners_own_state, in
shock_expansion.rs,
runs at eight Mach numbers. It checks that an angle a millionth either side of each edge falls on
the right side of the march’s own reduction. It also checks that the midpoint between the edges is
reduced. That is a spot check at each edge, not an exhaustive sweep of the angles in between.
These are the numbers that issue #117: the near-flat band the march used to refuse reported after bisecting the model’s own refusal. The band it quoted, 0.03816127° to 0.05882052°, is the crossing at Mach 4.70 and the balance at Mach 5. The 0.00090182° it quoted is the crossing at Mach 2.20. What the table shows and that band hides is that the region is not one interval in the angle. It moves with the Mach number, so a 0.04° flare is reduced at Mach 4.70 and marched at Mach 2.
Divided by how fast the gap closes with the turn, that is about 2e-10°. That is close to the 2.6e-10° the band’s lower edge was seen to spread over on the three operating systems CI runs. So that spread was the cone’s and not the bisection’s.
Neither residual is promised to be zero, and on a body whose cone flow is harder it is
larger. A residual of 4e-9 of the free stream’s pressure has been seen on a fatter body at Mach
2.6. So flare_reduction_turns_rad returns both of them beside the turns, and a caller who needs
the digits should read them.
What HPR Sim does now, and what changed. A reduced element is read by the generalized method wherever it has a tangent cone of its own. That means constant pressure and loading along it, which is what the report says the equations become. Before M1.8e19 that reading was allowed only on the nose, and anywhere behind it the march refused. HPR Sim builds a body’s table of the method’s shares downward from Mach 5 and needs the whole 0.3 Mach of the join inside it. So one refused row near the top took the table away and dropped the whole body to slender-body theory at every speed. Two switches came of that, and both are gone:
| drawing this | was worth | is worth |
|---|---|---|
| a flare of 0.05882052°, the band’s steep edge, at Mach 3 and 4° | −8.30% of the normal force and 1.16 calibers | nothing |
| a flare of 0.00090182°, which lifted the table’s start from Mach 1.2 to Mach 2.2, at Mach 2 and 4° | −4.62% and 0.75 calibers | nothing |
The middle column’s sizes are still measured, because they are the size of the fallback the
model used to drop to. a_near_flat_flare_marches_every_row_and_the_fallback_is_still_measured,
in model.rs, reads
the same rocket on SupersonicFlare::SlenderBody and finds them again. The table’s start is now
Mach 1.2 at fifteen flare angles from 0° to 1°. These include 0.00024°, 0.00025° and 0.0003°,
three angles a hair apart that used to give three different answers.
What is left is the crossing, and here is how big it is. At the crossing itself has a
pole. That leaves a step, not in the pressure, which rides through because the gap it multiplies is
zero there, but in the loading. On the side the method still owns, runs to as
the turn approaches the crossing. So the element sheds its corner’s loading onto its tangent
cone’s within its own length. On the reduced side it holds the corner’s. The two differ, so the
reading steps. The step is measured on the whole rocket at 4°, either side of that Mach number’s
own crossing, with a ±1e-9° probe. a_near_flat_flare_reads_through_and_leaves_only_the_corners_crossing,
in model.rs,
does the measuring (Mach 4.95 rather than 5 because the body’s normal force stops at Mach 5):
| Mach | at a flare of | normal force | center of pressure |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.00 | 0.000403337° | +0.00032% | −0.0000016 calibers |
| 3.00 | 0.006619249° | +0.011% | +0.00018 calibers |
| 4.00 | 0.023088893° | +0.055% | +0.0017 calibers |
| 4.95 | 0.043584193° | +0.129% | +0.0051 calibers |
A step, not a slope, except on the first row. Widening the probe a hundredfold, to ±1e-7°, leaves the figure where it is at Mach 3, 4 and 4.95. That is what says it is a step rather than the reading’s ordinary movement. At Mach 2 it does not. +0.00032% is already about what the reading itself moves over a ±1e-7° probe there. So that row is an upper bound on the step, not a measurement of one.
Those four numbers are one rocket, and they are not a bound. The step is the loading’s gap at
the pole, so it grows with the length of the element that holds it. Where the region sits
depends on the body ahead. Read on the body alone at Mach 5, either side of that body’s own
crossing (what_the_crossing_costs_is_the_loading_gap_times_the_element_that_holds_it, in
shock_expansion.rs):
| the body | its crossing | steps by | its center of pressure by |
|---|---|---|---|
| the tests’ rocket’s body: ogive nose, 0.7 m (2.3 ft) tube, 0.3 m (0.98 ft) flare | 0.044650° | +0.40% | 0.064 calibers |
| the same, with a 2 m (6.6 ft) flare | 0.044650° | +2.61% | 0.761 calibers |
| the same, with the tube cut to 0.1 m (0.33 ft) | 1.387993° | +4.34% | 0.186 calibers |
| a 10° cone and a 0.3 m (0.98 ft) tube, 0.3 m (0.98 ft) flare | 0.695840° | +3.82% | 0.251 calibers |
Read the third and fourth rows twice. With a short shoulder the region is not near-flat at all: it sits between 0.7° and 4.6°, which is where real flares live.
But there is a bound, and it is exact: you can work out your own. At the crossing the two sides take the two constants the method relaxes between. The side it still owns sheds the corner’s loading onto its tangent cone’s at once, . The reduced side holds the corner’s, . Along a conical flare both are constant, so eq. 19’s integrates a constant and the whole step is
for a flare of length between those radii. flare_reduction_turns_rad returns beside
the turns, as crossing_loading_gap_per_rad. On the tests’ rocket’s body at Mach 5 that gap is
6.116195e-4 per radian. The formula reproduces the measured step to a part in 1e5 at flare
lengths of 0.3, 1, 2 and 5 m (16 ft). So the four rows above are an illustration of that formula,
not the claim. The claim is the formula, and it holds for any conical flare.
The worst of the whole-rocket rows is a 64th of the switch it replaced in the force, and a 227th in the center of pressure. The step in that row is at Mach 4.95, and the switch was measured at Mach 3. So that compares sizes, not the same flight condition. The body-alone numbers above are not that small.
And the same pole is crossed in the Mach number. At a fixed flare angle the corner’s crossing sweeps past it as the speed changes. The table’s rows are 0.05 Mach apart, so a flight reads it as a step between two neighboring rows. On the short-shouldered body above with a 1° flare, the rows from Mach 2.90 to 2.95 step −2.77% and 0.14 calibers. The neighboring rows move by a fifth of that or less. Before M1.8e19: the near-flat flare those lower rows were refused, so the table began above them and the join covered the pole. The pole is now inside the table. That is the milestone’s trade. Two switches in shape were removed, and one pole was exposed in both shape and speed. On a body whose reduced rows sit at the bottom of its table, what is given up is a continuous join. What is bought is that an arbitrarily small change of shape no longer moves the whole body between two models.
It is not a new question, though. It is the loading through a tangent-cone crossing, which is what a crossing costs inside a segment. It is open as issue #108: the loading through a crossing. This part of it, at Mach 2.90 to 2.95, is inside the operating envelope’s extended band. So it is part of M1.14h: the extended band. Only #108’s part above Mach 4 is deferred (ADR-143). The region’s other edge, the balance, has no step at all. There is zero, so the exponential form and the generalized method are the same reading, and the two branches meet.
What it leaves out.
- A cylinder’s and a boattail’s reduced elements are still refused, and still take the whole body off the method. Not because a flare relaxes toward something and they do not. A reduced element does not relax at all, on a flare exactly as on a cylinder. It holds the pressure and the loading behind its corner for its whole length. What differs is what it is read against. A widening element’s and are a real cone’s at the flow’s own Mach number. So the two readings either side of the region are two readings of one picture, and they meet at the balance. A cylinder’s is identically zero and its is the free stream’s, so there is no cone there to meet. A boattail’s is footnote 8’s constant (a stand-in, not a solution of that element’s own flow). Nothing here measures what that would be worth, so the refusal stands: issue #123: a cylinder’s or a boattail’s reduced element. How near is it? An ogive nose on a tube marches every row from Mach 1.2 to Mach 5 with nothing reduced. The nose is 0.25 m (0.82 ft) on a 27 mm (1.1 in) radius. The tubes are 0.7 m (2.3 ft), 3 m (9.8 ft) and 6 m (20 ft). So it is not something a plain rocket walks into. What does hit it is TN D-4865’s own Newtonian start on the Arcas Robin’s nose from Mach 3.96. That is a reason HPR Sim does not use that start (The two starts).
- The generalized method is the older, rougher one. Reading an element with it is a real choice, not a formality, and TN 3527 does not say it is what it would have done. What is checked is that the choice joins the second-order reading continuously at the balance and makes the reading smooth in the flare’s angle. Whether it is closer to a measured flare is not checked. No measured flare in this band exists.
- Below about a millionth of a radian the flare is not drawn at all. Corners turning by less than that are merged into the element ahead of them, because two tangents that nearly coincide meet at an ill-conditioned point. That covers every flare shallower than about 0.00006°, which at the bottom of the table’s range swallows both turns. At Mach 1.2 the crossing is 0.00000023° and the balance 0.00000018°. So there is no corner there to reduce and nothing the reading could switch on.
- Only the flare’s own element was measured. The two turns are solved for a corner behind a body. Where a body has several corners that could be reduced at once, nothing here says how their readings combine. Nor does anything here say whether the generalized reading or the slender-body fallback it replaced was the nearer of the two to the air. What is claimed is that one of them moves smoothly with the shape and the other jumps.
- There is no rule of thumb for “is my flare one of these?”. The region belongs to the corner,
so the only way to ask is to run the model. Call
ShockExpansionBody::aft_flowon the body ahead of the flare, at the Mach number you care about, thenflare_reduction_turns_radon what it returns.
A step in radius
In short: a step is a joint where one part’s radius does not match the next one’s, so the rocket’s outline jumps rather than bending. Examples are a 54 mm (2.1 in) tube butted straight onto a 75 mm (3.0 in) one, and a coupler standing proud of the airframe. That stops HPR Sim’s second-order shock-expansion method, the march, which walks a chain of straight elements, the tangent body, from the nose tip aft. The march needs an outline without a jump in it. HPR Sim drops the whole body to slender-body theory, at every speed. A rocket with a step reads as though the method did not exist. M1.8e15 measured what that costs and tried the obvious fix; the fix was worse, so the behavior is unchanged and the cost is published instead. The decision record is ADR-049. The work left over is issue #87: a step takes the whole body off the method, open and not on the roadmap. Nothing measures a stepped body faster than sound, so neither the present reading nor any replacement has a reference.
What it costs. These numbers are for the tests’ straight rocket at Mach 3 and 4°. Its nose is a tangent ogive 0.25 m (0.82 ft) long. Three tubes of 0.7, 0.05 and 0.3 m (0.98 ft) follow, all 27 mm (1.1 in) in radius. The reference diameter is pinned at 54 mm (2.1 in) so that every row is divided by the same area. With no step it reads , its center of pressure 16.9492 calibers aft of the nose tip. Each row is the change from that. Down means the body narrows from that joint aft, up that it widens:
| the step and its joint | normal force | center of pressure, calibers |
|---|---|---|
| down 2.8e−11 m, the first size past the threshold, at any joint | −8.65% | +1.0285 |
| down 1 mm (0.039 in), at the nose’s joint | −10.62% | +1.1938 |
| down 1 mm (0.039 in), at the last joint | −10.29% | +0.9949 |
| down 2 mm (0.079 in), at the nose’s joint | −12.55% | +1.3593 |
| down 2 mm (0.079 in), at the last joint | −11.89% | +0.9597 |
| up 2.8e−11 m, at any joint | −8.65% | +1.0285 |
| up 1 mm (0.039 in), at the nose’s joint | −6.72% | +0.8674 |
| up 1 mm (0.039 in), at the last joint | −7.05% | +1.0644 |
| up 2 mm (0.079 in), at the nose’s joint | −4.75% | +0.7064 |
| up 2 mm (0.079 in), at the last joint | −5.41% | +1.0987 |
At the threshold the shape is flush to a part in a billion either way. So the whole difference there is the method itself, the same wherever the step sits and whichever way it goes. Past that the shape starts to matter, and the two directions part. A step down takes area off the body and costs more. A step up adds area that carries slender-body normal force of its own and costs
less. The center of pressure moves aft in every row, so a rocket that trips this reads more
stable than the same rocket drawn flush. That extra margin is more likely optimistic than real. The model it falls back to reads 15% to 50% below the wind tunnel on the Arcas Robin’s body faster than sound. See The body faster than sound in a flight. If you
can draw the joint as a short transition instead of a butt joint, the body keeps the method. HPR Sim’s own radius_step warning (the design model’s checks) tells you a design has tripped this.
a_step_takes_the_whole_body_off_the_method pins every figure in this section and the flush
rocket’s own readings with it; Checking a claim says how to run a named
test.
Where the threshold is. It is a pair, not one number, and which of the two binds depends on the joint:
| the joint | what binds | on the tests’ bodies |
|---|---|---|
| radius changes, slope does not (tube to tube), either direction | the tangent body merges two elements whose radii agree to a billionth of the radius | 1e−9 × 27 mm = 2.7e−11 m |
| slope changes too (a step up at a boattail’s fore end) | the elements’ corners have to stay in order along the body | 1e−12 × 1.3 m × 0.1 = 1.3e−13 m |
Both are bisected. The second is 208× finer. It depends on the body’s length and the change of slope rather than on its radius. So it is not a property of the step at all. It bites on the commonest high-power shape. Take the tests’ finned rocket with a boattail whose fore radius is 27.0000000000002 mm (1.062992125984 in) rather than 27 mm (1.1 in). The whole body loses the method, worth −11.34% and 1.0951 calibers, larger than the tube-to-tube switch above.
Neither number is a judgment about steps. They are the widths of the rounding the tangent body can absorb. Every step anyone could build or draw is far past both, so a step always takes the body off the method. (A third, much looser test is what actually refuses every step bigger than a millionth of the fore area, or 13.5 nm of radius here. That test, the run’s own coverage gate, asks how much of the body the method can cover. It gives the same reading, and the test pins which of the two owns which range.)
What a fix has to handle. The obvious fix is to stop the march at the step. The body ahead of it would keep the method, the way the run already ends at a flare. That was built and measured, and it failed three ways. The numbers in this list were taken on that prototype, which was not kept. Unlike the tables above, no committed test reproduces them. ADR-049 records how each was measured and where the prototype lives.
- What is behind the step. ADR-034, the decision that the method covers a body or nothing, rejected mixing the two models on a measured case. A step’s remainder is supposed to be a plain tube, but “the run stopped at a step” does not make it one. With a boattail behind the step, the mixture’s center of pressure lands at 16.7209 calibers, forward of both pure models. These are the method’s 16.7286 and slender-body theory’s 17.8237. A reading outside the envelope of both models it is made of is the pathology ADR-034 measured.
- It does not close the band it was meant to close. The prototype removes the step’s switch at a tube-to-tube joint. At a joint whose slope changes, it is the corner ordering that refuses the body, at 1.3e−13 m. So a boattailed rocket still loses the method, worth −11.34% and 1.0951 calibers. The commonest shape it was supposed to help is the one it does not.
- Which shape stopped the run, not whether the joint was flush. The prototype keyed off the joint. Any reason the run closed (a non-conical flare, a lip out of its wake) kept the forebody marched. That happened as soon as the closing element’s fore radius was a picometer off. That is a new jump of +7.2% and 0.69 calibers where today the reading is continuous. That one is a property of how the prototype was built rather than of the idea. A fix keyed off the shape would not have it. It is listed here because it is what a fix has to get right, not as evidence the idea cannot work.
What it leaves out.
- The step’s own force is slender-body theory’s, at any speed. at the joint, the limit of a transition whose length goes to zero. [B67] p. 18 assumes no discontinuities, so this goes beyond its source. There is no compressibility term. A forward-facing step at supersonic speed stands a detached shock with a separated pocket ahead of it; none of that is modeled.
- No source gives a stepped body’s normal force faster than sound. MIL-HDBK-762 treats a rearward-facing step only as base drag, TN 3527 ([SD56]) needs a continuous profile, and nothing else pinned here covers one. So “take the whole body off the method” is not known to be right either. It is the reading that does not mix two models, which is the only argument for it.
- One body, one placement sweep. Three joints on one rocket at one Mach number and one angle, and the large steps up carry a moving reference diameter with them.
Blunt tips
What this covers: the body faster than sound when the nose’s tip is blunt or vertical. Examples are power-series noses with below 1, Haack series (the von Kármán and L-V Haack) and elliptical noses. Their profile leaves the tip at 90°.
Against the smooth secant ogive fitted to the same nose the body reads lower at every Mach number. It is closer to the tunnel at nine of the eleven rows, by 0.7 to 5.8 points. Past Mach 4 it crosses into under-prediction and lands 0.6 to 1.5 points further out.
Why a cap. The shock-expansion method replaces the nose by straight elements, short cones and frustums each tangent to the profile. It starts at a pointed tip, where the air flows as it does over a cone. A vertical tip has no such cone: the shock stands off the nose, and the air just behind it is slower than sound. Jackson, Sawyer and Smith ([J68]) handled blunt noses by giving the tip’s cap Newtonian pressures. They handed over to the method where the flow behind the cap is fast again, the handover. HPR Sim does the same.
The cap. Newtonian theory takes the pressure from the angle between the surface and the
wind: ([J68] eq. 1, p. 5). is the pressure coefficient at the
stagnation point, the tip, where the air comes to rest behind a normal shock. It follows from the pitot pressure a probe would read there, the Rayleigh pitot formula ([R1135] eq. 100). At a small angle of
attack the windward side meets the wind a little more steeply. So the cap carries of loading in the method’s terms. A hemisphere then carries its Newtonian drag turned into the body’s axes, , as it must (test a_hemisphere_carries_its_drag_turned).
The handover. The method takes over where the surface’s slope falls to the largest angle a wedge can turn the flow through with its shock attached. That angle is 12.1° at Mach 1.5 and 22.97° at Mach 2 ([R1135] eqs. 138 and 168). The report chose this point “simply because it gave the best agreement with the available data in the low supersonic-speed range” ([J68] p. 5). HPR Sim caps the handover at 24°, which the wedge’s angle passes at Mach 2.06. The cap is there because the method needs the normal-force slope of a cone tangent to the body. TN 3527’s chart of that slope stopped at 24° ([SD56] Fig. 2). Those slopes now reach 30° (ADR-042) and the cap has not followed, because the method’s march does not carry it that far. What the cap is worth measures what moving it would buy and what it would cost.
How much of the nose the cap covers depends strongly on speed. Where it ends, as a share of the nose’s length and of its base radius:
| nose | Mach 1.25 | Mach 1.5 | Mach 2 | Mach 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| arcas robin, the committed nose | 59.1% / 0.72 | 5.8% / 0.16 | 0.9% / 0.05 | 0.8% / 0.05 |
| von Karman, five calibers | 47.8% / 0.69 | 4.1% / 0.12 | 0.3% / 0.02 | 0.2% / 0.01 |
| power series n = 0.5, five calibers | 29.2% / 0.54 | 5.4% / 0.23 | 1.4% / 0.12 | 1.3% / 0.11 |
| elliptical, two calibers | 65.3% / 0.94 | 34.9% / 0.76 | 13.9% / 0.51 | 12.8% / 0.49 |
| TN D-4865’s sphere-cone (model 1) | past the sphere: the method doesn’t hold | 7.8% / 0.34 | 6.0% / 0.32 | 5.9% / 0.32 |
Near the join’s start a slender nose leans on Newtonian pressures over far more of itself than anything the report checked. By Mach 2 the cap is a percent or so of the nose, less than the report’s own. The join’s weight rises from 0 at its start to 1 over the next 0.3 Mach, which damps that. But read a vertical tip’s numbers between the join’s ends as the blend they are.
A power-series nose meets its base at a slope of , with its length over its diameter. The cap can’t end on the nose while that slope is steeper than the handover’s angle. So such a nose
takes the method no earlier than the Mach number where the handover’s angle passes its base’s. Its join to slender-body theory starts there rather than at Mach 1.2. For that is Mach 1.23 at 3 diameters long and 1.49 at 1.2 diameters; the Arcas Robin’s from 1.22. One shorter than
diameters (0.56 for ) never takes it, since the handover stops at 24°, and keeps slender-body theory. HPR Sim doesn’t warn, and
AeroModel::supersonic_body
returns None. Haack and elliptical noses end level, so the cap always ends on them.
A blunt nose can be more than one shape, and the cap may end on any of them. Since M1.8e18, a nose that starts with a sphere carries on through the curved, widening shapes behind that sphere. HPR Sim looks for the handover along all of them rather than in the sphere alone. TN D-4865’s own model 2 needs it. Its nose is a sphere blended into a 2.75° cone by a second arc. The sphere is still at 38.3° where the arc takes over, steeper than the 24° cap at any speed. So the handover always falls on the arc (What a marched flare is worth).
Everything else reads exactly as it did before, on purpose. A pointed nose is one shape however many curved shapes follow it, so a curved transition behind one is still the afterbody. And the search stops at the first shape that is straight or narrows. A cap that reached a cylinder or a boattail would hand the flow over at no angle at all. It would do so with none of the total pressure the tip took out of it. So a nose steeper than the handover all the way to one is still refused. That is the case in the paragraph above, and its numbers are unchanged.
Behind the handover. HPR Sim starts the method there as it starts at a pointed tip. The flow is on the tangent cone, the cone that touches the body at the handover. The report starts it from the Newtonian pressure instead. What that choice is worth is set out in The two starts, after the checks below.
A worked example. The report’s sphere-cone at Mach 1.5: a nose radius of 0.175 base diameters on an 11.5° cone. The pitot pressure is 3.413 times the free stream’s, so
The wedge’s largest angle is 12.11°, reached on the sphere diameters behind the tip. On a sphere, with the angle from the tip, the loading integrates over the cap to on the sphere’s own cross-section. To that is 0.700, and 0.086 on the base (times ). The cone behind it, marched from the flow on a 12.11° cone, carries the other 1.595 of HPR Sim’s 1.681.
How it was checked. HPR Sim is checked against the report’s own model 1, measured at Mach 1.50 to 4.63. Its points are read from [J68] Fig. 8(a), p. 101, by pixel analysis of the scan, to about ±0.003. The plotting itself is good to about ±0.01. The comparison is made as ADR-036 compares the Arcas Robin. HPR Sim’s is taken at the plotted 0° to 12°, with the method’s slope including body lift. The body lift is Jorgensen’s, for a body of fineness 1.75, shorter than his Fig. 4 covers. The fit is a straight line, as for the measured and and for the report’s own method. Slopes are per radian on the base; the center of pressure is in base diameters from the tip:
| Mach | measured, per rad | the report’s method, per rad | vs measured | HPR Sim, per rad | vs measured | CP measured, diameters | HPR Sim CP, diameters |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | 1.908 | 1.844 | −3.3% | 1.885 | −1.2% | 1.00 | 1.03 |
| 1.9 | 1.926 | 1.964 | +2.0% | 1.926 | +0.0% | 1.03 | 1.02 |
| 2.3 | 1.833 | 1.989 | +8.5% | 1.971 | +7.5% | 1.03 | 1.02 |
| 2.96 | 1.786 | 1.878 | +5.2% | 2.009 | +12.5% | 1.06 | 1.02 |
| 3.95 | 1.618 | 1.800 | +11.3% | 2.099 | +29.7% | 1.05 | 1.03 |
| 4.63 | 1.550 | 1.762 | +13.6% | 2.048 | +32.1% | 1.09 | 1.03 |
Past Mach 2.3 HPR Sim reads high twice over. At Mach 3.95 and 4.63 its slope at is 13% to 21% above the measured one. There its body lift lifts its fitted slope 25% to 27% above that, where the measured curve rises only 9% to 16% above its own. The slopes at follow, beside it and not judged. The measured one is fitted with a curve two ways, as the decision record on comparing with a wind tunnel, ADR-036, asks:
| Mach | measured, fit, per rad | measured, fit, per rad | HPR Sim, per rad | HPR Sim from the report’s start, per rad |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | 1.741 | 1.810 | 1.681 | 3.392 |
| 1.9 | 1.979 | 1.952 | 1.711 | 1.960 |
| 2.3 | 1.657 | 1.717 | 1.713 | 1.792 |
| 2.96 | 1.646 | 1.684 | 1.702 | 1.700 |
| 3.95 | 1.433 | 1.484 | 1.678 | 1.625 |
| 4.63 | 1.339 | 1.419 | 1.613 | 1.484 |
The Arcas Robin’s committed design follows: its power-series nose, cylinder and boattail with the lip left off, to show the cap’s own effect. The lip itself carries nothing (A lip in a boattail’s wake). The readings run through a flight’s path and are fitted at the tunnel’s plotted angles as Checking the shock-expansion method fits them. They sit beside the secant ogive fitted to the same nose:
| model | Mach | measured, per rad | committed nose, per rad | vs measured | fitted ogive, per rad | vs measured | cap to radius ratio |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| short | 1.5 | 2.192 | 3.007 | +37.2% | 3.090 | +41.0% | 0.163 |
| short | 1.8 | 2.613 | 3.289 | +25.9% | 3.312 | +26.8% | 0.070 |
| short | 2.3 | 3.078 | 3.597 | +16.9% | 3.651 | +18.6% | 0.045 |
| short | 2.96 | 3.284 | 3.837 | +16.8% | 3.936 | +19.8% | 0.045 |
| short | 3.96 | 3.884 | 3.944 | +1.5% | 4.168 | +7.3% | 0.045 |
| short | 4.63 | 4.149 | 3.948 | −4.8% | 4.288 | +3.4% | 0.045 |
| long | 1.8 | 3.159 | 3.769 | +19.3% | 3.792 | +20.0% | 0.070 |
| long | 2.3 | 3.525 | 4.070 | +15.4% | 4.124 | +17.0% | 0.045 |
| long | 2.96 | 3.868 | 4.398 | +13.7% | 4.497 | +16.3% | 0.045 |
| long | 3.96 | 4.455 | 4.426 | −0.7% | 4.655 | +4.5% | 0.045 |
| long | 4.63 | 4.615 | 4.424 | −4.1% | 4.777 | +3.5% | 0.045 |
The rows are in
validation/fixtures/aero/blunt-tips.json,
written by cargo xtask aero; the readings in
tn-d-4865-sphere-cone.json.
A test holds these tables to the fixture, cell by cell. The committed nose reads within 3.8
points of the fitted ogive up to Mach 2.96 and 5.1 to 8.2 points below it past Mach 3. Below it is not always closer: past Mach 4 its error changes sign. So at Mach 4.63 it reads −4.8% where the
ogive reads +3.4%, 1.5 points further from the tunnel. Below Mach 3 both read high, most at Mach 1.5, for
the reasons in Checking the shock-expansion method.
What the cap is worth
A nose with a blunt or vertical tip flies Newtonian pressures over the tip. It hands the rest of the body to the shock-expansion method where the surface’s slope falls far enough, the handover (Blunt tips above). That handover is never steeper than a cap, 24°. Nothing here changes what a rocket flies: the cap is where it was, and no committed number moved.
The cap could move because the cone slopes the method reads now reach 30° (ADR-042),
where they once stopped at 24°. Moving it would follow the report’s own rule further. The wedge’s largest deflection passes 24° at Mach 2.06 and 30° at Mach 2.52. So a 30° cap keeps TN D-4865’s
([J68]’s) rule over that whole band, where 24° cuts it short from Mach 2.06 up. Where a cap binds at
all, going all the way to 30° reads nearer the report’s own sphere-cone at every row. Not every step along the way reads nearer, though. And on the Arcas Robin’s committed nose it breaks the march above Mach 4. The march steps the method element by element down the body from the handover. HPR Sim keeps 24° until that is settled (ADR-043). The cap is a parameter of the method rather than a
constant to argue over
(with_handover_cap_rad).
Each cap starts to bind at its own speed (Mach 2.06, 2.19, 2.34 and 2.52), and below that it costs nothing. The fit is the one in How it was checked. It uses HPR Sim’s at the tunnel’s plotted 0° to 12°, body lift included, fitted with a straight line. HPR Sim’s error against TN D-4865’s sphere-cone under four caps:
| Mach | error at 24°, as flown | at 26° | at 28° | at 30° |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | −1.2% | −1.2% | −1.2% | −1.2% |
| 1.9 | +0.0% | +0.0% | +0.0% | +0.0% |
| 2.3 | +7.5% | +7.3% | +7.1% | +7.1% |
| 2.96 | +12.5% | +12.2% | +11.9% | +11.5% |
| 3.95 | +29.7% | +28.9% | +28.3% | +28.0% |
| 4.63 | +32.1% | +31.2% | +30.9% | +31.3% |
Below Mach 2.06 no cap binds, which is why the first two rows are one reading four times. At Mach 2.3 only 24° and 26° bind, so the last two columns agree. Read the first two binding rows with care for another reason. The cone slopes are tabulated from Mach 3 up and held at that row below it (Bodies faster than sound). So at Mach 2.3 and 2.96 a steeper cap’s gain is read off a slope that is not itself a function of Mach there. Where a cap does bind, the whole step from 24° to 30° reads nearer the tunnel by 0.4 to 1.7 points, most at Mach 3.95. The one place a steeper cap reads further out is the last step at Mach 4.63, where 28° reads +30.9% and 30° +31.3%.
Now the cost, told by two counts. A reduced element is one where the method’s
exponential law would run the wrong way. The pressure behind the corner then heads away from the tangent cone’s instead of toward it, in the method’s own terms
([SD56] p. 13). So HPR Sim holds the pressure along it instead,
issue #81’s open question. A crossing is the rarer and worse thing. It is the marched surface pressure passing through its own tangent cone’s, either
way, within one part of the body. Where a nose meets a cylinder, a boattail or a flare the cone’s own pressure steps. That is not the same thing and is not counted. Both counts are per march, not
per element.
What a crossing is, and what it costs says how they
differ and how far either one can be trusted
(tangent_cone_crossings).
Here are two of the four caps on the Arcas Robin’s committed power-series nose and the short
model’s cylinder, nothing aft. The values are per radian on its cross-section at , read with the flown 10 elements per curve and with 160:
| Mach | 24° cap, 10 elements, per rad | 24°, 160 | 30°, 10 elements | 30°, 160 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | 2.531 | 2.532 | 2.531 | 2.532 |
| 1.8 | 2.697 | 2.702 | 2.697 | 2.702 |
| 2.3 | 2.873 | 2.881 | 2.851 | 2.862 |
| 2.96 | 3.021 | 3.029 | 2.943 | 2.955 |
| 3.5 | 3.071 | 3.079 | 2.953 | 2.964 |
| 3.96 | 3.073 | 3.080 (1 of 160 reduced) | 2.919 | 2.927 (1 of 160 reduced) |
| 4.63 | 3.030 | 3.034 (2 of 160 reduced) | 3.047 (5 of 10 reduced, 2 crossings) | 3.260 (109 of 160 reduced, 2 crossings) |
| 5 | 2.980 | 2.984 (2 of 160 reduced) | 3.400 (9 of 10 reduced, 1 crossing) | 3.454 (145 of 160 reduced, 1 crossing) |
Through Mach 3.96, cutting the nose into sixteen times as many elements moves the answer by under 0.01 per radian under the flown cap. Under the 30° cap it moves by under 0.013. So the answer is the model’s, not the mesh’s. Above Mach 3.96 the 30° cap’s march crosses its tangent cone, twice at Mach 4.63 and once at Mach 5. It reduces most of the nose too: 5 of 10 elements at Mach 4.63 and 9 of 10 at Mach 5. The 10-element counts are what HPR Sim would fly; at 160 they are 109 and 145. The answer follows the element count instead, and not even in order. It is 3.047 at 10 elements, 2.928 at the 40 the fixture also holds, and 3.260 at 160. That is a spread of 0.33 per radian, 11%, where the flown cap moves by 0.1%. The crossing is the cause and the reductions travel with it, which the next section takes apart.
What a crossing is, and what it costs
Here is the surface pressure just behind a corner and its tangent cone’s. is the lift per unit length (the loading) and the tangent cone’s. All are as the method’s equations define them.
The steeper cap starts the march from a steeper cone at a higher pressure. From there the tangent cone’s own pressure falls away faster than the marched pressure does as the nose flattens. So the surface pressure catches its tangent cone’s and passes through it. At Mach 4.63 under the 30° cap, that is about a tenth of the way back. The surface pressure stays above the cone’s until the nose flattens enough for the cone to catch up again. That is two crossings: one out, one back.
Why that hurts has nothing to do with . Write the exponent in as , so that
is a relaxation rate per meter: the gradient just behind the corner divided by how far the pressure has to go. A crossing closes that gap while the gradient carries on, so has a pole: it runs to infinity. The pressure itself doesn’t mind, because is only the gradient again, and that stays finite. The loading does mind, because it relaxes toward at the same ([SD56] eq. 19). Its own gap is set by something else entirely.
Follow that gap through the Mach 4.63 march under the 30° cap. Between the two crossings nearly
every element is reduced, so its loading is held where it was and never relaxes. By the second crossing stands about a quarter above . The element at that second crossing is back inside the method. How much of that quarter it sheds in its own length is whatever
happens to be for the step the mesh gave it. On the 40-element march it sheds 98% of
the gap in one step; on the 160-element march, 12%. That is the answer moving with the mesh, in one
number (test a_crossing_is_a_pole_in_the_rate_the_march_relaxes_at).
The counts say the same thing over the whole sweep. Of its thirty-two readings (four caps at eight Mach numbers on this one nose), twenty-seven never cross and five do:
| readings | most the answer moves over 10 → 160 elements | |
|---|---|---|
| no crossing | 27 | 0.012 per radian |
| a crossing | 5 | at least 0.035, up to 0.69 |
No overlap, and nearly three times (2.9×) between the two groups. The five are 30° and 28° at Mach
4.63 and 5, and 26° at Mach 5 (fixture
blunt-tips.json,
test over_the_sweeps_meshes_a_crossing_separates_the_readings_that_move).
A crossing is a flag, not a verdict, and it has to be read carefully. Three limits, all measured:
- A crossing does not prove an answer never settles. 28° at Mach 5 crosses at every mesh, and
its 0.69 spread is all in the coarse end. From 60 elements to 640 it holds to 0.005 per radian,
tighter than the worst reading in the sweep that never crosses. Compare 30° at Mach 4.63, which
moves by more than 0.2 per radian over that same range. The sweep shows that across its three meshes the crossings and only the crossings mark the readings that move (test
a_crossing_says_the_answer_moved_not_that_it_never_settles). - A count of zero does not prove one settled. Whether a crossing is seen depends on the mesh. 26° at Mach 5 and 28° at Mach 4.63 show none at the flown ten elements per curve. They show two at forty and a hundred and sixty, and both move. Read zero as “not proven”.
- HPR Sim does not count crossings while it flies, and everything here is one nose. The count is a tool for studying a body, not a guard. Another blunt nose above Mach 4 could cross under the flown 24° cap without saying so.
Reduced elements, on their own, do not move an answer. TN 3527’s own fineness-3 ogive reduces 27 of
160 elements at Mach 5.05 and 50 of 160 at Mach 6.28. Its answer settles to 0.002 per radian
from 10 elements to 160. There comes from the gradient changing sign, with the surface
pressure below its tangent cone’s the whole way down. The gap never closes, so there is no pole.
That ogive never crosses at either Mach number where it can be checked against the report. This is why the report could state its condition ([SD56] p. 13) and stop: it never had to say what a crossing
does (test a_reduced_element_settles_where_tn3527s_own_bodies_never_cross).
The two questions are tangled, though. The quarter-wide loading gap the second crossing sheds was opened by the reduced stretch behind it. That reduction is HPR Sim’s reading, not the report’s rule. So a different reading of would change the size of the step as well, and neither question can be judged without the other. What has changed is that the step itself is taken by an element the method still owns. So a rule for alone is not obviously enough.
The disorder under the steeper cap is not rounding. Nudge the Mach number by eight units in its last place (about a part in ) and the same elements reduce. The answer follows to a part in a billion (test a_steeper_handover_moves_the_march_out_of_its_range).
The break is not at 30°, and it is not orderly. It sits between the flown cap and the next step, and 28° is the worst of the four. At Mach 5 its answer moves 0.69 per radian over the element count, twelve times the 30° cap’s 0.055. No cap above the flown one holds its answer to Mach 5:
| cap | Mach 4.63, 10 elements | 160 elements | Mach 5, 10 elements | 160 elements |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24°, as flown | 3.030 | 3.034 (2 of 160 reduced) | 2.980 | 2.984 (2 of 160 reduced) |
| 26° | 2.961 | 2.965 (2 of 160 reduced) | 2.900 | 2.946 (40 of 160 reduced, 2 crossings) |
| 28° | 2.892 | 2.926 (33 of 160 reduced, 2 crossings) | 2.923 (4 of 10 reduced, 2 crossings) | 3.612 (140 of 160 reduced, 1 crossing) |
| 30° | 3.047 (5 of 10 reduced, 2 crossings) | 3.260 (109 of 160 reduced, 2 crossings) | 3.400 (9 of 10 reduced, 1 crossing) | 3.454 (145 of 160 reduced, 1 crossing) |
Below Mach 4 the four agree to 0.013 per radian, so nothing here says a cap between the two ends is a middle ground.
Settled is not the same as right. Under the flown cap HPR Sim still reads +29.7% and +32.1% against the sphere-cone at Mach 3.95 and 4.63, as the first table says. The cap chooses between an answer that is high and one that is high and moves with the mesh.
So the cap HPR Sim flies is set by the march’s range rather than by a chart’s edge. It moves when
the method has a rule for what the loading does where the surface pressure crosses its tangent cone’s. Such a rule is one whose answer stops changing as the nose is cut finer. It is judged together with the reading of that sets the gap it sheds. TN 3527 does not state either, because its own bodies never cross. So this is a modeling decision rather than a measurement to look up (issue #108: a steeper handover crosses the tangent cone above Mach
4). The milestone that would then move the
cap, M1.8e16, the blunt tip’s handover past 24°, waits on that (ADR-044 records the measurement behind this section). Both are deferred
as beyond the operating envelope, since the crossing bites above Mach 4. The vertical-tip switch’s error below that is part of
M1.14d: supersonic accuracy, and of
M1.14h: the extended band above Mach 2.5
(ADR-143).
All three tables are held to
blunt-tips.json
by a test, cell by cell. The second shows the two ends of the sweep, and the fixture holds 26° and
28° and a 40-element reading too. Its numbers are stored to six decimals, three more than the tables quote. Where most of the nose is reduced the march is not reproducible past about 1e-11 from one machine’s maths library to another’s. So pinning more would only break the build
(ADR-043).
The two starts
HPR Sim starts the march from the tangent cone at the handover, the report from the Newtonian
pressure there. Read at a small angle, the report’s start fails on
the Arcas Robin’s nose from Mach 3.96. There the march reduces the element at the nose’s end on the cylinder behind it (holding its pressure). The cylinder’s tangent cone is the free stream rather than a cone of its own. HPR Sim therefore refuses a reduced element there (issue #123: a cylinder’s or a boattail’s reduced element). From Mach 2.96 the answer from the report’s start drifts as the nose is cut into more elements. The reason is the same (issue #81, the method’s open question there). A flight’s table is built from Mach 5
down, so that failure would leave such a rocket no method at all. The tangent cone’s start holds to Mach 5 and settles. The Arcas nose moves under 0.01 per radian from 10 elements to 40. A five-caliber elliptical or von Kármán nose moves under 0.02 from 10 to 160. On the report’s sphere-cone, against the
measured slope at , the report’s start reads closer than HPR Sim’s at Mach 1.9, 3.95 and
4.63. It reads about the same at 2.96 and further at 2.3, and 95% high at Mach 1.5. That last is HPR Sim’s
reading of the report’s start at , not the report’s method, which reads 1.844 there at its own angles. The two differ because the handover sits 0.6° above the cone, so its linear range is that small. HPR Sim
takes the start that holds and settles everywhere over one that fits one body better where it
holds. Both are kept:
HandoverStart selects the report’s
for comparison (ADR-038). Slopes per radian on the body’s cross-section, at , for
the committed nose and the short model’s cylinder, nothing aft:
| Mach | the tangent cone’s start, 10 elements, per rad | 40 elements | the report’s start, 10 elements | 40 elements |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | 2.531 | 2.532 | 2.866 | 2.770 |
| 1.8 | 2.697 | 2.701 | 2.676 | 2.635 |
| 2.3 | 2.873 | 2.880 | 2.641 | 2.635 |
| 2.96 | 3.021 | 3.028 | 2.544 | 2.583 (6 of 40 reduced) |
| 3.5 | 3.071 | 3.078 | 3.361 (9 of 10 reduced) | 3.418 (39 of 40 reduced) |
| 3.96 | 3.073 | 3.080 | fails | fails |
| 4.63 | 3.030 | 3.031 (1 of 40 reduced) | fails | fails |
| 5 | 2.980 | 2.982 (1 of 40 reduced) | fails | fails |
What it means for a rocket. Mostly more force, barely any change of balance. Calisto’s von Kármán nose now takes the method past Mach 1.2. On Calisto the whole rocket’s normal-force slope rises 17% to 31% from Mach 1.5 to 2 (Normal force through Mach 1). The rocket’s center of pressure moves by under 0.15 calibers (forward at Mach 1.5, aft at Mach 2). So the stability margin moves by under a sixth of a caliber. The force that holds the rocket into the wind grows by about a quarter.
What it leaves out.
- No measurement checks a tip that isn’t spherical. The report tested spherical caps only. Newtonian theory on the cap and the tangent cone’s start are both approximations, and the method’s reduced elements (issue #81) still apply behind them.
- A cap that shrinks to nothing doesn’t reach the cone it sits on (issue #101). The march carries its start cone’s total pressure the whole way, as the method does from any vertex. Nothing makes that fade as the cap shrinks. A power-series nose of is a 7.1° cone but for a tip 1e-55 calibers across. Yet at Mach 4 its cylinder carries 1.21 per radian where the cone’s carries 1.37, 12% less. This is because the march runs on the 24° cone’s total pressure rather than the 7.1° cone’s. The shapes a rocket uses have caps that are small but not vanishing. At Mach 1.5 the table above puts their ends at 0.12 to 0.76 of the base radius, where that nose’s is 1e-55. How much of this bias they carry is unknown.
- At the handover is held where it sits on the body, as TN 3527 holds every other point. The report’s equivalent bodies turn the body about the sphere’s center, which slides the handover along the surface instead; HPR Sim leaves that term out. How much it is worth is not measured here. The two starts in the tables above differ by more than it alone, since their pressure and total pressure differ too. That is 2.53 against 2.87 per radian on the Arcas nose at Mach 1.5, and 1.70 against 1.70 on the sphere-cone at Mach 2.96.
- Two switches in shape, of the family issue #87 tracks. A vertical-tip nose steeper than the cap’s handover all the way to its base gets no method at all. A pointed tip steeper than the cone tables’ 30° is refused where a vertical one flies. The pointed tip’s edge was Fig. 2’s 24° until M1.8e11. The vertical tip’s edge is the handover’s cap, which stands at 24° for the reason above. Moving the cap waits on issue #108: a steeper handover puts the march into above Mach 4, which is deferred. The switch’s error itself is part of M1.14d: supersonic accuracy (and of M1.14h above Mach 2.5).
- Elements that merge, merge with Mach. Behind the cap, a tangency point whose tangent turns by under a microradian is folded into the element before it. This is because its corner can’t be placed in floating point. Which points merge changes with the handover, so the method’s answer takes a step of about a millionth of a per-radian slope as it does. That step is far below anything measured here, but there.
- Drag is unchanged: the nose’s wave drag already covers blunt shapes (Drag through Mach 1).
Fins, pods and overrides
The normal force of fin sets, pods and tube fins, and how a flight can take RASAero II’s normal force instead of HPR Sim’s own.
Fins
A fin set is identical fins spaced evenly around a body tube. For one fin of the set:
| symbol | meaning | unit |
|---|---|---|
| span: the fin’s height from the body surface to its tip | m | |
| height above the root, from 0 to | m | |
| , , | chord: the fin’s length along the airflow at height ; at the root and at the tip | m |
| , | how far the leading edge sits aft of the root’s leading edge, at height ; at the tip (the sweep length) | m |
| one fin’s area, one side (written inside the integrals) | m² | |
| the mid-chord sweep: the angle by which the line joining the chords’ midpoints leans aft from square to the body | rad | |
| the Prandtl-Glauert factor , the classic correction for the air’s compressibility below Mach 1: 1 at rest, falling to 0 at Mach 1 | none | |
| , , | the mean aerodynamic chord (MAC), an average chord that weights long chords more; its height; and its leading edge, aft of the root’s | m |
| the fin set’s CP, aft of the root leading edge | m | |
| the angle between fin and the direction the air crosses in (set by the flow roll ) | rad | |
| the fin-count factor, for five to eight fins | none | |
| the body tube’s radius at the fins | m | |
| the interference factor: how much the body raises the fins’ normal force | none |
One fin ([B67] eq. 3-4–3-6, [N09] eq. 3.38–3.40):
The mean aerodynamic chord (MAC; [N09] eq. 3.30–3.32):
The CP, aft of the root leading edge ([B66] eq. 76a, [N09] eq. 3.34):
fins ([N09] eq. 3.51–3.53, [TD] eq. 3.54):
The interference ([B66] eq. 77, [N09] eq. 3.56):
-
Trapezoids. , and the closed forms give [B66] eq. 57 and 76a exactly.
-
Ellipses on the root chord. , , and
Loft replaced the ellipse with an equal-area trapezoid, whose sweep made the slope 1.3% low (Loft lesson L10).
-
Freeform outlines. runs from the leading edge to the trailing edge. So a jagged edge’s gap counts toward the CP but not toward ([N09] pp. 27–28). is the span average of the mid-chord angle ([N09] p. 29), which gives the natural angle for trapezoids and ellipses. The integrals are exact. Between vertex heights the edges are straight, and a three-point Gauss rule per band (quadrature, a weighted sum of samples) is exact. Bands thinner than 1e-12 of the span (vertex heights a few rounding steps apart, as when a tip is converted from inches) are skipped.
-
A root along a nose cone or a transition (ADR-166, fins on a nose cone). There the root (where the fin meets the body) follows the curved surface. Its points are part of the fin’s outline. So , and the CP are those of the region between the outline and the surface. Heights run from the surface at the root’s leading edge. The body radius in the interference factor above is the radius there. No measured fin on a nose cone checks the model; against OpenRocket, the one example is the cockpit of Pods--airframes and winglets:
- Across the airflow at Mach 0.3, its normal-force slope is 0.2784 per radian in HPR Sim and 0.2117 in OpenRocket, 31.5% more. The CPs there are 0.13 mm (0.0051 in) apart. Closed straight along its chord, HPR Sim’s would be 0.2802, so the curved root isn’t the cause (#326).
- OpenRocket takes its margin with the air crossing at 0° roll. There the single fin lies in the airflow’s plane, and neither code counts it. HPR Sim’s margin is the weakest direction’s since #329 (Stability margin).
- Above Mach 1, the tip-cone correction still mirrors the flow at a level line through the root’s leading edge, an approximation on a rising root.
-
Prandtl-Glauert enters through in the fin slope only, up to Mach 0.8. The CP stays at the quarter chord, a quarter of the way along the MAC, through that range ([B67] p. 6). Past Mach 0.8 the fins follow Fins through Mach 1, below.
-
Fin count. A fin at angle to the lateral airflow adds in the plane of the flow. The sum is for three or more evenly spaced fins, at any roll. For one or two fins it changes with the direction the air crosses. So the margin differs with direction. HPR Sim reports the weakest (Stability margin). is 1 up to four fins, then 0.948, 0.913, 0.854 and 0.810 for five to eight ([TD] eq. 3.54). Those factors make six and eight fins 1.37 and 1.62 times four ([762] p. 5-24), and interpolate five and seven (Loft lesson L8). More than eight fins are refused: [TD]’s 0.750 has no data behind it. [N09]’s roll-dependent 15% and 6% reductions for three and four fins were dropped in [TD].
-
Side force of one- and two-fin sets. Each fin sees ([N09] eq. 3.50) and pushes along its own normal. Eq. 3.51 keeps the in-plane share . The share across the plane is , which cancels for three or more fins but not for one or two. [N09] pp. 31–32 drops it, arguing that it cancels for two or more fins; for two fins the pushes add. HPR Sim reports it as at the fins’ CP (derived here from eq. 3.50, not taken from a source).
-
Interference is Barrowman’s straight-line fit to NACA TR-1307, justified for ([B66] p. 36).
-
Not modeled.
- The body lift the fins induce, ([B66] p. 36 neglects it; [B67] eq. 3-98 has it).
- The roll moment of a single fin’s normal force at an angle of attack: its force acts at along the fin’s normal. Two or more even fins cancel it; one fin doesn’t. Roll from cant and against the roll rate is modeled (Roll: forcing and damping).
- Interference between fin sets at the same station.
- Damping coefficients for pitch and yaw. They would replace the local-flow damping below, not
add to it, or it would be counted twice; HPR Sim keeps the local flow:
- In a flight, pitch and yaw damping come only from evaluating each component in its own local flow. That flow includes the speed the rocket’s rotation adds there (Rigid-body flight).
- Only components with a slope give it: nose cones, transitions and fin sets. A boattail’s slope is negative, so it takes some away.
- Body tubes give none at small angles. Their own slope is 0, and their body lift grows with , so it adds nothing there.
- Tube fins, which have their own section (Tube fins). Any part kind the model doesn’t know is refused. Pods have their own section (Pods).
- Launch lugs and rail buttons add drag only.
Fins through Mach 1
Faster than sound, air can’t flow around a fin’s edges ahead of it. The fin’s lift comes from the pressure behind the shock and expansion waves at its surfaces, and a different theory applies. HPR Sim uses Barrowman’s subsonic method to Mach 0.8, supersonic linear theory from where that theory holds, and a straight-line join between them. Below Mach 1.2 the body terms don’t change with Mach: slender-body theory’s slope and CP hold at any speed ([B67] p. 18). Past it, a body that takes the shock-expansion method gains lift with Mach (The body faster than sound in a flight). How well this agrees with a wind tunnel and with RASAero II is under Verification.
Supersonic linear theory. Past Mach 1, is redefined as , which grows from 0 as the speed passes that of sound. At a small angle to a supersonic flow, a thin flat plate has the pressure coefficient on the side facing the flow. The other side has . Both are the first term of Barrowman’s pressure series ([B67] appendix A, p. 82). So every part of the fin carries the same load, per unit area. Each strip (a narrow slice of the fin along the airflow) carries it at its middle. MIL-HDBK-762 finds linearized theory accurate for the supersonic stability of thin fins ([762] p. 5-15). Two things change the load near the tip:
- The tip’s Mach cone. The tip disturbs the flow only inside the cone that spreads inboard from its leading edge at the Mach angle, . Barrowman halves the load inside it ([B67] appendix A, p. 84). For a rectangular tip that is exactly linear theory’s loss.
- The body as a mirror. At the root the body stands in for the fin’s mirror image. A cone that reaches the root continues into the mirror image. The part of it there counts too, as the mirror fin’s cone crossing onto this one.
One fin ([B67] appendix A):
The CP, aft of the root leading edge, is the centroid of that load: the fin’s area centroid, less half the cone’s ([B67] appendix A). A rectangle, , in exact linear theory ([TN2114], [N09] eq. 3.35):
is the part of the fin (and of its mirror image) inside the tip’s Mach cone. The fin-count factor, the sum over fins and apply as above.
Where it starts. Linear theory’s strips need four things, so it starts at
where and are the leading- and trailing-edge sweeps and is the tip chord. is the aspect ratio of the fin and its mirror image:
- Mach 1.2, the bottom of the supersonic region ([N09] Table 3.1, p. 19);
- supersonic edges, each with its Mach number square to the edge, , past 1, the case [TN2114] covers;
- , where linear theory’s tip loss holds; a rectangle’s slope peaks there, at ;
- , so the mirror fin’s tip cone stays off this fin’s tip, which matters for a tip chord longer than the fin’s average.
Calisto’s and the Arcas Robin’s fins start at their leading edge’s 1.2806 and at 1.2.
The transonic join. From Mach 0.8 to , the slope and the CP are each a straight line in between their values at the two ends. No source gives this region in closed form. MIL-HDBK-762 reads it from charts of transonic similarity (the way thickness and Mach number combine near Mach 1, [762] pp. 5-104–5-105). The join keeps both continuous. For most fins the slope peaks at (a leading edge swept forward can make it fall across the join instead). For most fins the CP also moves aft from the quarter chord toward the middle of the chord.
Worked example. Calisto’s 2018 fins: root chord 0.12 m (0.39 ft), tip chord 0.04 m (0.13 ft), span 0.10 m (0.33 ft). The sweep length is 0.08 m (0.26 ft). The example uses (). The leading edge is swept 38.66°, so . At Mach 2, . The tip cone is a triangle 0.04 m (0.13 ft) along the tip and down the unswept trailing edge. Its area is 0.000462 m², 5.8% of the fin’s 0.008 m². So, per rad,
HPR Sim gives, per fin:
| Mach | slope , per rad | CP aft of the root leading edge, m |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 1.853 | 0.0550 |
| 0.8 | 2.170 | 0.0550 |
| 1.0 | 2.499 | 0.0632 |
| 1.2806 | 2.960 | 0.0747 |
| 1.5 | 2.158 | 0.0753 |
| 2.0 | 1.416 | 0.0758 |
| 3.0 | 0.877 | 0.0761 |
What it leaves out.
- Thickness. Linear theory is for thin plates; a thick fin or a blunt leading edge detaches the bow shock near Mach 1.
- Exact linear theory for a tapered fin. The strip method’s constant load outside the tip cone runs above it. Against [TN2114] eq. A7 (printed p. 18), a fin with a taper ratio of 0.5, an unswept trailing edge and gets 4.5% more slope.
- Subsonic leading and trailing edges, which the join covers without a method of its own. A curved edge counts by its span-averaged sweep. So an elliptical fin, whose edge is swept 90° at the tip, keeps a subsonic stretch past . So does a freeform fin with a raked outboard edge.
- Leading edges swept forward. The tip then sits ahead of the root, and its Mach cone covers much of the fin. There the half-load overstates the loss, so the slope rises past instead of falling. The rise is up to +7.7% for fins swept 40° to 50° forward, peaking up to 0.37 Mach later (issue #64). Such fins are rare on rockets. A property test covers every trapezoid whose leading edge is straight or swept aft (to 65°), tapered either way. Each is held to a slope that falls with Mach from .
- The fins’ lift carried onto the body behind them, , as below Mach 1.
Other choices, and why not.
- Niskanen’s supersonic slope ([N09] eq. 3.48–3.49) multiplies the fin’s area by one strip’s pressure coefficient, with : the pressure on one face. A plate is pushed by the difference between its faces, twice that. His thesis finds its simulated for the Arcas Robin “notably lower than the experimental values” (p. 91). The cause is unknown, and the comparison runs to Mach 4. HPR Sim counts both faces.
- RocketPy 1.13.0 flies Diederich’s subsonic slope at every Mach number, with held at 0.6 from Mach 0.8 to 1.1. Past Mach 1 that tends to , about times linear theory’s . Its fin CP doesn’t move with Mach.
- Tuning the join to the wind tunnel below would shrink its misses by fitting the model to its own check. The join’s ends come from the sources’ speed regions, set before measuring.
Roll: forcing and damping
Fins set at a small angle to the rocket’s axis, cant, each push sideways as a wing at that angle would. Each push acts off the axis, so together they twist the rocket and spin it up: the roll forcing. Once the rocket rolls, each fin also moves sideways through the air and meets it at an angle of its own. The fin pushes back against the spin: the roll damping. The two balance at a steady roll rate. HPR Sim takes both from Barrowman’s thesis ([B67] §3.13–3.14, appendix A), by strip theory. Each narrow strip of a fin, running with the flow, lifts in proportion to the angle it meets the air at.
Below Mach 1.5 only two committed checks apply: the flight’s agreement with the closed-form balance and Barrowman’s own computed damping at Mach 0.07. Measured sets there, not yet committed, put the damping 24.5% to 200% high, most near Mach 1.1 (research note, §3). Strips that each lift at the fin’s average slope ignore how the flow at one strip changes the next. For short fins that likely overstates the damping, so a subsonic spin may read low.
Other symbols follow Fins: the body’s radius at the fins, the span, and the root and tip chords. is one fin’s area and the mean aerodynamic chord’s distance from the root.
| Symbol | Meaning | Unit |
|---|---|---|
| cant: the angle each fin is turned about its own span, positive turning fin 0’s (the fin along ) leading edge toward (Mass properties) | rad | |
| roll rate about (Frames) | rad/s | |
| a strip’s distance from the rocket’s axis, | m | |
| rolling moment about over , with the reference diameter | none | |
| one fin’s rolling moment per radian of cant, in the sense its lift turns the rocket | per rad | |
| one fin’s rolling moment per unit of : the damping, negative | none | |
| the whole rocket’s rolling moment from cant at no roll rate | none | |
| , | the body’s effect on the forcing and on the damping | none |
The moment. A fin set of fins adds
The minus sign is the cant’s direction. A positive cant turns fin 0’s leading edge toward , so its lift pushes toward . That turns the rocket about (a negative ), clockwise seen from ahead of the nose, looking aft. Its first term, summed over the sets, is . In flight the cant’s forcing is scaled by . The cant meets the air as it runs along the axis. So there is none broadside, and it reverses tail first, as the fins’ normal force follows (Rigid-body flight). Bodies of revolution add nothing, and fin-fin interference is left out, as in [N09] eq. 3.66.
Below Mach 0.8. The cant is an angle of attack for each fin, so its lift is the fin’s own normal force. It acts at its mean aerodynamic chord: ([B67] eq. 3-35, [N09] eq. 3.66). For the damping, a strip at meets the air at . The strip lifts by the fin’s slope per unit of its area, : ([B67] eq. 3-40–3-49, [N09] eq. 3.67–3.70). For a trapezoid
for any outline HPR Sim takes it from the polygon.
From , where supersonic linear theory starts (Fins through Mach 1), each strip carries the load , halved inside the tip’s Mach cone:
with ([B67] appendix A, first order). Between Mach 0.8 and each is a straight line in , as the fin’s slope is.
The body. The body reshapes the flow the fins meet. Barrowman’s factors from slender-body theory ([B67] eq. 3-95 with 3-105, and 3-123 with 3-122) use . They scale the forcing by , 0.940 at , and the damping by , 1.33 at for a rectangular fin. Both are 1 without a body. [N09] leaves both out. is for a chord that falls linearly from root to tip. Another outline takes it at its tip-to-root chord ratio. So an elliptical fin is taken as a triangle, about 5.5% too much damping.
The steady roll rate is where the two cancel: . Below Mach 0.8 the fin’s slope cancels between them, and for one fin set
It grows with the airspeed and the cant, and not with the air’s density or the number of fins.
A worked example: Valetudo with its fins canted 1°. Valetudo, one of RocketPy’s example rockets, has three fins on a body of radius 40.45 mm (1.6 in). Each has root chord 58 mm (2.3 in), tip chord 18 mm (0.71 in) and span 77 mm (3.0 in). One fin has , , , and , so and . At 100 m/s (328 ft/s),
2.7 turns a second. With no drag and no gravity, HPR Sim’s flight settles on it within 1e-6 (1e-11 measured). It spins up with a time constant of 0.48 s (canted_fins_spin_to_the_analytic_balance). That test also checks this example’s rate and time constant.
Why these choices:
- The fin’s own slope in the damping. Barrowman’s text writes the airfoil’s slope there
(eq. 3-40, ), as does [N09] eq. 3.69. His own computed curve for the Basic Finner reads
−34.21 at Mach 0.07 (Fig. 5-7). That is the fin’s slope spread over its strips, −33.53 (
the_basic_finner_damps_as_barrowman_computed). The airfoil’s gives about −81, 2.4 times as hard. His curve’s rise toward Mach 1, about 20% read from the figure, follows the fin’s slope too, where the airfoil’s would grow without bound. Stubby fins lift far less than an airfoil. - The body factors. Barrowman has them and [N09] doesn’t. For the Arcas Robin’s fins they lower the forcing 6.5% and raise the damping 20%. His is a ratio of forces (eq. 3-116, 3-120) applied to a moment (eq. 3-123). Weighted by the moment it would be 3.4% to 4.2% smaller for the fins here. HPR Sim keeps his, which his computed curve seems to use too. is reference 23’s factor for fins turned together; for cant, whose load turns the other way on the opposite fin, it isn’t derived.
- Moments about the body’s axis. Faster than sound Barrowman’s appendix A takes each strip’s moment about the fin’s root. HPR Sim takes it about the axis, , as his subsonic eq. 3-27 and 3-35 do. About the root the Arcas Robin’s forcing would be about half. Its load sits 25 mm (0.98 in) from the root and 53 mm (2.1 in) from the axis.
- Limits on the input. HPR Sim refuses a cant beyond 15°, where a fin stalls and the linear model means nothing. It also refuses a cant on a single fin, whose sideways push it doesn’t carry.
- Pitch and yaw keep the local-flow damping. A flight’s pitch and yaw damping come from each part’s own local flow (ADR-011); coefficients would count it twice.
- No target was set for the comparisons. The roadmap asked for the forcing to be compared with the measured roll effectiveness, and set no bar. The numbers are reported as they are (ADR-031).
What it leaves out:
- The roll forcing near Mach 1.5 reads high: linear theory’s load rises as toward Mach 1, and the Arcas Robin’s measured forcing doesn’t. Barrowman found the same for the Tomahawk sounding rocket (“the theoretical value at is no good”, [B67] p. 66).
- The damping reads high faster than sound, most near Mach 1.5 (+27.5% against NOL’s wind tunnel). Near Mach 1.5 the likely cause (an inference, not shown) is that linear theory’s load rises as toward Mach 1 faster than the fins’ does, as the forcing does. The fins’ thickness, 8% of the diameter, is unlikely to be the cause: what evidence there is says a thickness term would raise the damping.
- No committed measurement checks roll below Mach 1.5. Measured sets there put the damping 24.5% to 200% high (research note, §3); #1033 adds one at Mach 0.22.
- A fast spin at low airspeed meets the fins at angles past stall, where the linear damping no longer holds. Valetudo spinning at 17 rad/s at 5 m/s (16 ft/s) meets the air 23° off at its fin tips.
- The angle of attack: the measured roll effectiveness changes by up to 13% between 0° and ±4° (TN D-4014 Fig. 14). HPR Sim’s is the same at every angle. A single fin’s roll from its normal force, the body’s own roll, and fins’ airfoil sections are not modeled.
Pods
A pod is a body beside the airframe: a side pod, or an outboard motor pod (the design page’s Pods). HPR Sim gives each pod the forces its parts would have on the airframe, once per pod, and adds them to the airframe’s. No measured flight checks it. The formulas are checked against hand-worked numbers. They are also checked against OpenRocket 24.12 on six probe designs, small designs written only to test pods (pod designs against OpenRocket). Five carry pods of bodies, fins, a tail cone, winglets or motors, and one is the same airframe without pods. Below Mach 0.81, HPR Sim’s apogee is within 0.92% of OpenRocket’s, and its stability margin within 0.0014 calibers. What the pods change agrees to 0.32 percentage points of apogee (table below). That shows the two codes compute the same thing, not that either is right. Both leave out how the pods and the body disturb each other’s flow, whose size is given below. Faster than sound a pod keeps slender-body theory’s slope, which nothing checks.
The rule. A pod’s nose cones, transitions and tubes are Barrowman’s bodies, as on the airframe ([B67] eq. 3-65, [N09] eq. 3.19). A part whose cross-section grows from to has the slope , on the rocket’s reference area . Bodies of revolution gives its center of pressure. Each pod adds that once:
- Normal force. pods add times one pod’s slope and moment, at the part’s station along the rocket. The pod’s first part steps up from nothing, as the airframe’s nose does. So a pod that starts with a tube gets no slope from its flat front. Faster than sound, a pod keeps slender-body theory’s slope, since the shock-expansion method (Bodies faster than sound) covers the airframe alone.
- Body lift. Each pod’s body lift, Jorgensen’s crossflow term, uses the pod’s own planform and fineness (its length over its largest diameter), not the airframe’s.
- Fins on a pod. A pod’s fin set is turned with its pod: pod at roll angle holds fin at . Each fin takes its share of the flow as an airframe fin does (Fins). The fin-fin factor (how a set’s fins shade each other) counts one pod’s fins. The body’s interference with the fins, , is the pod tube’s: 1 for the tube of no radius a pod of winglets hangs from.
- Drag. Each pod adds its own drag buildup (Drag): friction on its surface, with the body form factor at its own fineness. It has its nose’s or shoulder’s pressure drag, its steps, its boattails and its own base, the last part’s aft area. A pod’s fins, lugs and buttons drag once per pod too. The Reynolds number stays the rocket’s, as for every part ([N09] §3.4).
- Motors in pods. A burning motor’s cross-section comes off the base of the body it sits in. The airframe’s motors come off the airframe’s base, and a pod’s off its own pod’s
([N09] pp. 50–51 for the base). This is worked out per pod set. Each pod set that holds motor
mounts has its own total of thrusting motor area
(
DragConditions::thrusting_pod_motor_areas_m2, in the order ofLayout::motor_pod_sets). Each of its pods takes an even share of that total. A base smaller than its motors has no base drag left, never less. Up toMOTOR_POD_SETS, 4, pod sets may hold motor mounts; a rocket with more is refused by name. Until M4.5i, motor mounts in two different pod sets were refused (ADR-168). Worked example: two pod sets of one pod each, both holding a burning 18 mm motor (2.54 cm² each). Each pod’s own base loses 2.54 cm²; the airframe’s base keeps its own motors’ relief alone. - Roll. In HPR Sim a pod adds no rolling moment of its own (but see A single pod’s moments below); it damps a roll. Rolling at , a part at distance from the axis crosses the air at , so it meets it at the angle . Its normal force acts about the axis with the arm . That gives, for each pod’s body part, a roll damping (Roll: forcing and damping) of , on the reference diameter . A pod’s fins damp as the airframe’s fins do, with each strip’s distance taken from the rocket’s axis. A fin whose root is out along its span has its strips at .
Where the forces act. The flight engine applies each pod part’s force on the rocket’s axis at its station. For two pods or more, spaced evenly, the pods’ offsets add to zero. So the forces on the axis turn the rocket in pitch and yaw as they would at the pods. What an offset adds, to first order, is roll damping, which HPR Sim adds as above, and a pitch damping from the pods’ drag. Pitching at , a pod off the pitch plane meets the air faster or slower on either side. So its drag changes by as much and pitches back. That is (the pitch moment per unit pitch rate, one pod’s drag coefficient, the sum over the pods). is about −0.15 on the worked example below. HPR Sim leaves it out. The airframe’s own pitch damping from its fins is , with the fins’ distance from the center of gravity. It is of order on such a rocket.
Worked example. The tests’ rocket is the finned_rocket of hpr-aero’s tests. It has a 0.25 m (0.82 ft) ogive nose and 0.7 m (2.3 ft) of tube 27 mm (1.1 in) in radius. A 0.05 m (0.16 ft) boattail leads to a 22 mm (0.87 in) tail tube 0.3 m (0.98 ft) long. Its four fins have 0.12 m (0.39 ft) root chord, 0.05 m (0.16 ft) tip chord and 0.06 m (0.20 ft) span. The sweep is 0.07 m (0.23 ft). It carries three pods 40 mm (1.6 in) from its axis, starting 0.35 m (1.1 ft) aft of the nose tip. Each is a cone 0.05 m (0.16 ft) long on a tube
0.2 m (0.66 ft) long, both 10 mm (0.39 in) in radius. So each pod’s fineness is . At Mach 0.3,
Reynolds number per meter:
| rocket | one cone’s slope, per rad | its CP, m | rocket’s normal-force slope, per rad | rocket’s CP, m aft of the tip | zero-lift drag coefficient | pods’ share of drag coefficient | roll damping coefficient |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| without pods | 12.374 | 1.0662 | 0.5051 | −35.215 | |||
| with three pods | 0.2743 | 0.3833 m (1.258 ft) | 13.197 () | 1.0237 | 0.6386 | 0.0074, 0.0127, 0.0592, 0.0542 | −36.118 (−0.903) |
One cone’s slope is per radian and its center of pressure . The pods’ share of drag is the cones’ friction and pressure, then the tubes’ friction and base. Their share of roll damping is .
The pods move the center of pressure about 43 mm (1.7 in), 0.79 calibers,
forward, and add 26% to the drag. The test the_aero_page_s_pod_example holds this table to the
digits printed. The tests a_pod_adds_its_bodies_slopes_once_per_pod,
a_pod_s_body_lift_takes_its_own_fineness, a_pod_drags_once_per_pod,
a_pod_s_base_takes_its_own_motors_area, a_pod_s_bodies_damp_the_roll,
a_pod_s_fins_turn_with_their_pod and a_pod_s_fins_are_the_pod_s_turned_with_it hold the rules to hand-worked values. They hold the fins’ damping to Barrowman’s strips summed by hand over two pods with a
fin pointing each way. In the flight engine’s tests,
pods_damp_the_spin_of_canted_fins_by_their_cones flies Valetudo
with three pods and canted fins: it spins to the balance the pods’ damping predicts, to 1e-6.
Against OpenRocket. The six probe designs are written by
pod_probes.py.
Each is an airframe with a 0.2 m (0.66 ft) conical nose on 0.6 m (2.0 ft) of tube 60 mm (2.4 in) across. It has three fins, an AeroTech H128W and one set of pods. The pods are about 0.3 m (0.98 ft) long and 20 mm (0.79 in) to 32 mm (1.3 in) across. They stand 5 mm (0.20 in) to 10 mm (0.39 in) off the airframe. The winglets hang from pods of no length at its surface. Every
outside part is set to OpenRocket’s regular paint finish, 60 µm roughness. OpenRocket 24.12 flies
them straight up in calm air, and HPR Sim flies the same files
(HPR Sim’s flights against OpenRocket’s). In
such a flight the apogee and the largest speed test the drag and the mass. The normal force enters
only through the margin, which both codes take as the rocket leaves the rod. Pods’
change is the difference from pods-none, the same airframe with no pods, so it shows the pods’
own share in each code:
| probe | its pods | apogee, OpenRocket | HPR Sim’s apogee, % from OpenRocket | pods’ change of apogee in OpenRocket, % | pods’ change of apogee in HPR Sim, % | margin, OpenRocket | margin, HPR Sim |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
pods-none | none | 776.1 m (2,546 ft) | +0.81% | 2.757 cal | 2.759 cal | ||
pods-bodies-3 | three: a cone and a tube | 663.3 m (2,176 ft) | +0.48% | −14.53% | −14.81% | 2.360 cal | 2.362 cal |
pods-fins-2 | two: a cone, a tube, three fins | 613.7 m (2,013 ft) | +0.49% | −20.93% | −21.18% | 2.653 cal | 2.654 cal |
pods-fins-tail-4 | four: a cone, a tube, four fins, a tail cone | 533.3 m (1,750 ft) | +0.91% | −31.28% | −31.21% | 2.470 cal | 2.471 cal |
pods-winglets-2 | two of no length, two fins each | 699.8 m (2,296 ft) | +0.71% | −9.84% | −9.92% | 2.622 cal | 2.623 cal |
pods-motors-2 | two: a cone, a tube, three fins and an H128W each | 876.9 m (2,877 ft) | +0.53% | +12.98% | +12.66% | 2.990 cal | 2.991 cal |
pods-motors-2 flies an H128W in each of its two pods and none in the airframe, twice the impulse. It has 0.35 kg of nose ballast instead of 0.15 kg, so its change is not its pods’ alone. HPR Sim’s
largest speed is 0.73% to 1.24% above OpenRocket’s, its margin 0.0011 to 0.0014 calibers larger. The pods’ change of margin agrees to 0.0004 calibers. The launch masses agree within 0.0001%.
The test pod_designs_are_within_5_percent_of_openrocket holds every probe within 5% of
OpenRocket’s apogee and largest speed, the bar every flight against OpenRocket is held to
(ADR-076). It also holds each margin within 0.005 calibers, and the pods’ change within
1 percentage point of apogee and 0.005 calibers. Those bounds were set after these numbers were
measured, tight enough to catch a broken pod rule. A pod fin’s body interference taken on the
airframe’s radius would move a margin by some 0.04 calibers. The whole table is in the
committed report.
The first probes stated no surface finish. HPR Sim flew them 6.0% to 7.3% high because the two programs’ defaults differ. OpenRocket reads a part with no finish as regular paint, 60 µm. HPR Sim’s reader gave it HPR Sim’s own default, 20 µm, and now reads it as OpenRocket does (issue #216, which gives the run). The probes now state their finish.
One private design flies with pods too: C02, an anonymized design of the library
(HPR Sim’s flights of the private designs).
Its pods hold only a launch lug each, on a tube of no length, so they add the lugs’ drag and
nothing else. Over its 5 configurations HPR Sim’s apogee is −0.94% to +2.15% from OpenRocket’s. 3 of them are compared with an OpenRocket flight whose parachute opened before apogee, including the +2.15%. Of OpenRocket’s own pod examples, Pods--airframes and winglets flies, its cockpit fin
read on the nose cone
(fins on a nose cone). Every apogee is within 0.5% of OpenRocket’s, with the margin 0.071 to 0.076 calibers above it, the flattering side
(#325,
#326). Pods--powered with recovery deployment
flies since M4.5i, as saved since M4.5k. As saved, the design weighs its rail buttons’ screw heads and takes each of its two pod sets’ motors off that set’s own pods (ADR-168). With
only the sustainer’s motor it reads 0.36% below OpenRocket’s apogee, and with only the booster’s
motors 1.86% below. Its staged flight reads 37.93% low because its sustainer is unstable when the air
crosses it edge-on to its two-fin strake set. In the conditions of OpenRocket’s record it turns over before apogee in both codes. That record’s site is at 28.61° N, where the Earth’s
rotation tips HPR Sim’s flight. HPR Sim’s angle of attack passes 90° at 2.25 s
(HPR Sim’s flights against OpenRocket’s).
What neither code models. OpenRocket documents no pod model of its own. On the probes its answer is HPR Sim’s. Neither code
turns the flow around the body, then. On pods-fins-2 the upwash beside the body (below) would add
about a third to the pod fins’ force. So the limits below are both codes’ limits, and the agreement
above cannot size them. The probes do not test a single pod (each has two or more) or a pod faster than Mach 0.81. Nor do they test a rocket flying at an angle of attack, so not a pod’s body lift, which is zero straight into the air. Nor do they test airframe and pod motors burning together, or a roll: none has canted fins,
and neither code’s roll is compared.
Left out, and how large it may be.
-
The body’s flow around the pods, and theirs around it. The airframe turns the crossflow around itself, so a pod beside it meets the air at a different angle. In potential flow past a cylinder of radius , consider a point at distance , at the angle from the crossflow’s direction. It meets the crossflow at along it and across it. At the first is NACA Report 1307’s upwash ([PNK57] p. 4 eq. 15). For three pods or more, spaced evenly, both average to zero, and the first-order change cancels. For one or two they do not. On the worked example’s pods, . So a pair’s cones lift up to 46% more or less, by roll angle, and push sideways by up to as much. HPR Sim leaves this out. Interference drag is left out as well. Barrowman leaves it out for fins ([B67] p. 62, “No interference drag effects are considered”) and Niskanen for the whole rocket ([N09] §3.4).
-
A single pod’s moments. One pod’s drag acts off the axis and pitches the rocket; its normal force, and its fins’, act off the axis and roll it. HPR Sim applies them on the axis, so it drops those moments (issue #213). The worked example with one pod has drag coefficient 0.0445 at 40 mm (1.6 in). With a one-caliber margin, the pitch moment would trim the rocket at about
Which way that moves the flight turns with the pod’s side against the wind and the rail’s tilt. So the apogee or the drift may read low. A flight with one pod off the axis warns of it (the flight-path warnings). Two or more pods stand evenly round the axis, so their moments cancel.
-
The interference on a pod’s fins’ roll damping. HPR Sim takes the pod tube’s roll-damping factor on the whole sum. The part that comes from the pod’s offset is the pod moving sideways, whose factor is closer to the normal force’s . For a fin whose span equals the tube’s radius (), is 1.5 and a rectangular fin’s 1.33 (Fins, Roll: forcing and damping). So that part may be some 10% too small; no test sizes it. On a pod of no radius, winglets’ usual pod, both are 1 and nothing is lost.
-
A pod inside the airframe. Nothing checks that a pod clears the airframe (#206); a pod sunk into it still gets its whole slope, friction and base.
-
Canted fins on a pod are refused: their roll forcing about the rocket’s axis is not modeled. So is a pod’s tube of no length with a radius, a flat disc the drag buildup has no term for.
Tube fins
A tube fin set is a ring of short open tubes around the airframe, in place of flat fins. HPR Sim flies each tube as an annular wing (a ring wing). That is a wing bent round into a tube, which lifts when the air meets it at an angle.
Only its parts are validated: no tube fin rocket has been checked against a wind tunnel or a measured flight. The ring wing’s slope is within 3% of five rings measured in a wind tunnel, which were thick and cambered, not paper tubes. What the tubes do to each other and to the body is not modeled. Nothing measures it, and theory predicts more lift than HPR Sim gives (#234).
The model came with M2.2e9 (ADR-099, tube fins flown as ring wings).
On OpenRocket’s Tube fin rocket HPR Sim’s center of pressure is 1.07 calibers forward of OpenRocket’s. That misses the quarter caliber Loft lesson L19 asks for, and nothing measured says which code is nearer (below).
The normal force. A ring wing of diameter and length lifts about twice as much as a flat wing of span and chord . A long, thin ring lifts twice what a solid body of its diameter would. This is because it turns the air inside it as well as the air around it. Hoerner (1965, p. 7-13) gives for a ring of small aspect ratio. HPR Sim takes Weissinger’s formula for a thin ring (1955, as quoted by Wagner 2021, eq. 15). It runs from the short-ring limit to that long-ring limit. With , its lift slope reads as below. At small angles that is its normal-force slope, here on the area , not the reference area, per radian:
is the tube’s mean diameter, its outer and inner radii added. For a paper tube it is within a few per cent of the inner diameter the other choice would give. Fletcher’s rings run from to 3. A longer tube rests on the formula alone, which the tests hold to its long-ring limit. A set of tubes takes times one tube’s slope, on the rocket’s reference area. Faster than Mach 0, it takes Göthert’s rule, the same idea as the fins’ Prandtl-Glauert factor. The slope is the one a ring times longer would have, over . That leaves the long-ring limit unchanged and scales the short-ring limit by .
The center of pressure. Fletcher measured where the lift of five rings acts (NACA TN 4117, 1957, Fig. 8, at Mach 0.13). HPR Sim reads it against the ring’s aspect ratio , interpolated in straight lines:
| aspect ratio | aerodynamic center, fraction of aft of the leading edge |
|---|---|
| 0 | 0 (theory) |
| 1/3 (thick ring) | −0.11 (left out) |
| 2/3 | 0.143 |
| 1 | 0.203 |
| 1.5 | 0.253 |
| 3 | 0.355 |
The table ends at , Fletcher’s shortest ring. Below the line runs to the leading edge at . That end point comes from slender-body theory, in which a long, thin ring’s lift all appears at its front edge. Hoerner and Borst assume the same of the air turned inside an open tube. They say it turns “at or near the rim of the inlet” (Hoerner and Borst 1985, p. 19-16). They write that they “do not have suitable experimental results at hand” on how an axial duct changes a slender body’s lift and moment.
Fletcher’s ring is left out, a judgment. Its center sits ahead of its leading edge. Fletcher puts that down to its low aspect ratio: such a ring behaves more like a slender body of revolution than the others (p. 4). That this would not carry over to a paper tube is HPR Sim’s inference, untested. His rings had a Clark Y section 11.7% of the chord thick, all of it outside a straight bore. At a chord of three bores that wall is 0.35 of the bore thick, so about two thirds of the ring’s frontal disc is wall. A paper tube’s is a few per cent. His thinner rings may carry some of the same forward shift. On the worked example below, the margin at rod clearance is:
| center rule | margin (calibers) |
|---|---|
| Fletcher’s point taken | 0.29 |
| the line to the leading edge (HPR Sim’s) | 0.79 |
| OpenRocket | 1.87 |
The 0.29 holds Fletcher’s −0.11 below , as the model’s first version did; it comes from a one-off run, not kept in the report.
The drag. Friction takes the inside and the outside of every tube, per tube, at the rocket’s skin-friction coefficient (Drag). The wall’s front ring, per tube, takes a square fin edge’s pressure drag. That is a blunt face at the front and base drag behind (Drag, eqs. 3.90 and 3.92).
Refused. HPR Sim refuses these cases rather than guess:
- Mach 0.8 and faster. No source covers tube fins near the speed of sound, where the flow through a tube can choke. A flight that reaches it stops with the tube-fin model’s error, even on an override table, which still takes the model’s tube stations and roll.
- Fewer than three tubes. The body’s own flow cancels in the sum only around three or more evenly spaced tubes.
- Solid tubes, with a wall as thick as the radius.
- Tube fins on a pod.
- A ring shorter than a third of its diameter (), past Fletcher’s rings.
- Tubes that overlap each other.
A tumbling airframe with tube fins stays refused too (Recovery).
Worked example. OpenRocket’s Tube fin rocket has six tubes 76.2 mm (3.0 in) long, of radius 12.395 mm (0.49 in) with a 0.330 mm (0.013 in) wall. They sit on a body of the same radius. Its tubes are just longer than Fletcher’s longest ring, and their center falls on the line below his , the judgment above.
| quantity | value |
|---|---|
| mean diameter | 24.46 mm (0.96 in) |
| 3.115 | |
| Weissinger’s on | 0.990 per radian, 98.1% of the long-ring limit |
| one tube’s slope, on the reference area 4.827 cm² | 3.82 per radian |
| the set’s, six tubes, at Mach 0 | 22.93 per radian |
| at Mach 0.35, its fastest | 22.96 per radian |
| center, at | , 5.2 mm (0.20 in) aft of the leading edge |
| friction area, six tubes inside and out | 145.6 times the reference area |
| wall area | 0.315 times the reference area |
| drag at Mach 0.2, friction and wall | 0.741 and 0.310, of the rocket’s 1.654 |
| OpenRocket 24.12’s slope for the set, at every Mach number | 37.85 per radian |
| OpenRocket’s center, to Mach 0.5 | , 19.05 mm (0.75 in) aft of the leading edge |
Against OpenRocket. The Tube fin rocket is in the flight report. Flown on HPR Sim’s own drag, its apogee is 6.95% above OpenRocket’s, 302.5 m (992 ft) against 282.8 m (928 ft). On OpenRocket’s recorded drag, HPR Sim’s apogee is within 0.03% of OpenRocket’s (ADR-097). So the net gap is the drag’s, though parts of it could cancel, and the rest of the flight agrees. OpenRocket’s per-component drag, read through its public API but not kept as a record, points to where. These are leads for #228, not measurements the repository reproduces:
- The nose, the body and the lug agree within 0.005.
- The tube fins take 1.18 in OpenRocket’s total and 1.05 in HPR Sim’s.
- Keeping the whole base while the motor burns, as OpenRocket does, closes 2.3 of the 6.95 points. This one is in the report: HPR Sim flew it. That rule is not specific to tube fins (#222).
HPR Sim’s tube-fin drag probably reads low. OpenRocket refined its tube-fin drag against measured flights of two tube-fin rockets. A table in a comment on the change that last revised it (openrocket#2066) has seven flights in five motor cases. OpenRocket’s apogee is within −2% to +5.2% of the measured one, and high in four of the five. HPR Sim has checked itself against no measured flight, and a code-to-code gap is not a measurement. Still, that is evidence OpenRocket’s drag is the nearer of the two here. #228 holds the search for a measured source.
The center of pressure against OpenRocket. The stability margin differs more. At rod clearance, the moment the rocket leaves the launch rod, HPR Sim’s margin is 0.79 calibers and OpenRocket’s 1.87. Almost all of that gap is the center of pressure: HPR Sim’s is 1.07 calibers forward of OpenRocket’s. The two centers of mass differ by 0.002 calibers. The tube fins’ center of pressure against OpenRocket is recorded in ADR-102.
OpenRocket 24.12’s answers for tube fins are kept as a
fixture,
openrocket-tube-fin-aero.json,
written by
tube_fin_aero.py.
It holds OpenRocket’s slope and center for the tubes and for the whole rocket, at five Mach
numbers. It covers the Tube fin rocket and 14 probe designs, each
changing one thing: the tubes’ length, count, radius or wall. The test
tube_fin_cp_against_the_oracle_measured_and_pinned
reads the same probes with HPR Sim and pins all 70 gaps. The record shows:
- The two codes agree on the probes’ geometry and on the nose and body. Given OpenRocket’s slope and center for the tubes, HPR Sim’s rocket has OpenRocket’s center of pressure within 0.01 calibers. So the whole gap is the tubes’.
- OpenRocket’s tubes lift 1.26 to 1.86 times what HPR Sim’s ring wings do, at every Mach number.
- Its lift per tube is the same whatever the number of tubes, so it models no interference that changes with the count. Slender-body theory with the body included predicts one, and it falls as tubes are added. An estimate is taken 0.005 tube radii from the body and still rises as that gap closes. The theory gives at least 1.96 times the lift of the same number of isolated rings for three tubes of 6 mm (0.24 in) radius. Six tubes of that radius give at least 1.57 times the lift of six isolated rings. Six touching each other give at least 1.13 (the estimate, #234) (evidence row G27). OpenRocket’s lift on the 6 mm (0.24 in) probes is 1.73 times the long-ring limit of isolated rings: below the estimate for three tubes. For six, the same estimate taken closer, and carried on to contact, is about 1.65, a little below OpenRocket’s.
- An independent solve reproduces that estimate, but nothing has measured it. A source-panel solve gives 1.971 for the three 6 mm (0.24 in) tubes against the estimate’s 1.96, and is within 1% on all six tube sets the estimate gives (the research note). No measured tube set beside a body was found, so the size isn’t bounded. For the three tubes, the solve’s factor falls from 1.971 at a gap of 0.005 tube radii to 1.40 at 0.25. HPR Sim leaves the interference out. If the rise is real, that keeps the stability margin cautious: applying it would move the center of pressure aft and raise the margin. Evidence row G27 waits on a measured tube fin (#679).
- OpenRocket puts the tubes’ center a quarter of their length aft of the leading edge up to Mach 0.5. Its maintainers describe that as the subsonic rule its flat fins and tube fins share (openrocket#3262).
On the probe built like the Tube fin rocket, six tubes 75 mm (3.0 in) long touching the body and each other:
| Mach | HPR Sim’s center of pressure less OpenRocket’s, calibers |
|---|---|
| 0.05 | −1.04 |
| 0.3 | −1.05 |
| 0.5 | −1.06 |
| 0.6 | −0.36 |
| 0.75 | −0.39 |
The Tube fin rocket itself, at rod clearance (Mach 0.056), gives −1.07. Its tubes are 76.2 mm (3.0 in) long and its nose and body differ a little from the probe’s.
From Mach 0.6 the gap shrinks only because OpenRocket 24.12 moves the tubes’ center to the leading edge. Its maintainers call that jump a bug and fixed it after 24.12 (openrocket#3235). The jump moves OpenRocket’s own center of pressure on the Tube fin rocket 0.73 calibers forward between Mach 0.5 and 0.6. It probably accounts for the five probe results, of 28 from Mach 0.6, that come within the lesson’s quarter caliber.
On that probe at Mach 0.05, giving HPR Sim’s tubes OpenRocket’s center but keeping their slope moves HPR Sim’s center of pressure 0.50 calibers aft. Giving them OpenRocket’s slope but keeping HPR Sim’s center moves it 0.53 calibers aft. Up to Mach 0.5, every probe’s gap is between 0.42 and 3.0 calibers.
HPR Sim keeps its model. Fletcher’s measured center moves forward, as a share of the ring’s length, as a ring gets longer. Nothing measured supports OpenRocket’s quarter length or its extra lift. HPR Sim’s own center for this rocket is unmeasured too: its tubes () are longer than every ring Fletcher measured. With his ring left out, their center comes from HPR Sim’s line from to the leading edge. Placed as his thick ring’s instead, it would give a margin of 0.29. Neither code has been checked against a measured tube-fin rocket, so which margin is nearer is open (#228). Until then, check a tube-fin design in both programs and treat the smaller of the two margins as the more cautious estimate. It is not a bound: the thick-ring reading above gives a smaller one still.
What it leaves out:
- How the body and the tubes change each other’s flow. Slender-body theory predicts that they raise each other’s lift, but HPR Sim applies no interference factor (#234).
- The gaps between tubes and body, and the drag where they meet.
- How the flow through a tube develops, or chokes.
- A thin tube’s measured center of pressure.
The rocket’s own crossflow, around a tube from its axis, turns with twice the roll angle. It sums to zero over three or more tubes evenly spaced, which is why the model takes three or more. That is a first-order derivation, not a measurement. It takes the body’s flow at each tube’s center and leaves out the rest of their effect on each other.
The normal force from RASAero II
A flight can use another program’s normal force and center of pressure in place of HPR Sim’s own. Today it is RASAero II, read from the table it exports. Use it to fly two programs on the same aerodynamics, so a difference between them comes from something else. Or use it to fly RASAero II’s numbers faster than sound, where HPR Sim’s own normal force is less tested (Fins through Mach 1).
The 0° column, which HPR Sim works out, agrees at 15 Mach numbers with the reading made for M1.8a. A rocket on a table swings in pitch and yaw as the small-angle equations of motion predict for the table’s slope and center of pressure. The assumptions past the export’s last angle and at 0° fit RASAero II’s viscous part through Mach 1.3. Faster, that part grows much more slowly with the angle.
Three parts are HPR Sim’s choices, not RASAero II’s:
- the damping, which stays HPR Sim’s own;
- the normal force past the export’s largest angle of attack (4° in the one export tested);
- the slope at 0°, where the export’s normal force is zero.
In code, two calls take a file to a flight:
NormalForceTable::from_rasaero_csvreads the text.Simulation::with_normal_force_tableflies it. Its documentation has a worked program.
The decisions are in the record on normal-force overrides, ADR-032. The milestone is M1.8d.
What the export holds
RASAero II’s Aero Plots screen exports a table to CSV (File, Export, To CSV File; [RAS] p. 76).
There is one row for each Mach number and angle of attack
(Alpha, in degrees). The Calisto export has rows at 0°, 2° and 4°. HPR Sim reads five of the
columns:
| column | what it is |
|---|---|
Mach, Alpha | the Mach number, and the angle of attack in degrees |
CN | the normal-force coefficient at that angle |
CN Potential | the part of CN from potential flow (the air treated as smooth and without friction), which grows in step with the angle |
CP | the center of pressure, in inches ([RAS] p. 13) measured from the nose tip (p. 114) |
CN also holds a viscous part, CN Viscous. It is the extra push, from the air’s friction, of
the air flowing sideways across the body. RASAero II takes it from Jorgensen’s method ([RAS] p. 55). RASAero II adds it from Mach 0.91 in Calisto’s export, and moves the center of pressure forward with
the angle. HPR Sim’s own model has neither. From Mach 0.91 through Mach 1.3 the viscous part grows
exactly as : at 4° it is times its value at 2°. Faster, it grows
more slowly: 3.90 times at Mach 1.5, 3.16 at Mach 2, 1.73 at Mach 3 and 1.05 at Mach 4. The export’s CNalpha (0 to 4 deg) and CP (0 to 4 deg) columns
repeat its 4° values on every row; HPR Sim doesn’t read them.
How the simulator reads it
HPR Sim builds one column for each angle in the export. Each column holds (the normal force over the angle, per radian) and the center of pressure, both against Mach number.
- At a positive angle, is
CNover the angle in radians. - At 0°,
CNis zero, so it can’t be divided. HPR Sim takesCN Potentialat the smallest positive angle, over that angle. The potential part grows in step with the angle: in Calisto’s export its is the same at 2° and 4° to 2e-15. Through Mach 1.3 the viscous part grows as , so it adds no slope at 0°. Faster, the export doesn’t show how it starts from 0°, and leaving it out of the slope is an assumption. - The center of pressure is converted from inches to meters at 0.0254 m (0.083 ft) to the inch. It stays measured from the nose tip, as HPR Sim’s stations are (station). So the design must start at the same nose tip as the RASAero II file. A table is refused if its center of pressure lies outside the rocket, ahead of its nose or behind its tail. The check runs at each of its Mach numbers up to 5 (where a flight stops). Such a center is the sign of a length in the wrong unit.
- Reference area. RASAero II’s coefficients are on the body’s largest cross-section ([RAS] p. 72). HPR Sim records that and rescales them to the rocket’s own reference area, when that is something else. For a rocket of several stages, export the whole stack (“Sustainer plus Booster” or “All Stages”): HPR Sim flies the whole stack.
A flight looks up the table at its Mach number and angle of attack:
- Within one column, the values are linear in Mach number. Outside a column’s range the end values hold, and the lookup says so.
- Between two columns, and the center of pressure are linear in the angle. Then comes back exactly at each column’s angle. Between them it is a part in step with the angle plus one in its square. That is RASAero II’s own shape through Mach 1.3 ( is within 0.2% of to 4°), and an assumption faster than that.
- Past the largest angle , the normal force splits in two. The linear share is the slope at 0° times , at the 0° center of pressure. The share grows as , as HPR Sim’s own fins do (Aerodynamics in flight). The rest of the force, with the rest of the moment, grows as . This is the form of the air crossing the body that HPR Sim’s body lift also takes ([G] p. 1; [N09] eq. 3.26). The force and center of pressure are continuous at , and the force is zero when the air comes from the tail. Two limits keep this sensible for any table. The rest’s center of pressure is held within the rocket. And a table whose falls with the angle has no rest: its whole force grows as , so the force never turns round. Neither limit makes a jump as the Mach number changes. Either way this is an assumption, and the lookup reports it.
A worked example. Take an export with invented numbers. At Mach 1, CN Potential is 10 per radian times the angle. CN Viscous is 0.03 at 2° and 0.12 at 4°. The center of pressure is
50, 49 and 48 inches at 0°, 2° and 4°. These are the numbers in the CSV reader’s unit test,
reads_a_rasaero_export_by_angle_of_attack.
| angle | normal-force coefficient CN | , per rad | center of pressure |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0° | 0 | 10.000 (CN Potential at 2° over 2°) | 1.2700 m (4.167 ft) |
| 2° | 0.37907 | 10.8594 | 1.2446 m (4.083 ft) |
| 3° (looked up) | 0.59110 | 11.2892, halfway between 2° and 4° | 1.2319 m (4.042 ft) |
| 4° | 0.81813 | 11.7189 | 1.2192 m (4.000 ft) |
| 10° (past the table) | 2.4815 | 14.2180 | 1.1662 m (3.826 ft) |
At 10°, is 2.4893. The linear share, 10 × 0.069813 = 0.69813 at 1.2700 m (4.167 ft), grows to 1.7379. The rest, 0.12 at 0.9237 m (3.031 ft, the station that gives the 4° moment), grows by to 0.7436. Together they make 2.4815 at 1.1662 m (3.826 ft): the center of pressure moves forward with the angle, as RASAero II’s does. The first draft scaled the whole 0.81813 by 2.4893 at 1.2192 m (4.000 ft) instead. That gave 2.0366, 18% less force, with the center of pressure 5.3 cm (2.1 in) further aft. That reads the rocket as more stable than the viscous part makes it.
In a flight
The flight takes the table’s normal force at the center of mass’s airflow and applies it at the table’s center of pressure.
The export has no damping, so HPR Sim keeps its own (Rigid-body flight). The table gives the force as if the rocket weren’t turning. When it turns, each part meets the air at a slightly different angle, and HPR Sim adds that difference: it is the damping. When the rocket isn’t turning, the difference is exactly zero.
The flight still stops at Mach 5, where HPR Sim’s own parts, which give the damping, end. The table gives no side force: RASAero II’s rockets are symmetric.
How it was checked
| check | result | where the numbers are |
|---|---|---|
| Calisto’s export, every row at 2° and 4° read again apart from the library | 4,999 rows; CN within 2.2e-16 relative, CP exact; columns at 0°, 2° and 4° of 2,500, 2,500 and 2,499 Mach numbers, from Mach 0.01 to 25 (24.99 at 4°) | normal-force-override.json |
The 0° column at 15 Mach numbers against the reading of the export made for M1.8a, the normal force through Mach 1, which normal-force-vs-mach.json holds | the same to 1e-12 relative. That reading applies the same 0° rule, so this checks the reading, not the rule | both files |
| Valetudo at 100 m/s (328 ft/s) on a table of 1.5 times HPR Sim’s slope with the center of pressure 5 cm (2.0 in) further aft, against the small-angle equations of motion, in pitch and in yaw | period 1.104077 s against 1.104073 s, within the test’s 3e-5 (1.44965 s on HPR Sim’s own); the decay within 0.03%, the test’s bound 1% | hpr_sim::tests::pitch_oscillation_follows_a_normal_force_table |
| Tables of HPR Sim’s own normal force flown in a crosswind: every 0.5° and every Mach 0.01, and at 0°, 2° and 4° only, where the flight uses the continuation past 4° | apogee within 7.8 mm (0.31 in) and 5.5 cm (2.2 in) of HPR Sim’s own flight, the test’s bounds 5 cm (2.0 in) and 10 cm (3.9 in) | hpr_sim::tests::a_table_of_hpr_s_own_normal_force_flies_as_hpr_does |
| The continuation past the last angle: a table shaped as RASAero II’s (a part linear in the angle, one as ), and random tables | the part continues to 1e-12; the force never turns round, the center of pressure stays within the rocket, and nothing jumps as the table’s values change with Mach number | hpr_aero::table::tests |
| Calisto from a 5.2 m (17 ft) rail at 85° in a 5 m/s (16 ft/s) crosswind, up to Mach 0.747: on the export, on HPR Sim’s own normal force, and on HPR Sim’s own as a table at the export’s angles | the export: apogee 2,827.09 m (9,275.2 ft) against 2,828.21 m (9,278.9 ft), 12.6 m (41 ft) further into the wind. HPR Sim’s own as a table moves it 0.02 m (0.066 ft): the table’s method, apart from its numbers. Each flight spends 2.2 to 2.3 s past 4° before apogee | normal-force-override.json |
The Calisto flights show how much the change matters. They are not a check of accuracy: nothing
measured flew. cargo xtask aero writes the fixture from the export, which isn’t committed, and
checks it again wherever the export is present. CI has no copy of the export. There, a test checks
that the fixture’s 0° values agree with the ones committed for
M1.8a, and flies the 15-point table again.
What it leaves out:
- No real export has been flown through Mach 1. Calisto peaks at Mach 0.75. The reader’s unit tests cover the transonic columns.
- Past the export’s largest angle, the split continuation is HPR Sim’s assumption. In a 5 m/s (16 ft/s) crosswind Calisto flies past 4° for about 0.3 s just after leaving the rail (up to 7.9°). In that crosswind it flies past 4° again for the last 1.9 s before apogee, as it slows below 30 m/s (98 ft/s). Its export has no viscous part below Mach 0.91, so Calisto’s flights use only the linear share. The flights on tables of HPR Sim’s own normal force are the ones that grow a rest as . From Mach 3, where RASAero II’s viscous part grows far less than does between 2° and 4° (1.73 times at Mach 3, 1.05 at Mach 4), the share probably gives too much force.
- The nose tip can’t be checked from the export beyond the refusal above. A design that starts somewhere else gets a shifted center of pressure, with no warning.
- Only RASAero II’s layout is read. A table from anywhere else can be built in code with
NormalForceTable::new.
Drag
Code: hpr_aero::drag (the terms),
AeroModel::drag and
AeroModel::buildup_components
(their sum over a rocket), hpr_aero::table (override tables),
hpr_design::Finish (roughness).
Decisions: ADR-009 (drag buildup, surface finishes and override tables). Extra sources:
- [B67] ch. 4 (pp. 43–62): the friction, roughness and leading-edge formulas Niskanen adopts, and Table 4-1 of roughness heights (p. 46, after Hoerner p. 5-3).
- [N09] §3.4 (pp. 41–53) and appendix B (pp. 106–110). [TD] reprints the same drag equations and tables unchanged.
On this page is the zero-lift drag coefficient: the drag with the air straight along the axis, divided by . Recovery uses the same symbol for something else: a parachute canopy’s drag coefficient on its nominal area.
Drag is built up term by term. Skin friction acts over the whole surface. Pressure drag acts on noses and shoulders (here, a transition that widens toward the tail) and on boattails (one that narrows). Base drag acts on the flat aft end and fin pressure drag on the fins’ edges. Parasitic drag acts on launch lugs and rail buttons ([N09] eq. 3.75, 3.97). Each pressure, base and parasitic term acts on its own area:
The axial coefficient is .
| symbol | meaning | unit |
|---|---|---|
| the zero-lift drag coefficient: the drag with the air straight along the axis, divided by | none | |
| its skin-friction part | none | |
| , | the area one pressure, base or parasitic term acts on (a nose’s base, the fins’ front edges), and its coefficient on that area | m², none |
| , | the axial coefficient (the drag along the axis at an angle of attack), and the factor that turns into it | none |
| , , , | the Reynolds number, the airspeed, the rocket’s length and the air’s kinematic viscosity | none, m/s, m, m²/s |
| , | the surface’s roughness height, set by its finish; the Reynolds number above which roughness, not , sets the friction | m, none |
| , | the skin-friction coefficient, before and after its correction for Mach number | none |
| the body’s fineness ratio: its length over its largest diameter | none | |
| , | the areas friction acts on (see Friction on the axial projection) | m² |
| a fin’s thickness | m | |
| (nose and shoulder row) | the joint angle between the surface and the axis where a nose or shoulder meets the next component: 0 for a smooth joint, for a step. Not the flow roll | rad |
| , , , | a boattail’s length over its drop in diameter, from at its fore end to at its aft end | none, m |
| the base drag coefficient (the base row) | none | |
| the pressure rise where the air comes to rest on a blunt face, over ; 1 at low speed | none | |
| a fin’s leading-edge sweep | rad | |
| the fins’ frontal area: fin count × thickness × span | m² | |
| , , | a launch lug’s outer and inner radii, and its length over its outer diameter | m, none |
| square, rounded, airfoil | a fin’s cross-section: constant thickness with square edges; semicircular leading and trailing edges; or a NACA four-digit symmetric airfoil |
| term | formula | area | source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reynolds number | , nose tip to aft end of the last body component | [N09] eq. 3.12, p. 42 | |
| skin friction | for ; to ; from it | [N09] eq. 3.78–3.81, [B67] eq. 4-4–4-8 | |
| roughness limit | [N09] eq. 3.79, [B67] eq. 4-7 | ||
| compressibility | for ; turbulent and rough (not below turbulent) above | [N09] eq. 3.82–3.84 | |
| friction drag | below the table | body: ; fins: both sides | [N09] eq. 3.85 |
| nose, shoulder | at rest, the joint angle at the aft end; through Mach 1 as under Drag through Mach 1 | base area; increase in area | [N09] eq. 3.86–3.87, appendix B |
| boattail | to Mach 0.8, × 1 (), , 0 (); ; faster, as under Boattails faster than sound | decrease in area | [N09] eq. 3.88; [762] Fig. 5-122 |
| base | below Mach 1, above; behind a boattail, times its base-pressure ratio: to Mach 0.8, then Boattails faster than sound | aft base less thrusting motors | [N09] eq. 3.94, p. 50; [S61] p. 11; [762] Fig. 5-141 |
| fin leading edge | square: ; rounded, airfoil: (to 0.9), (to 1), ; times | [N09] eq. 3.89–3.91, B.2 | |
| fin trailing edge | square: base; rounded: half base; airfoil: 0 | [N09] eq. 3.92–3.93 | |
| stagnation pressure | below Mach 1; above, below the table | [N09] eq. B.1 | |
| launch lug | below the table | below the table | [N09] eq. 3.95–3.96 |
| rail button | (a rail pin) | side profile | [N09] p. 52 |
| angle of attack | , ; , ; past 90° | [N09] §3.4.7 (conditions only) |
The friction drag, on the areas in its row:
The stagnation pressure above Mach 1:
A launch lug’s coefficient, then the area it acts on:
- Roughness.
hpr_design::Finishnames the fifteen rows of [B67] Table 4-1 (0 to 1,000 µm; [N09] Table 3.2 reprints ten) or takes a custom height. The default is “paint in aircraft mass production”, 20 µm. Each component has its own finish; the Reynolds number and use the whole rocket’s length, as [N09] does (Loft lesson L12). Loft cited none of its values. Its 60 µm is OpenRocket’s “regular paint” ([N09] p. 83), and its 2 µm is [B67]’s sheet-metal row, which [N09] leaves out. Its is Raymer’s aircraft fuselage form factor, not [N09]’s. - Fully turbulent. The boundary layer (the thin layer of air the skin drags along) is taken as turbulent everywhere, never laminar (smooth and layered). [N09] p. 43 found laminar runs changed apogee by under 5% and dropped them. Eq. 3.81’s branch applies first, even on surfaces rough enough that .
- Friction jumps where [N09] does. Eq. 3.79 is not where eq. 3.78 and 3.80 cross, so eq. 3.81 jumps at . The jump is +9% for 60 µm on a 1 m (3.3 ft) rocket (0.00419 to 0.00458). The subsonic and supersonic corrections also differ at Mach 1 (0.900 against 0.922 turbulent). HPR Sim keeps the published forms, and the tests pin both jumps (Loft lesson L90).
- Friction on the axial projection (a departure). Wall shear (the air’s drag on the skin, per unit area) acts along the surface. So on an element of area at an angle to the axis, its axial share is . The body’s friction area is rather than the slant surface in [N09] eq. 3.85. On slender noses the difference is small: a tangent ogive loses 1.1% of its own friction area at fineness 3 and 2.4% at fineness 2. On a short, steep shoulder it removes friction on what is nearly a flat face. So a shoulder’s drag tends to a bare step’s as its length goes to zero (Loft lesson L15). With the slant surface it would stay about above it. The OpenRocket comparison (M2.2) will measure the difference.
- Steps in radius. Where one body component meets the next with a different radius, a step up is a zero-length shoulder. It is a flat face ( at rest, rising with Mach as under Drag through Mach 1). A step down is a zero-length boattail, the base drag of the uncovered area. A body with no nose cone gets the same flat face on its front. Each is the limit of the transition it replaces (Loft lesson L15), and it is reported with the aft component. A step up just behind a step down is sheltered by the step’s corner at every speed. An example is a motor retainer behind the step to the motor tube. The shelter depends on how far the step up rises and how much motor tube shows ahead of it. It is gone once the motor tube showing ahead of the step is as long as the step’s drop in diameter. This is unmeasured. For a 98 mm (3.9 in) airframe with a 62 mm (2.4 in) retainer, 12 mm (0.47 in) of a 54 mm motor tube shows. There the shelter lowers the rocket’s 12% to 23% from Mach 0.3 to 2.5 (Boattails faster than sound).
- Boattails. [N09] eq. 3.88 writes without defining the areas, and p. 48 says a zero-length boattail drags like “the total base drag”. Taking as the aft base would count that base twice and leave out the uncovered ring (annulus). So HPR Sim reads both as the boattail’s decrease in area (Calisto’s boattail: 0.052, against 0.046 the other way). The joint angle is at the aft end, where a curved transition ends in a blunt tip. A lip (a short step up or flare) just behind a boattail or a step down is in its wake at every speed. From Mach 0.8 a boattail’s drag rises to its supersonic wave drag (Boattails faster than sound).
- Base drag under power subtracts the thrusting motors’ cross-section from the aft base, down to zero ([N09] pp. 50–51; Loft lesson L13). Eq. 3.94 is on p. 50. On p. 51, “if the base is the same size as the motor itself, no base drag” is Niskanen’s rule from Fleeman’s Tactical Missile Design. On the Hermes A-3A’s measured flight below
Mach 0.8, whose motor case is wider than its base, this rule leaves no base drag under power and
reads low; given only the nozzle exit it reads high, as OpenRocket’s below does. The jet more
than doubled the base drag, where this rule lowers it
(Base drag under power against the Hermes A-3A’s flight). On one private design’s supersonic flight,
C06/1, the choice moves HPR Sim’s apogee difference from OpenRocket’s from +13.60% to −10.71%. That is about 24 percentage points, more than any other known cause (#222, open on both this and the supersonic pressure drag).DragConditions::thrusting(reynolds_per_m, motor_area_m2)takes the cross-section of the burning motors from the flight engine (zero when unknown: no relief). The base belongs to the last body component.- OpenRocket’s rule, for comparisons. OpenRocket 24.12 does not take the motor off. While a
motor burns, its base drag is the whole base’s. A committed probe measures this.
validation/oracles/openrocket/base_drag.pyrecords OpenRocket’s base drag on its own example designs, the rows while a motor burns against the rows after, invalidation/fixtures/ork/openrocket-base-drag.json. A test inhpr-validateholds it (ADR-097, the decision on sizing a drag cause). On all 42 of its flights of one data branch (nothing separating), the base drag under power is exactly the whole base’s, to 1e-12. Their motors cover 9% to 94% of the reference area, and one flight’s motors are in pods. On a rocket whose motor fills most of the base, the rule is a large difference under power. OnC06/1, switching HPR Sim to OpenRocket’s base rule alone lowers its apogee from +13.60% to −10.71%, 24.3 percentage points. Switching the rest of the drag to OpenRocket’s then raises it to +1.11%, 11.8 percentage points. The second number is by subtraction, and the split depends on which change is made first (a supersonic flight).AeroModel::with_full_base_drag_under_power()andSimulation::with_full_base_drag_under_power()fly OpenRocket’s rule. A sustainer lit after a powered separation keeps it. They exist to size a difference from OpenRocket, not as a better model. HPR Sim keeps Niskanen’s rule of taking the motor’s area off the base by default. - Supersonic pressure drag against OpenRocket. Faster than sound, the pressure on the nose, the fins’ edges and any step is mostly wave drag. On that flight HPR Sim’s supersonic pressure drag is about twice OpenRocket’s. OpenRocket gives the nose almost none well above Mach 1, and the fins about a quarter of HPR Sim’s. Which is right is open, since neither has been checked against a measurement on that shape (#222). A public probe has since recorded the nose’s part: OpenRocket 24.12’s is a confirmed defect (a tangent ogive past Mach 1).
- OpenRocket’s rule, for comparisons. OpenRocket 24.12 does not take the motor off. While a
motor burns, its base drag is the whole base’s. A committed probe measures this.
- Fins. Each fin set is its own term with its own thickness, chord and cross-section, so their order doesn’t matter (Loft lesson L11). is the mean aerodynamic chord and the leading-edge sweep. The sweep is for a trapezoid and the span average for freeform outlines ([N09] p. 50). For an ellipse it is , (the closed-form average, with its form for ). The drag goes as , whose span average is 6% lower than of the average angle for an ellipse of . Fin-body interference drag and tip vortices are neglected ([N09] p. 41).
- Launch lugs. in eq. 3.95–3.96 is taken as the outer diameter. [N09] p. 52 treats a solid
rail pin as a lug “with a length equal to its diameter”. That fits only the outer diameter (Loft lesson L14). A row of
countlugs iscountlugs. Rail buttons follow [N09]’s rail-pin rule on their side profile (base and flange at the outer diameter, waist at the inner). - Angle of attack (derived coefficients). [N09] §3.4.7 describes, without an equation, a two-part polynomial taking 1 at 0°, 1.3 at 17° and 0 at 90°, with zero slope at each. HPR Sim uses the unique cubic on each part that meets those four conditions. is positive toward the tail. Past 90° the flow meets the tail, and HPR Sim mirrors with the sign reversed, , an assumption that keeps drag opposing the motion. The planned OpenRocket comparison (M2.2) will check it against OpenRocket, whose polynomial may differ.
- Refusals, not clamps (Loft lesson L16). Geometry the terms can’t use is an error naming the component. Examples are a lug wall
thicker than its radius and a button’s base and flange taller than the button. Another is a negative roughness,
which
Rocket::layoutalready refuses. A coasting condition (no motor burning) with a motor area is an error, and so is a non-finite result. Large coefficients are returned as they are. - Override tables (
DragTable) replace HPR Sim’s own with curves of against Mach number from another tool, power-off and power-on. They are read from CSV text in one of two layouts. One is two columns, optionally under a header (RocketPy’s curves;\r\n, a byte-order mark and01.05accepted). The other is a header naming the column, with rows at non-zeroAlphaskipped (RASAero II’s export:Mach, Alpha, CD, CD Power-Off, CD Power-On, …). An identical repeated row is skipped; a Mach number repeated with another value, or out of order, is refused with its line, not sorted. Tables interpolate linearly and hold their end values;Drag::tablereports any extrapolation.DragConditions::thrustingselects the power-on curve. A table’sreference_diameter_m, when set, rescales it to the rocket’s reference area. The angle-of-attack factor still applies, and an override accepts any Mach number.AeroModel::buildup_componentsalways reports the buildup, table or not. The normal force has a table of its own (The normal force from RASAero II).
A part’s stated drag coefficient
A part’s or stage’s stated drag coefficient flies as OpenRocket 24.12 flies it. The change it makes to the rocket’s drag is within 0.0059 of OpenRocket’s on 25 probe designs. The exceptions are lugs and buttons, up to 0.072, HPR Sim’s own lug and button drag being higher. Faster than Mach 0.6, a nose or a boattail is an exception too. This checks the rule, not the rocket’s whole drag, and the stated number itself is the designer’s.
OpenRocket lets a part say its own drag coefficient, in place of the drag its shape gives (the
Override tab’s drag coefficient, saved as <overridecd>). Designers use it for a part whose
drag they measured, and for “hacks”. One is OpenRocket’s Base drag hack example, which hangs a
weightless, dragless cone behind the rocket to make OpenRocket count a second
base. HPR Sim reads the setting from a .ork into
DragOverride, a part’s or stage’s
drag_override. OpenRocket’s documentation names the checkbox but not what it replaces. So the rule below was measured on 25 probe designs
(drag_override.py;
ADR-167, a part’s drag override as OpenRocket flies it).
- The coefficient is on the rocket’s reference area, the same at every Mach number. It is counted once per instance: per fin of a fin set, per lug or button.
- It replaces all of the part’s own drag: friction, pressure drag, and the base drag of its aft face. That covers the rocket’s base and a step down to a narrower part behind it. A step up at its fore end is its own face too. A step down just ahead of it stays: that is the aft face of the part in front.
- With override for all subcomponents (the design’s
include_children), the parts attached to it have no drag of their own. - On a part inside the body (an inner tube, a ring, a mass) it does nothing; such a part has no drag anyway. On a stage it is added to the rocket’s drag, or, covering its children, it is all of the stage’s drag.
- HPR Sim refuses by name what OpenRocket wasn’t measured on. Those are a coefficient on a pod set, on a part in a pod, on a tube fin set, or covering a pod set.
A worked example. OpenRocket’s Base drag hack (short-wide) is a nose, a body tube 78.7 mm (3.1 in) across, and a cone behind it. The 247 mm (9.7 in) cone widens from a point back to the tube’s diameter. The cone is stated at 0. HPR Sim’s at Mach 0.3, from the example file:
| term | drag coefficient (without the setting) | drag coefficient (with it) |
|---|---|---|
| the cone’s friction | 0.030 | 0 |
| the cone’s pressure drag, as it widens | 0.020 | 0 |
| the cone’s own base, a second base | 0.132 | 0 |
| the tube’s base, the step down to the cone’s point | 0.132 | 0.132 (the tube’s aft face, so it stays) |
| the nose’s and tube’s friction | 0.062 | 0.062 |
| fins and lug | 0.015 | 0.015 |
| total | 0.390 (rounded terms sum to 0.391) | 0.209 |
Checked against OpenRocket. On every probe, the change in the rocket’s drag from the same
airframe with nothing stated is held to OpenRocket’s
(a_stated_drag_coefficient_moves_the_drag_as_openrocket_s).
The stated number is the same in both, so what differs is each code’s own drag of the parts it
replaces.
| probes | held to | a wrong rule would move it by |
|---|---|---|
| bodies, at every Mach number | 0.0065 (largest 0.0059) | 0.043 or more: a step charged to the wrong part |
| a nose or a boattail stated | 0.0065, up to Mach 0.6 | the same |
| lugs and buttons stated | 0.075 | 0.5: one counted once, not per instance |
| a tube covering its children | 0.0065, less the lugs’ and buttons’ own gaps | 0.03 or more: a lug or button left uncovered |
| a stage covering its children | exactly 0.5 in both | anything left uncovered |
| fins | 1e-4 | 1.0: three fins counted once |
| a stage alone, an inner part | 1e-9 | none |
Faster than Mach 0.6, the two codes’ own drag of a nose and a boattail differs by up to 0.21 and 0.061. That is the drag buildups’ difference, not the setting’s.
What it leaves out. When an aft part is stated, OpenRocket also raises the friction of the parts left. On the Base drag hack example the rise is 6.8% of their friction (about 1% of its ), as though the body were shorter. HPR Sim keeps each part’s friction as its shape gives it: the parts are all still there.
On the example’s flights. With recovery in both, Base drag hack reads +1.95% and +4.52% on OpenRocket’s apogee on C11-5 and D12-3 motors, and +7.80% on an E12-4 (the report’s descent.apogee_m, tabled). Flown on OpenRocket’s
own drag curve, HPR Sim comes within 0.1% of OpenRocket’s flight with nothing deployed. So what is
left is the drag coefficient: by OpenRocket’s breakdown, the stubby ellipsoid nose (0.58 calibers long). OpenRocket gives it 0.064 at Mach 0.3. HPR Sim gives it 0.0008, read off a straight line
between Hoerner’s two measured round heads. These are a hemisphere at 0.01 and a longer head at −0.05
(blunt ellipsoids). A one-off probe, not committed, found that
about 0.013 to 0.015 would bring the E12-4 within 5%, more than the hemisphere’s 0.01. The gap
stays, and the 5% bar is not met. Nothing here measures which program’s nose drag is nearer the truth. But the measurement puts a head this long at or below the hemisphere’s (ADR-173,
a blunt ellipsoid’s measured drag; #177).
Drag through Mach 1
Near the speed of sound a nose starts to push shock waves ahead, and the pressure on its
surface climbs: the transonic drag rise. Past Mach 1 this pressure drag, called
wave drag, settles
to a value set mostly by the nose’s shape and how slender it is. HPR Sim follows Niskanen’s method
([N09] §3.4.3 and appendix B, pp. 47–48 and 106–110) for noses, shoulders and steps. The other
terms already had faster-than-sound forms in the table above. These are friction’s Mach correction,
base drag’s , the fins’ leading and trailing edges, and the stagnation pressure on blunt
faces. The code is hpr_aero::nose_drag; the decision
record is ADR-028. How far it holds against a wind tunnel is under
Verification. In the tunnel HPR Sim’s drag reads high at every row: least with fins on at Mach 1.0, most with fins on past Mach 1.2.
A nose’s or shoulder’s pressure-drag coefficient, on the area it adds, has three parts:
- At rest, eq. 3.86’s , with the joint angle at the aft end (the table above). A step, or a bare front face, has no length, and takes the flat face’s at every Mach number instead (below).
- From , the Mach number where the transonic formula takes over, a transonic and supersonic value . is 0.8 or 1 by shape, in the table below. An ellipsoid has its own curve at every Mach number. depends on the shape and the fineness ratio . For a nose, is its length over its base diameter. For a shoulder, it is its length over its rise in diameter, so a conical shoulder drags like the cone with the same surface angle.
- Between rest and , eq. 3.87: , with and chosen so the curve meets and its slope at : and . Here . Niskanen asks for a curve that doesn’t fall and is flat at rest, which needs and ; otherwise HPR Sim uses a quadratic (below). With near 10, as for slender cones, the curve stays close to its value at rest until about Mach 0.8.
| shape | source | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| step up in radius, or a bare front face | a flat face: , at every Mach number | n/a | [N09] eq. B.1–B.2 |
| cone | at Mach 1 with slope ; from Mach 1.3; a cubic between, meeting both ends’ values and slopes; | 1 | [N09] eq. B.3–B.6 |
| ogive | the cone of the same length and diameter, times , the tangent ogive’s arc radius over this one’s (0 for a cone, 1 for a tangent ogive) | 1 | [N09] eq. B.8 |
| power series, parabolic series, Haack series | Stoney’s measured curve at fineness 3, , scaled to the nose’s fineness by , , with the flat face’s | 0.8 | [N09] eq. B.7, B.9; [S61] Fig. 12 |
| elliptical | below Mach 0.8, Hoerner’s low-speed forebody drag, interpolated in fineness; from Mach 1.2, Stoney’s ellipsoid scaled as above; a straight line between (blunt ellipsoids, below) | none: its own curve throughout | [H65] p. 3-12, Fig. 20; [N09] eq. B.9; [S61] Fig. 12; ADR-173 |
Here is the ratio of specific heats of air and the stagnation-pressure ratio of the table above. The fineness scaling is the curve through a flat face at fineness 0 and the measured nose at fineness 3 (eq. B.7). Stoney’s report suggested that fineness and Mach number act separately ([N09] p. 108).
Stoney’s curves. Stoney’s 1961 NASA report collected the drag of about 200 bodies flown on
rockets at NASA Langley ([S61]). Its Figure 12 plots the pressure drag of noses of fineness 3
against Mach number. Panel (a) is from flight models, Mach 0.8 to 2.0; panel (b), from a wind tunnel (his ref. 30), to Mach 3.6. No table prints them, so HPR Sim carries them as points read off
a 600-dpi scan of the figure, to about ±0.0015. Each panel’s grid is calibrated where the curve runs.
HPR Sim takes panel (a) for the seven shapes it has, and panel (b) for the and the ellipsoid,
which only it has. Where (a) and (b) overlap, (b)’s von Kármán reads 0.004 to 0.011 higher from
Mach 1.2. Past a curve’s last point HPR Sim holds its last value. Panel (b) checks two of those holds. Its von Kármán reads 0.079 to 0.086 from Mach 2.4 to 3.59, against panel (a)’s held 0.079. Its falls to 0.073 by Mach 3.2, 8% under the held 0.079. Panel (a)’s is still
rising at its end. The and the ellipsoid, which panel (b) starts at Mach 1.2, are joined by a
straight line to 0 at Mach 0.8. Every smooth 3:1 nose of panel (a) reads 0 there, so every measured
shape starts at Mach 0.8. An elliptical nose of another fineness draws its own line, after the
scaling, from its low-speed value, held to Mach 0.8
(blunt ellipsoids). The points and where each was read
are in the code (StoneyNose). A sample of the pressure
drag coefficient, on the nose’s base area (panel (a)’s values at Mach 3.0 are its held end values):
| Mach | von Kármán coefficient | L-V Haack coefficient | parabola coefficient | ¾ parabola coefficient | ½ parabola coefficient | coefficient | coefficient | coefficient | ellipsoid coefficient |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.9 | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.000 | 0.015 | 0.013 | 0.000 | n/a | n/a |
| 1.0 | 0.025 | 0.025 | 0.037 | 0.069 | 0.094 | 0.085 | 0.046 | n/a | n/a |
| 1.2 | 0.076 | 0.100 | 0.116 | 0.104 | 0.114 | 0.109 | 0.080 | 0.141 | 0.111 |
| 1.5 | 0.089 | 0.116 | 0.108 | 0.082 | 0.088 | 0.093 | 0.086 | 0.181 | 0.151 |
| 2.0 | 0.079 | 0.112 | 0.107 | 0.081 | 0.086 | 0.079 | 0.090 | 0.216 | 0.158 |
| 3.0 | 0.079 | 0.112 | 0.107 | 0.081 | 0.086 | 0.079 | 0.090 | 0.246 | 0.160 |
Stoney’s model numbers: von Kármán 58, L-V Haack 60, parabola 59, ¾ parabola 62, ½ parabola 57, 61, 63.
A shape between two measured ones interpolates between their curves in its parameter, before the fineness scaling ([N09] p. 108). The parameter is the exponent , or of Shapes. A power series runs through a flat face (), , , and the 3:1 cone (). A parabolic series runs through the 3:1 cone () and the ½, ¾ and full parabolas. A Haack series runs between von Kármán () and L-V Haack ().
Worked example. A 5:1 von Kármán nose at Mach 1.5. Stoney’s 3:1 von Kármán gives 0.0893. The flat face gives
The exponent is , so the nose drags
on its base area. A 5:1 cone drags 0.0653 there, from
eq. B.4, so the von Kármán’s wave drag is 38% lower. The test
nose_drag::tests::the_guides_worked_example pins these numbers.
Where HPR Sim departs from, or adds to, the source (ADR-028):
- Short cones and ogives. Below fineness 1 the cone formula runs past a flat face’s drag. As the cone flattens, eq. B.4 tends to 2.39 at Mach 2 against the flat face’s 1.41. So below fineness 1 HPR Sim scales between a flat face at fineness 0 and the whole curve of the cone at fineness 1. It does so at every Mach number, as eq. B.9 scales the measured shapes. A shoulder then tends to a bare step as it shortens (Loft lesson L15), and above fineness 1 Niskanen’s cone is unchanged.
- Steps. A step up in radius, or a body with no nose cone, is a flat face, the blunt cylinder’s at every Mach number. The value is 0.85 at rest, 0.9947 at Mach 0.8, 1.0888 at Mach 1 and 1.4118 at Mach 2. Eq. 3.86 “does not take into account the effect of extremely blunt nose cones (length less than half of the diameter)” ([N09] p. 47). A step has no length, so eq. 3.86 does not cover it. Before M1.8b1 it was eq. 3.86’s 0.8 at every speed.
- Blunt ellipsoids. An elliptical nose has its own curve below Mach 1.2, from Hoerner’s measurement (blunt ellipsoids).
- Where eq. 3.87 has no solution. An nose meets its tube at a small angle, so it has some drag at rest. But Stoney’s measured curve is still at 0 at Mach 0.8, so no can rise from the first to the second. Eq. 3.87 needs the transonic value above the value at rest and . Where either fails, HPR Sim goes from the value at rest to along instead. That curve is continuous, flat at rest, with a kink at . Falling, as here, it follows Stoney’s measurement rather than Niskanen’s assumption that the curve doesn’t fall; the coefficients are below 0.01. Rising, it serves near-flat noses. A power series has almost nothing at rest by eq. 3.86, which leaves bluntness out, and rises along it to 0.80 at Mach 0.8.
- Refused shapes. A bulged secant ogive (its arc radius below the tangent ogive’s) is outside eq. B.8. A Haack series past is outside Stoney’s data (Niskanen limits it the same way, p. 103). The drag buildup refuses both, naming the component, when asked for drag. The model still builds, so the normal force, the center of pressure and a drag table work.
Blunt ellipsoids below Mach 0.8
This covers an elliptical nose’s pressure drag below Mach 1.2 (ADR-173, a blunt ellipsoid’s measured drag). Stoney’s ellipsoid curve is 0 at Mach 0.8, and eq. B.9 keeps it 0 at any fineness. So before, an ellipsoid nearly as blunt as a flat face got no drag below Mach 0.8, though a flat face gets 0.85. Hoerner measured the forebody pressure drag of round heads on a cylinder at low speed, from their pressure distributions ([H65] p. 3-12, Fig. 20). HPR Sim now uses it:
- A hemisphere (0.5 calibers long) reads 0.01, and a round head about one caliber long −0.05. The suction on its shoulder outweighs the stagnation pressure at its tip.
- Between them, a straight line, falling 0.12 per caliber past the hemisphere. It crosses 0 at 7/12 caliber, and HPR Sim holds it there, since it never charges a negative pressure drag.
- Blunter than a hemisphere, eq. B.9’s form between the flat face (, 0.85 at Mach 0) and the hemisphere’s 0.01. This is HPR Sim’s interpolation: nothing in Fig. 20 measures an ellipsoid between the two.
- From the hemisphere up, the value holds to Mach 0.8, and blunter heads follow the flat face’s rise with Mach number. That is HPR Sim’s assumption. The measurement is at low speed, and the drag rise begins near the critical Mach number, about 0.65 to 0.7 for a hemisphere.
- From Mach 0.8, a straight line to Stoney’s curve, scaled to the nose’s fineness, at Mach 1.2, its first point. This is HPR Sim’s join, not data. The scaling comes first, then the line; scaling the line instead, as before, made the drag rise with an infinite slope at Mach 0.8.
Worked example. A ¼-caliber ellipsoid at Mach 0: , where 1.25 is 1 + ¼ and 1.5 is 1 + ½ (the hemisphere), is . Base drag hack’s 0.577-caliber nose lies on the line:
The test
nose_drag::tests::a_blunt_ellipsoid_takes_hoerners_measured_forebody_drag pins both.
Cross-check against a measured cone. Stoney’s Figure 12(a) also has a 3:1 cone. Niskanen’s
closed form reads high through the whole rise. It reads +87% at Mach 0.8 and +105% at 0.85, where eq. 3.87
carries its Mach 1 value down. It reads +49% at Mach 1 and +48% at 1.1, where the cubic join is near its
peak, 0.234 against the measured 0.158. Then it reads +15% at Mach 1.5 and +4% at Mach 1.94, the curve’s end
(nose_drag::tests::niskanens_cone_against_stoneys_measured_cone). Ogives inherit this. So a
stubby cone or ogive gains the most drag at high subsonic speeds. Bella Lui’s 1.55:1 tangent ogive
takes its whole rocket’s at Mach 0.9 38% above the model before
M1.8b1. That model held the nose at its value at rest. That change moves under 1% on Calisto and Prometheus, with
von Kármán noses (ADR-028).
Boattails faster than sound
A boattail narrows the body toward the tail, usually to shrink the flat
base behind it. Below Mach 0.8 HPR Sim keeps Niskanen’s boattail rule from the table above, a share
of the base drag, and the base behind an attached boattail keeps of the flat-base drag,
the base’s diameter over the boattail’s fore diameter: 0.6 for a 4.8 in base behind an 8 in body
(Stoney’s rule from tunnel data, held to one measured flight; ADR-362 and
the base against a measured flight).
Faster than sound two more things happen. The air turns inward around the
boattail’s shoulder and expands, as in a Prandtl-Meyer expansion.
It speeds up, its pressure falls below the free stream’s, and it pulls back on the boattail. That
is a wave drag, and on a short, steep boattail it can be the largest
drag term on the rocket. Behind the boattail, the base’s pressure is higher than behind a plain
cylinder, which lowers the base drag. Code: hpr_aero::afterbody.
Decision: ADR-030.
None of the Arcas Robin’s 11 fins-off readings from Mach 1.5 is within 10%. Of Calisto’s 17 supersonic rows against RASAero II, 8 are. Theory that leaves out the air’s viscosity (inviscid theory) reads such boattails up to about 20% high ([CS51] p. 17). The rules for a boattail drawn in parts, a lip in its wake and the gaps between apply at every speed. The last three rows of the table are judgments that no measurement checks but the Arcas Robin’s lip.
In the table, a boattail runs from diameter to over its length . is its area ratio, its half-angle (the cone through the same ends; curved boattails are taken as that cone). Coefficients are on its fore area , the cross-section where it starts. is the pressure coefficient after the Prandtl-Meyer turn, and the base drag coefficient of the table above. is the base’s area over and a cylinder’s base pressure over a boattail’s. “Jet off” means the measurements were made with no motor exhaust.
| piece | what HPR Sim does | source |
|---|---|---|
| wave drag, attached flow | MIL-HDBK-762’s chart for conical boattails, against for from 0.25 to 0.80, read into the code (±(0.005 + 2%)) | [762] Fig. 5-122, p. 5-187 |
| its upper limit | never more than the pressure after a two-dimensional Prandtl-Meyer turn through over the whole annulus, ; past the chart’s end at the drag approaches that limit, the gap shrinking as | [R1135] eq. 44, 171c |
| separation | between 16° and 30°, a straight-line blend in from the attached value to the base drag on the annulus, , where flow separates | [C57] pp. 6, 8 |
| through Mach 1 | the rule to Mach 0.8, where the buildup’s other transonic terms start; a straight line to Mach 1; from there the attached drag held at its Mach 1.2 value to Mach 1.2 | [N09] p. 47, [762] p. 5-47 |
| base behind a boattail | from Mach 2.5, , with the cylinder’s pressure from Love’s correlation of measured bases, turned into the ratio of the two base-pressure coefficients, , which multiplies HPR Sim’s own base drag; below Mach 2.5, at Mach 2.5; to Mach 0.8, , a conical afterbody’s base drag scaling with on the largest cross-section where the rule on the base’s area scales with its square; a straight line between Mach 0.8 and 1; none for a separated boattail | [762] Figs. 5-139, 5-141, pp. 5-208, 5-210; [S61] p. 11; [H65] p. 3-20, eq. 35 |
| a lip in its wake | a lip behind a boattail or a step down (a boattail of no length), drawn as a shoulder, a step up or both, in one part or several, loses its pressure drag while its top rises up to a quarter of the boattail’s drop in diameter above the boattail’s end, keeps all of it from half, and a straight-line share between; a lip in parts takes at each part the smallest share any top so far leaves; the base behind it takes the same share of the relief, less the lip’s length’s fade. A lip’s rise is its top diameter less the boattail’s aft diameter. | [D4014] p. 6, [R22] slide 2; the quarter and half are a judgment |
| a boattail in parts | a narrowing part after another drags, as its share of the boattail it continues, as the cone from that boattail’s start through its aft end less the cone through its fore end (below 0 where extending the boattail lowers its drag); so parts of one straight cone add up to one cone. Its drag is that share for a turn of up to 3° between the parts, its own drag as a boattail from 10° (a corner), and a straight-line blend of the two between (the turn is the difference of the two parts’ half-angles) | a judgment |
| gaps and steps | whatever lies between a boattail and what follows weakens its effect in a straight line, gone once the gaps add up to one of the boattail’s drops in diameter; gaps add: the lengths of tubes, lips and parts, and the drops in diameter of steps down and narrowing parts. | a judgment |
The last three rows in full.
- A lip in its wake. A motor retainer behind the step down to its motor tube loses much of its step’s drag: behind a 98 mm (3.9 in) airframe stepping down to a 54 mm motor tube, a 62 mm (2.4 in) retainer rises 8 mm (0.31 in), 0.18 of the 44 mm (1.7 in) drop, so its rise alone would shelter it wholly, and the 12 mm (0.47 in) of motor tube ahead of it fades that by 12/44: its step keeps 27% of its drag (
a_retainer_behind_a_step_down_is_in_its_wake), and the rocket’s reads 12% to 23% lower from Mach 0.3 to 2.5 than with the retainer’s step in full (the physics review’s measurement; unmeasured in any tunnel). With the exposed motor tube as long as the 44 mm (1.7 in) drop, its step keeps none. - A boattail in parts. When either part is shallower than 1°, the merge is scaled by the smaller angle over the larger (the larger taken as at most 1°), so a part narrowing by almost nothing acts as a tube and a straight cone of any angle drawn in parts merges wholly. The merge holds at every speed, so below Mach 0.8 a curved boattail in parts drags as the cones through its ends, not part by part as eq. 3.88 would.
- Gaps and steps. With several boattails ahead, the flow is shared among them: a narrowing part takes over the share it merges with, and takes what no boattail holds as its own; a step down counts as a boattail of no length. The base and each lip add the boattails’ shares. So a part narrowing by nothing drags as a tube, a part of no length as a step, and a small change in any radius or length changes the drag a little.
Why each piece is there:
- The chart is second-order theory. MIL-HDBK-762 cites no source for it. Jack computed conical boattails from Mach 1.5 to 4.5 by Van Dyke’s second-order theory ([J53]). That theory is an inviscid method that keeps the next term past linear theory’s small-disturbance approximation. The chart agrees with his 83 points inside its range within −10.4% to +8.0% for up to 0.6. First-order (linear) theory reads far higher at these angles, so the chart is not linear theory.
- The 2D limit matters for short, steep boattails. The chart plots its drag against one combined variable, , which holds only for small angles. Near Mach 1 the chart can ask for more suction than a flat (two-dimensional) turn gives. A round boattail, whose pressure recovers aft of the shoulder, cannot exceed that. Past the chart the same limit gives the curve its shape: against Jack’s 28 points beyond it, −2.7% to +8.0%.
- Near Mach 1 no method exists for boattails. [762] p. 5-47 says so and advises holding the supersonic value to a peak between Mach 1.0 and 1.2. The straight line starts at Mach 0.8, where HPR Sim’s other transonic terms start, and is half-way up at 0.9. The measured rise is later and steeper. It is half-way by about 0.89 for Compton’s 10° boattail ([C72]) and 0.92 to 0.96 for Cubbage’s ([C57]). The rise has a peak at Mach 1.0 to 1.1 that holding the Mach 1.2 value does not reach. An earlier draft started the line at Mach 0.9, a choice made after seeing the Arcas Robin, one of the targets. The validation audit caught it, and it was put back to 0.8.
- The base’s relief is the handbook’s correlation, measured at Mach 2.5 to 3.5. Used as a ratio of pressures below Mach 2.5, it over-predicts the relief of the bases measured at Mach 1.59 and 1.91 ([DN54], [CS51]). Held as a ratio of coefficients, it matches them on average. It depends on the base’s area only, where the measured relief also grows with the boattail’s angle. Behind Cortright and Schroeder’s small bases () HPR Sim keeps 0.352 of the cylinder’s base pressure coefficient at every angle. Cortright and Schroeder measured 0.60 at 5.6° and 0.26 at 9.3°, against 0.352.
- The lip. NASA’s Arcas Robin models end in a lip 1.3 mm (0.051 in) long that flares from the boattail’s end to the base. NASA found the lip lowering the force on the balance chamber inside the base at Mach 1.5 and 1.8 with the fins off. The lip’s effect was “masked” when the flow over the boattail separates or the boundary layer thickens ([D4014] p. 6). RASAero II’s own comparison with the tunnel left it out as “buried in the boattail boundary layer” ([R22]). HPR Sim used to take it as a stubby cone in undisturbed air, 0.085 of drag. The quarter and half that bound the wake were chosen knowing this lip rises 0.17 of its boattail’s drop. Every one of the 44 Arcas Robin rows depends on that choice. With the lip counted as a shoulder in undisturbed air, each would read 0.065 to 0.086 higher.
A worked example: Calisto at Mach 1.5. Calisto’s boattail is 60 mm (2.4 in) long from 127 mm (5.0 in) to 87 mm (3.4 in): , , . The chart’s is , where it gives . A Prandtl-Meyer turn of 18.4° from Mach 1.5 gives , so the limit is , and the attached boattail drags 0.211. At 18.4° it is 17% of the way from 16° to 30°. So the blend takes the drag 17% toward the base drag on the annulus, : 0.190, where the rule gave 0.066. For the base, : at Mach 2.5 Love’s cylinder gives , so
so ; after the blend
0.683, so the base’s drag falls from 0.078 to 0.053. Calisto’s at Mach 1.5 rises from
0.443 to 0.542. The module’s documentation test runs this example
(hpr_aero::afterbody).
Against measurements (drag-vs-mach.json, sections boattails,
base_pressures and second_order_theory, from the readings in
measured-boattails.json; tests::boattails_against_measurements). Every
source is a wind tunnel with a turbulent boundary layer and the jet off. Each value was read from
the report’s figure, with its reading uncertainty in the file. The last column says whether the
rows helped build the model: those check it on its own data.
| boattails | Mach | rows | HPR Sim against measured | helped build it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| attached, 3° to 10°: [CS51], [DN54], [C72], [MJ54], [C57] | 1.2 to 3.12 | 58 | −21.9% to +28.3%, within 0.0123 | no |
| attached, 5.6° and 8° ([C57]) | 1.0 and 1.1 | 4 | −18.2% to −5.4% | partly: Cubbage’s peak was weighed in holding the Mach 1.2 value |
| attached, 3° to 10°, points near Mach 1 that Compton calls questionable (strut interference, reflected bow shock; [C72] p. 9) | 0.95 to 1.1 | 27 | −46.2% to +60.0% | no |
| attached, 3° to 10°, in the rise ([C72], [C57]) | 0.85 to 0.95 | 28 | −77.5% to +7.6% | no |
| attached, 3° to 10°, under the rule ([C72], [C57]) | 0.3 to 0.8 | 58 | −100% to −83.5% | no |
| 16°, attached, boundary layer thick ([C57]) | 1.0 to 1.28 | 9 | +26.4% to +54.2% | no |
| the same, below Mach 1 | 0.6 to 0.9 | 6 | −30.2% to +60.4% | no |
| 30° and 45°, separated ([C57]) | 1.2 | 3 | −2.8% to +6.6% | yes: the separation angles |
| the base behind 5° to 10° boattails ([CS51], [DN54]) | 1.59, 1.91 | 8 | base drag within 0.0102 of the measured on the cylinder’s area; behind small bases up to about 40% of the base’s own drag | yes: the ratio held below Mach 2.5 |
| the base behind 2.5° to 15° boattails ([Love57]) | 3.24 | 4 | within 0.003 | no |
The 0.0102 and 0.0123 are pins on these readings, not tolerances. Below Mach 0.8 Niskanen’s rule gives nothing to a boattail longer than three times its drop in diameter. It gives Compton’s and Cubbage’s long, gentle boattails 0 to 0.009, where they measure 0.011 to 0.075 (issue #73).
What it leaves out.
- Steep boattails in a thick boundary layer read high. HPR Sim reads Cubbage’s 16° boattails 26% to 54% above the measurements, though the flow is still attached. The boundary layer is a fifth of the diameter thick. The Arcas Robin’s 15° boattail sits in one thicker than its own drop in radius. The Arcas Robin’s forebody reads +13.5% to +24.1% from Mach 1.5 (below). No source here gives a correction, so none is applied (issue #72); MIL-HDBK-762 advises boattails under 8° to avoid separation ([762] p. 5-12).
- Through Mach 1 it reads low for gentle boattails: the straight line from Mach 0.8 misses the measured rise’s later, steeper climb and its peak.
- Separation’s 16° and 30° come from one report at Mach 0.6 to 1.28. Between 10° and 30° no attached boattail was measured faster than Mach 1.28. So a boattail of 12° to 20°, like Calisto’s 18.4°, rests on the least-validated part of the model, and likely reads high.
- For one length and area ratio, Jack found the cone’s wave drag the smallest of three shapes ([J53] p. 1). So a curved boattail likely drags more than HPR Sim gives. The chart’s 0.70 and 0.80 curves read up to 32% above Jack past , 0.0084 at most.
- A tube behind a boattail loses the base’s relief over one drop in diameter. The 3°, 10°, quarter and half that shape the merge and the wake are judgments, with no measurement behind them but the Arcas Robin’s lip. Its own 1.3 mm (0.051 in) length is a gap too: the base keeps 0.944 of its relief.
- A straight cone drawn in parts drags as one cone. A part’s share can be below 0, where the chart makes the longer cone drag less than the shorter: extending the boattail lowers its drag. The one exception is a cone behind a boattail that it only partly merges with (a turn of 3° to 10°). Its parts may drag a little less than the whole. An 8° cone behind a 14° part reads the same in 2 or 4 parts. It reads up to 0.45% lower in 8, and up to 2.2% lower drawn in hundreds, worst near Mach 1.
- The 1° below which a part merges only in part, and the fade of a step’s corner over one drop in diameter, are judgments too. Flow behind a backward-facing step reattaches farther downstream, so the fade likely understates a lip’s shelter.
- Nothing models the jet. Fig. 5-141 is measured with the motor off, as are the base drag it scales and Stoney’s subsonic rule. Under power HPR Sim applies them to what the motors leave of the base.
- Below Mach 0.8 the relief rests on one measured flight, the Hermes A-3A’s long 4.5° cone, and on Stoney’s tunnel rule, which gives no range of cone angles and does not allow for the negative base drags measured at subsonic speeds ([S61] p. 11). Measured bases behind cones read lower still (subsonic boattail base drag), so the rule likely reads high behind a long attached boattail (evidence row G41).
Drag limits
- The buildup covers Mach 0 to 5 and refuses Mach 5 and faster, like the normal force
(
drag::BUILDUP_MACH_LIMIT); an override table takes any Mach number. - It reads high against the one wind tunnel it has been measured against, at every reading. With the fins off, it reads 12% to 54% high, most of it the model’s steep boattail. With the fins on, past Mach 1.2, it reads far higher, from the fins (Verification). The fins’ leading edge takes [N09]’s rounded-edge formula, a blunt edge’s, for the airfoil and rounded sections alike. Nothing models the wave drag of a thin, sharp fin, which is far smaller. The Arcas Robin’s four double-wedge fins measure 0.046 at Mach 4.63, against HPR Sim’s 0.30.
- Against MIL-HDBK-762’s worked example, fins left out, the body reads high from Mach 0.9 to 1.2 (the nose and the base). The body reads 6% to 10% low from Mach 1.6 (friction and the base) (Drag against MIL-HDBK-762’s sample calculation).
- It reads low against RASAero II’s Calisto past Mach 1.6, −14.9% at Mach 2 (Drag against RASAero II through Mach 2). Part of that is the body’s lean above; plausible fin inputs bring most rows within 10%.
- Through the transonic rise, from Mach 0.8 to 1.2, the measured shapes follow Stoney’s curves. Cones and ogives follow Niskanen’s closed form, which reads 45% to 105% above Stoney’s measured 3:1 cone there (the cross-check above).
- Shoulders and boattails past Mach 1. A shoulder takes the nose method, except a lip in a boattail’s wake, which loses a share of it. [N09] calls the nose method “somewhat dubious at supersonic velocities” (p. 48). A boattail keeps eq. 3.88 to Mach 0.8, a rule “based primarily on subsonic data” (p. 49). The rule over-predicts the Arcas Robin’s 15° boattail and gives long boattails nothing (issue #73). Faster than sound its wave drag reads high for steep boattails in a thick boundary layer (Boattails faster than sound).
- Stoney’s curves end at Mach 1.94 to 1.99 (panel (a)) and 3.59 (panel (b)). Past that HPR Sim holds their last value, which panel (b) puts within 8% for two shapes (above).
- Stubby noses. Below fineness 1 a cone or ogive blends toward the flat face at every Mach number, so at rest it reads above eq. 3.86. A cone of fineness 0.5 gives 0.547 against eq. 3.86’s 0.400. Two routes to one shape disagree. A tangent ogive and an ellipse of fineness 0.5 are both hemispheres. The ogive rises from rest by that blend, which no measurement backs. The ellipse takes Hoerner’s measured 0.01 to Mach 0.8 and then rises in a straight line (blunt ellipsoids). Below Mach 0.8, trust the ellipse’s.
- Before M1.8b1 the buildup held nose and shoulder pressure drag at its value at rest and refused Mach 1.
- Nothing models laminar flow, fin-tip vortices, interference drag, fin tabs, fillets, canted fins or the flow a boattail guides into the base ([N09] p. 51).
Limits and verification
What the models leave open, and the checks that pin them against worked examples, wind tunnels and other programs.
Validity and open questions
- A flared body’s supersonic normal force rests on one measured flare. Since M1.8e17 a conical flare flies the shock-expansion method while its corner’s shock is attached. This moves a flared rocket’s center of pressure forward by a tenth to a quarter of a caliber against its earlier model (evidence row G28). The one measurement beside it is TN D-4865’s model 2, an 18.5° flare on a 2.75° cone. The results are −1.9% and +7.0% at Mach 1.9 and 2.3, and +13.4% at 2.96. They are +51.5% and +50.4% at 3.95 and 4.63, where that flare’s boundary layer is separated (What a marched flare is worth). No other flare angle, and no other body, has been checked. Two more things about that model are open. The attachment test is a wedge’s limit, not a flare’s own (A flare through the method). And a near-flat flare has its one element read by the older generalized method, which leaves a step at the corner’s crossing. The step is +0.129% of the normal force and 0.0051 calibers on the tests’ rocket. It is +4.3% and 0.19 calibers on a body whose shoulder is short. There the region sits at degrees rather than thousandths of one (A near-flat flare).
- A step in radius is unmodeled, and nothing measures one faster than sound. A mismatch of radius past a threshold takes the whole body off the shock-expansion method at every speed. The thresholds are 2.7e−11 m between two tubes and 1.3e−13 m stepping up at a boattail’s fore end, far below any tolerance anyone builds to. On the tests’ straight rocket that is worth −8.65% of the normal force and 1.03 calibers of center of pressure at the threshold. At a 2 mm (0.079 in) step down it is −12.55% and 1.36 calibers. On the boattailed one, it is −11.34% and 1.10 calibers (A step in radius). No published source gives a stepped body’s normal force faster than sound, so the present behavior is not known to be right either. Stopping the march at the step was built and rejected (ADR-049, issue #87: a step has no model of its own).
- The body alone misses the 15% target on six of eleven wind-tunnel rows, the one M1.8e set for the body faster than sound. The misses are +37.7% at worst (the short Arcas Robin at Mach 1.5). The body is within 5% at Mach 3.96 and 4.63. The likeliest cause is Jorgensen’s crossflow term reading too large at the few degrees a slope is fitted over. But the measurement cannot split its own slope from its curvature cleanly, and one row points at the method instead. Closing it needs a cited rule for how the crossflow term grows from zero over the first few degrees. Or it needs measurements at finer angles than the reports plot. Neither is in hand, so the gap is left visible (The body alone, against the 15% target).
- A center of pressure means little where the body’s normal force is near zero. A deep, steep transition can remove almost all the lift the nose and tube carry. HPR Sim still divides the moment by what is left. One test shape reports its body’s center of pressure 160 calibers ahead of its own nose tip at Mach 1.2. It is tracked in issue #104: a near-zero normal force gives a meaningless center of pressure. That body-alone figure is printed nowhere. Every center of pressure HPR Sim prints is the whole rocket’s. The flight applies each part’s moment as computed, so no number reads wrong (ADR-201).
- A blunt tip’s handover is capped where the method’s march still settles, not where its theory runs out. The cap is 24° and the cone slopes reach 30°. At 30° the committed Arcas Robin nose reads nearer the report’s own sphere-cone. But its answer starts to follow the element count above Mach 4, so the cap stays. What that is worth is measured on both sides in What the cap is worth. The way out is issue #108: a steeper handover puts the march into above Mach 4.
- A boattail steeper than 16° is worth 0.67 to 1.35 calibers of doubt, the most at the lowest supersonic speeds. Nothing measures a separated boattail’s supersonic normal force. HPR Sim holds the measured correlation at 16° rather than fading it, the conservative end (A steep boattail reads the correlation no steeper than 16°).
- These are small-angle models. is accepted over , but fin slopes stay linear in and nothing models stall. The flight engine uses them at every angle anyway (Rigid-body flight). So its results are least trustworthy where large angles occur: off the rail in a strong crosswind, and near apogee.
- Body lift in wind (measured by flying both codes, not against a real flight; ADR-026, ADR-037). A rocket that leaves the rail slowly in a crosswind meets the air at a steep angle. Juno III, one of RocketPy’s example rockets, leaves at 18 m/s (59 ft/s) in an 8.5 m/s (28 ft/s) wind, 26° off the airflow. There body lift is nearly half its normal force. Much of it acts ahead of the rocket’s center of mass, the nose’s above all. So body lift moves the center of pressure forward and weakens the moment that turns the rocket into the wind. HPR Sim turns into it less than RocketPy, whose normal force has no body term. Body lift’s sideways push alone is about a sixth of its effect on the drift. Juno III’s apogee ends 245.3 m (805 ft) from the pad in HPR Sim and 396.6 m (1,301 ft) in RocketPy. Body lift is about half of that difference, and HPR Sim’s rail release and fin slope most of the rest. Flown in RocketPy with HPR Sim’s model, Juno III’s apogee drift is 248.3 m (815 ft) with Jorgensen’s crossflow. There is about 0.91 at that speed (Body lift). With a constant across [G]’s range, the drift runs from 194.1 m (637 ft) at to 240.2 m (788 ft) at 1.0. The drift is 231.1 m (758 ft) at , the value HPR Sim used before M1.8e6. It would be 328.0 m (1,076 ft) with no body lift. Calisto, off the rail at 28 m/s (92 ft/s) and 11°, changes its drift by under 0.5% across that range. Which is nearer a real flight is open: the real flights so far compare heights, not drift.
- No airfoils. Fins use the flat-plate lift slope ( per radian in two dimensions). An airfoil lift curve, such as the one Juno III’s example gives its fins, is not modeled. RocketPy uses it, and its fin slope there is 7.6% steeper (ADR-026).
- In one measured case, fins at give 17.4 against a flat-plate estimate near 5. In the same case, at the fins still give 34.7 while every body term vanishes. That case is a 54 mm (2.1 in) four-fin rocket at Mach 0.3.
- Speed. The normal force and the drag buildup cover ; a drag table covers any
Mach number.
- The drag buildup’s transonic and supersonic terms are [N09]’s semi-empirical ones. [N09] expects them “to be reasonably accurate to at least Mach 1.5” (p. 94). Against the one wind tunnel they read high from about Mach 1.2 (Drag limits). On the one supersonic flight compared with OpenRocket, HPR Sim’s supersonic pressure drag is about twice OpenRocket’s (#222: which is right is open).
- Between Mach 0.8 and linear theory’s start , the normal force is the straight-line join of Fins through Mach 1. Against the wind tunnel its slope reads up to 27.1% high (Mach 1.2), and its CP 0.67 to 1.35 calibers aft at Mach 0.9: the flight margin reads high (#1198 warns). Past Mach 3 the normal force’s body terms read low (Normal force through Mach 1).
- Below the join, from Mach 0.6 (the slowest point of the TN D-4013 tunnel tests) to 0.8, the fins are still on Prandtl-Glauert, yet the short Arcas Robin model’s CP reads 0.117 calibers aft of the report’s curve at Mach 0.6 and 0.912 at 0.8, each beyond the reading’s ±0.055. The long model reads 0.360 calibers forward at Mach 0.6 and inside its ±0.071 at 0.8, so only one of the two models shows the error. Both misses depend on the angles they are fitted over: fitted on the tunnel’s plotted points over the same angles, Mach 0.6 reads −0.03 calibers over −2° to 2° and −0.49 over −3° to 4°, and Mach 0.8 +0.87 and +0.08 (the fit). Below Mach 0.6 the tunnel has no data. A flight from Mach 0.6 may have its margin read high (#1290 warns, quoting the report’s-curve figures, 0.11 to 0.92 calibers, the larger side, and the −3° to 4° fit’s 0.08). A flight past Mach 0.8 prints both #1290 and #1198: they quote different tunnel points, and aren’t added together.
- [N09] eq. 3.35–3.36 would start moving a fin set’s CP aft at Mach 0.5. By Mach 0.8 the CP would reach about 0.30 of the way along its mean aerodynamic chord (MAC, defined under Fins) for aspect ratio 1.6. Aspect ratio measures how long the span is against the chord. HPR Sim keeps 0.25 to Mach 0.8: the Arcas Robin’s measured CP moves forward, not aft, from Mach 0.6 to 0.8.
Verification
-
Barrowman’s worked examples (
hpr_aero::tests::barrowman_worked_examples). Inputs and printed results, with page numbers, are in the fixturevalidation/fixtures/aero/barrowman-worked-examples.json. Every printed component and total must agree within 1%. Measured:example slope , per rad: HPR Sim / printed CP: HPR Sim / printed (in) Testbed II [B66] pp. 41–45 21.397 / 21.44 (−0.20%) 16.703 / 16.7 (+0.02%) Aerobee 350 [B66] pp. 47–50 21.449 / 21.5 (−0.24%) 390.48 / 391 (−0.13%) Javelin [TIR] pp. 21–22 35.927 / 35.9 (+0.07%) 11.286 / 11.3 (−0.13%) Recruiter [TIR] pp. 23–25, HPR Sim’s model: outside 1% 36.416 / 35.4 (+2.87%) 15.665 / 15.6 (+0.42%) Recruiter with TIR-33’s six-fin rule substituted 35.415 / 35.4 (+0.04%) 15.627 / 15.6 (+0.17%) Arcon-Hi, two stages [TIR] pp. 27–29 96.163 / 96.2 (−0.04%) 20.803 / 20.8 (+0.02%) Arcon-Hi, sustainer alone 32.257 / 32.2 (+0.18%) 17.845 / 17.9 (−0.31%) - With HPR Sim’s own model, every CP agrees within 1%, and every slope but the Recruiter’s. Its six-fin slopes are +3.42% (fins) and +2.87% (total). Those are the only 2 of the 38 printed values (19 slopes, 19 CPs) outside 1%, and the test pins that list.
- With TIR-33’s six-fin rule substituted for the Recruiter, the worst is the Testbed II nose CP, −0.77%: [B66]’s fit against the integrated tangent ogive.
- CPs are compared as stations from the nose tip. Measured from each part’s own front, two printed values miss 1%. One is the Testbed II boattail (0.655 in against 0.72 in, −9%, Barrowman’s diameter ratio slip). The other is the Javelin fins (0.653 in against 0.66 in, −1.1%, rounding).
- Recruiter’s six fins. TIR-33 scales six fins by with and no fin-count factor. With HPR Sim’s own rule (0.913 and the full ), the fins are +3.42% and the total +2.87% from the print. The difference between the two rules accounts for +3.22% and +2.83% of that. The test checks the TIR-33 rule within 1% (slopes and CP weighting) and reports HPR Sim’s own values. It checks that the rules differ by more than 2%.
- The printed mid-chord lengths were measured or rounded. HPR Sim computes them from the geometry (Aerobee: 39.7 in printed, 40.50 in geometric). The fixture’s notes list each slip in the printed arithmetic.
-
Loft lessons, each with what it concerns:
- L7, a fin slope and CP that never changed with Mach:
fins::tests::fin_cna_compressibility_reduces_to_barrowman_at_m0 - L8, no correction for five to eight fins:
fins::tests::six_fin_cna_applies_fin_count_factor - L9, the conical transition’s CP formula used for every shape:
body::tests::ogive_transition_cp_uses_volume_form - L10, elliptical fins given a trapezoid’s sweep:
fins::tests::elliptical_fin_cna_uses_zero_midchord_sweep - L89, Barrowman’s values worked by hand, a check kept from Loft’s tests:
tests::barrowman_hand_values. A cone’s slope is 2 with its CP at ( its length). A conical transition from 20 to 40 mm (0.79 to 1.6 in) radius over 0.1 m (0.33 ft) has a slope of 1.5. Its CP is 0.05556 m (0.1823 ft) aft of its fore end. An elliptical fin’s CP is aft of its root leading edge.
- L7, a fin slope and CP that never changed with Mach:
-
Limits and invariants (
body::tests,fins::tests,model::tests):- Cylinders and thin transitions; body lift at 0 and 90°.
- Eq. 57 and 76a closed forms against the same trapezoid as a polygon (1e-13).
- A 2000-gon ellipse, and a jagged fin.
- Prandtl-Glauert against [B67] eq. 3-6 written with the aspect ratio, and its limit.
- Roll sums against direct sums; a two-fin set along and across the flow.
- Mach changes only the fins.
- Supersonic linear theory on a rectangle, whose slope and CP have closed forms, including a tip cone that crosses the root.
- Outlines of each planform; where linear theory starts.
- A proptest (a rule checked on many random inputs): scaling every length leaves slopes unchanged and scales the CP; the reference diameter scales slopes only.
- Refusals: nine fins, Mach 5 for the normal force and for the drag buildup, angles out of range.
Normal force through Mach 1
Two references, in the fixture
validation/fixtures/aero/normal-force-vs-mach.json,
which cargo xtask aero writes and tests::normal_force_against_mach recomputes and pins
(ADR-027). The targets, set before measuring: within 15% and the CP within 0.5 calibers (a caliber is one reference diameter). 13 of the 37 rows miss, each for a measured
reason below.
- A wind tunnel. NASA tested half-scale models of the Arcas Robin sounding rocket from Mach 0.6 to 4.63 ([D4013], [D4014]). The short model has a nose 4.2 calibers long, a cylinder, a 15° boattail and four trapezoidal fins swept 30°, 18.2 calibers long in all. A longer version is 23.8 calibers long. The reports print only plots, so their points were read off the pages into
validation/fixtures/aero/arcas-robin-wind-tunnel.json. It records every figure and page, and each is read to about ±0.01 to ±0.02. The designs model the reports’ nose, a table of coordinates rather than a named shape, as a power-series nose with the same volume. That sets its slender-body CP. They model the planform within 2.4%. The slope is the straight line fitted through the plotted from about −4° to +4°. So HPR Sim’s is fitted the same way at the same angles. Its CP is taken over −2° to 2°, the reports’ low angles. - RASAero II, another code, for Calisto from Mach 0.1 to 2.0. Its potential-flow slope and CP come from the export RocketPy’s first commit shipped. The slope is the attached-flow part, without the crossflow lift its export adds from Mach 0.95. They are compared with HPR Sim’s small-angle values.
The short model (the Arcas Robin itself, 18.2 calibers long), rows outside the targets in bold. The last column is the body alone: the fins-off wind-tunnel reading, and HPR Sim’s body terms fitted the same way. The design’s lip sits in the boattail’s wake and carries nothing faster than sound (A lip in a boattail’s wake). The design’s vertical tip flies behind a Newtonian cap (Blunt tips). So the body flies the method to its base from Mach 1.2. With fins off it reads 3.02 to 3.95 per radian from Mach 1.5, where it read 1.90 to 2.09 on slender-body theory. Below the join its body lift grows as and with the crossflow Mach number. So the body terms’ fitted slope moves a little with Mach and with the angles each plot covers (1.90 to 2.09). From Mach 0.6 to 1.2 the fins-off readings, on a coarse grid (±0.02 per point), scatter from 1.41 to 2.88 with no trend. So they don’t settle whether HPR Sim’s 1.91 is high there.
| Mach | measured, per rad | HPR Sim, per rad | difference | CP measured, m | HPR Sim CP, m | difference, calibers | body alone, measured / HPR Sim, per rad |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.6 | 11.05 | 10.54 | −4.6% | 0.7770 | 0.7837 | +0.12 | 1.53 / 1.91 |
| 0.8 | 9.92 | 10.85 | +9.5% | 0.7375 | 0.7896 | +0.91 | 1.41 / 1.90 |
| 0.9 | 10.22 | 12.77 | +25.0% | 0.7447 | 0.8215 | +1.34 | 2.44 / 1.91 |
| 0.95 | 11.88 | 13.74 | +15.6% | 0.7952 | 0.8342 | +0.68 | 2.88 / 1.92 |
| 1 | 15.79 | 14.69 | −6.9% | 0.8690 | 0.8455 | −0.41 | 1.58 / 1.92 |
| 1.2 | 15.42 | 18.54 | +20.2% | 0.8862 | 0.8798 | −0.11 | 2.43 / 1.92 |
| 1.5 | 13.43 | 14.61 | +8.8% | 0.8137 | 0.8282 | +0.25 | 2.19 / 3.02 |
| 1.8 | 11.99 | 12.46 | +3.9% | 0.7908 | 0.7883 | −0.04 | 2.61 / 3.29 |
| 2.3 | 9.89 | 10.50 | +6.2% | 0.7505 | 0.7369 | −0.24 | 3.08 / 3.60 |
| 2.96 | 8.77 | 9.10 | +3.7% | 0.6967 | 0.6858 | −0.19 | 3.28 / 3.84 |
| 3.96 | 7.73 | 7.85 | +1.6% | 0.6312 | 0.6330 | +0.03 | 3.88 / 3.95 |
| 4.63 | 7.55 | 7.30 | −3.3% | 0.5876 | 0.6073 | +0.34 | 4.15 / 3.95 |
| reference, Mach | difference | CP difference, calibers | rows within both targets |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arcas, long, 0.6 and 0.8 | +0.7%, +8.9% | −0.36, +0.07 | 2 of 2 |
| Arcas, long, 0.9 to 1.2 | −8.8% to +27.1% | +0.67 to +2.36 | 0 of 3 |
| Arcas, long, 1.8 to 2.96 | +8.4% to +9.4% | −0.53 to −0.43 | 1 of 3 |
| Arcas, long, 3.96 and 4.63 | +2.8%, −2.3% | −0.13, +0.21 | 2 of 2 |
| Calisto against RASAero II, 0.1 to 0.7 | +0.1% to +10.1% | −0.08 to +0.43 | 4 of 4 |
| Calisto against RASAero II, 0.8 to 2.0 | −6.3% to +21.9% | −0.44 to +0.95 | 7 of 11 |
What the misses come from:
- Faster than sound, every slope now passes, and the long model’s CP at Mach 1.8 and 2.3 does not. Until M1.8e7 and M1.8e8 the committed designs’ vertical tip and lip kept the shock-expansion method off. So their bodies flew slender-body theory past Mach 1. They lifted 2.0 to 2.6 per rad where the tunnel’s body alone lifts 2.2 to 4.6. The short model read −16.3% at Mach 2.96 and −28.0% at 4.63. With the cap (Blunt tips) and the lip carrying nothing in the boattail’s wake (A lip in a boattail’s wake), the body grows with Mach. It grows as the measurement does, though less steeply. The whole rocket’s rows from Mach 1.5 read +8.8% to −3.3% (short) and +9.4% to −2.3% (long). What is left is the body reading high: 15% to 19% above the tunnel fins off, at Mach 1.8 and 2.3 on the long model. That pulls the whole rocket’s CP 0.53 and 0.52 calibers forward of the measured one, just outside the half-caliber target. M1.8e6 sized that excess and left it (ADR-037). The body alone is judged against the 15% target in The body alone, against the 15% target. The fins’ share is the fins-on reading less the fins-off one. It agrees with HPR Sim’s fins within −1.4% to +7.0% at Mach 3.96 and 4.63. That agreement carries about 5% of doubt of its own. Over the boattail the models’ fin roots follow its 15° surface below the cylinder. The design leaves that strip out, about 0.32 in² of each fin’s 5.8 in² (5.5%).
- Mach 0.6, within the targets by errors that cancel. Both models pass there. But HPR Sim’s body is 25% and 19% above the fins-off readings, which are poorly determined at these speeds. HPR Sim’s fins’ share is 9.3% and 3.9% below the measured one.
- Transonic, Mach 0.8 to 1.2. The fins’ measured share lifts less at Mach 0.8 and 0.9 than at 0.6, then jumps at Mach 1. HPR Sim’s fins lift more, by Prandtl-Glauert and then along the join to linear theory’s peak at (1.2 for these fins). The long model’s CP jumps forward at Mach 1, 2.36 calibers from HPR Sim’s. No closed-form method covers this region, and the join is not fitted to it.
- RASAero II keeps its slope and CP constant through subsonic flow, where HPR Sim’s rise with Prandtl-Glauert, so they part from Mach 0.8. Past Mach 1.2 Calisto’s von Kármán nose flies the shock-expansion method behind a Newtonian cap, so its cylinder carries lift. Mach 1.5 reads +12.9% and Mach 2 +8.3% (−3.1% and −16.8% on slender-body theory, before M1.8e7). The wind tunnel sides with neither there. Below that the agreement is partly by construction: the Calisto design has the 2018 fins because they reproduce this export at low speed (ADR-009). Past Mach 1 the result rests on the choice of RASAero’s columns. RASAero’s secant slope and CP to 4° include its crossflow lift. Against them, 3 of the 11 rows from Mach 0.8 are within the targets, not 7. The tightest of the three passes at Mach 1 by 0.00002 calibers. Against them Mach 2 is −9.6%. That comparison is a summary in the fixture’s
secant_comparison, not a second set of rows. The export stays inrefs/, and the fixture commits its values once (ADR-009, ADR-027). Calisto has no fins-off data, so its body and fins can’t be split as the wind tunnel’s can.
So, for fins like these, whose linear theory starts at , trust HPR Sim’s slope to about
10% from Mach 1.5 up. The rows run +9.4% to −3.3%. From Mach 1.5 up, trust its CP to about half a
caliber. The long model misses that by 0.03 at Mach 1.8 and 0.02 at 2.3. Between Mach 0.8 and
, in the join, trust neither. A fin set’s own is
FinSetAero::fin.supersonic_mach,
from AeroModel::fin_sets. Fins
swept further back start later: a leading edge swept 48° starts at Mach 1.5, and until then it is in
the join. Nothing past Mach 4.63 has been checked, though the model runs to 5.
The body alone, against the 15% target
What this covers: how far HPR Sim’s body alone is from NASA’s measurement of the same body, and where the remaining gap sits.
The milestone M1.8e set a target before any of this was built: the Arcas Robin’s body alone within 15% at every Mach number from 1.5. It had a second part: both configurations’ whole-rocket slope within 15% at Mach 3.96 and 4.63. The second half is met (+2.8% to −3.3%). The first is not, on six of eleven rows, and this is where they stand (ADR-040).
- Rows outside the target are in bold. Slopes are on the body’s cross-section.
- is the Mach number over the nose’s fineness, the argument TN 3527 ([SD56]) states its method for from 0.4 to 2. One row, the short model at Mach 1.5, is below that at 0.36.
- measured and HPR Sim are the straight-line slopes fitted at the tunnel’s plotted angles, as ADR-036, which fixes how these comparisons are fitted judges them.
- at is the slope at zero angle. HPR Sim’s is the method alone, since body lift vanishes there. The measurement’s comes from fitting its points with , the form the tunnel’s own curves follow, and is quoted with its standard error.
- curvature is the rest: the fitted slope less the slope at . For HPR Sim it is body lift.
| model | Mach | ratio | measured, per rad | HPR Sim, per rad | difference | measured at , per rad | HPR Sim at , per rad | slope ratio, HPR Sim ÷ measured at | curvature ratio, HPR Sim ÷ measured |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| short | 1.5 | 0.36 | 2.192 | 3.017 | +37.7% | 1.779 ± 0.32 | 1.852 | 1.04 | 2.82 |
| short | 1.8 | 0.43 | 2.613 | 3.290 | +25.9% | 2.519 ± 0.33 | 2.143 | 0.85 | 12.20 |
| short | 2.3 | 0.55 | 3.078 | 3.598 | +16.9% | 2.196 ± 0.32 | 2.394 | 1.09 | 1.37 |
| short | 2.96 | 0.71 | 3.284 | 3.838 | +16.9% | 2.184 ± 0.30 | 2.612 | 1.20 | 1.11 |
| short | 3.96 | 0.95 | 3.884 | 3.946 | +1.6% | 2.694 ± 0.32 | 2.735 | 1.02 | 1.02 |
| short | 4.63 | 1.11 | 4.149 | 3.950 | −4.8% | 2.758 ± 0.32 | 2.718 | 0.99 | 0.89 |
| long | 1.8 | 0.43 | 3.159 | 3.770 | +19.4% | 1.920 ± 0.42 | 2.143 | 1.12 | 1.31 |
| long | 2.3 | 0.55 | 3.525 | 4.071 | +15.5% | 2.245 ± 0.41 | 2.394 | 1.07 | 1.31 |
| long | 2.96 | 0.71 | 3.868 | 4.400 | +13.7% | 2.521 ± 0.36 | 2.614 | 1.04 | 1.33 |
| long | 3.96 | 0.95 | 4.455 | 4.428 | −0.6% | 3.129 ± 0.41 | 2.740 | 0.88 | 1.27 |
| long | 4.63 | 1.11 | 4.615 | 4.425 | −4.1% | 2.877 ± 0.41 | 2.724 | 0.95 | 0.98 |
What the rows say, and what they can’t. What is solid is the first three number columns. On six rows HPR Sim’s fitted slope is 15% to 38% above the tunnel’s. The split into a slope at and a curvature is softer. The tunnel plots seven points over about ±4.5°. In a fit of over so short a span the two terms trade off almost exactly: their correlation is −0.96. A fit that reads low must read high. So the measurement’s own split carries the standard errors in the table (±0.30 to ±0.42 per radian). The widest of them is on a slope of 1.920. The curvature, being the same slope subtracted from another, carries at least as much.
Where the gap most likely is. At HPR Sim is within 1.5 standard errors of the measurement on every row outside the target (0.2 to 1.5 of one). So the readings cannot convict the shock-expansion method, the Newtonian cap or the boattail’s measured share. On five of those six rows most of the fitted gap sits in the curvature instead. That is what the rest of the plotted angles add, which for HPR Sim is body lift. The sixth is the short model at Mach 2.96, where 77% of the gap is HPR Sim’s slope at , 1.2 times the measured one. There the method itself, not body lift, carries most of the miss. HPR Sim’s curvature is 1.3 to 2.8 times the measured one below Mach 2.96, and 1.1 to 1.3 times at Mach 2.96. It is 0.89 to 1.27 times at Mach 3.96 and 4.63. The ×12.20 on the short model at Mach 1.8 is not a measurement of anything. The tunnel’s own curve barely bends there (0.094 per radian, against an uncertainty three times its size). So the ratio’s denominator is consistent with zero.
The likeliest single cause is Jorgensen’s crossflow term, which ADR-037 chose because the tunnel’s high-angle points support its size. At the few degrees these slopes are fitted over, that term reads too large. Two other explanations are open, and the readings do not close them. First, the short model at Mach 1.5 (the worst row, +37.7%) sits at 0.36, below the 0.4 that TN 3527 states its method for. Second, the same model at Mach 2.96 points at the method rather than at body lift.
What would close it. A cited rule for how the crossflow term grows from zero over the first few
degrees. Or measurements of this body at finer angles than the reports plot. Neither is in hand,
so the gap is left visible here rather than tuned away. The rows are in
validation/fixtures/aero/arcas-robin-body-gap.json,
written by cargo xtask aero, and a test pins which rows are outside.
Checking the shock-expansion method
A flight uses the second-order shock-expansion method of Bodies faster than sound
from Mach 1.2 on the bodies it covers. It is checked against two references in the fixture
validation/fixtures/aero/shock-expansion.json.
cargo xtask aero writes it, and shock_expansion::tests::against_tn3527_and_the_arcas_robin
recomputes every value and pins every miss (ADR-033).
To check a share by hand from outside the crate,
ShockExpansionBody::element_flows
reports each element’s flow. That is the state behind its corner, the tangent cone it relaxes toward, how
fast it does so, and the radius eq. 19 needs. The library’s own hand integral of a
boattail and the tube behind it uses that flow (footnote_eights_boattail_share_by_hand).
The tip cone’s flow (cone_flow_agrees_with_naca_1135_charts), against [R1135]’s cone
charts 5 to 7 at Mach 1.5 to 3 and cones of 10° and 20°. The shock angle is within 0.3°, the
surface pressure coefficient within 0.004 and the surface Mach number within 0.015. These bounds are twice the
charts’ reading error, since the charts are drawn for and HPR Sim uses 1.4. At Mach 2 on a 10°
cone HPR Sim gives a shock at 31.21° against the chart’s 31.25°.
The report’s own tables ([SD56] Tables I and II, transcribed from the page images into
tn3527-bodies.json).
They cover 144 bodies at Mach 3, 4.24, 5.05 and 6.28. These are cones and tangent ogives of fineness 3, 5 and 7, on cylinders of 0 to 10 calibers. For each they give the method’s slope and CP, as its
authors computed them by hand in 1956. For all but the 8-caliber cylinders they also give NASA’s
wind-tunnel measurements. The targets were set before measuring: within 0.05 per radian and
0.1 calibers of the report’s values. Against the measurements the target is the ±0.2 per radian and ±0.2 calibers that the report
claims. Each cell counts the rows within, with the range of HPR Sim’s value
less the reference’s:
| nose | slope within 0.05 per radian of the report’s | CP within 0.1 caliber of the report’s | slope within 0.2 per radian of the measured | CP within 0.2 caliber of the measured |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| cone, fineness 3 | 24 of 24 (−0.006 to +0.024) | 24 of 24 (−0.003 to +0.040) | 20 of 20 (−0.128 to +0.145) | 19 of 20 (−0.194 to +0.250) |
| cone, fineness 5 | 23 of 24 (−0.003 to +0.066) | 24 of 24 (−0.003 to +0.072) | 20 of 20 (−0.075 to +0.176) | 19 of 20 (−0.165 to +0.272) |
| cone, fineness 7 | 11 of 24 (−0.001 to +0.146) | 16 of 24 (−0.003 to +0.257) | 18 of 20 (−0.061 to +0.251) | 16 of 20 (−0.153 to +0.328) |
| tangent ogive, fineness 3 | 12 of 24 (−0.115 to +0.014) | 19 of 24 (−0.670 to +0.062) | 19 of 20 (−0.278 to +0.008) | 17 of 20 (−0.540 to +0.104) |
| tangent ogive, fineness 5 | 15 of 24 (−0.134 to +0.009) | 20 of 24 (−0.181 to +0.090) | 20 of 20 (−0.111 to +0.138) | 19 of 20 (−0.143 to +0.217) |
| tangent ogive, fineness 7 | 17 of 24 (−0.072 to +0.013) | 22 of 24 (−0.107 to +0.128) | 20 of 20 (−0.107 to +0.142) | 19 of 20 (−0.206 to +0.147) |
The 12 cones with no cylinder only read Fig. 2 back, so against the report’s values they check the hand reading, not the method.
A worked example: a cone of fineness 5 on a cylinder 4 calibers long, at Mach 4.24. Slender-body theory gives 2 per radian at any length. The tip cone alone gives 1.868 (Fig. 2). With the cylinder HPR Sim gives 2.922, the report 2.91, and the wind tunnel 2.84.
Against the measurements, 117 of 120 slopes and 109 of 120 centers of pressure are within the report’s ±0.2. Against the report’s own values, 102 of 144 slopes and 125 of 144 centers of pressure are within 0.05 and 0.1. That is 75 of the 528 comparisons outside, so the targets are not met (ADR-033 records it):
- Against the report’s own values (61 misses), in two kinds.
- Where the march stays inside the method’s limit (49 misses), HPR Sim follows the printed equations and the printed values depart from them. The largest misses are two. One is the fineness-7 cone on long cylinders (HPR Sim high, up to +0.146 at Mach 6.28 over 10 calibers). The other is the ogives (HPR Sim low, most at fineness 5 and Mach 3, down to −0.134). The evidence is a second implementation of the same equations, written from the paper with its own cone solver. For the cone-cylinders it used the report’s closed form (its Appendix C), for the ogives its ten-element march. With HPR Sim’s hand-read Fig. 2, the second implementation agrees with HPR Sim within 0.0001 per radian on all 72 cone-cylinders. With the same Fig. 2 it agrees within 0.0006 per radian and 0.0003 calibers on the 60 ogive-cylinders that stay inside the limit. It is an uncommitted scratch script by the same author, so it can’t be rerun from the repository. It can’t catch a misreading both share. Why the printed values differ is not known. The report took its cone pressures from charts (its Fig. 1), and a thin cone’s small pressure differences are sensitive to them. That is a guess, not a finding.
- Where the march reaches the method’s limit (12 misses), on the fineness-3 ogive at Mach 5.05 and 6.28, near the tip. There HPR Sim’s CP at Mach 5.05 sits 0.19 to 0.67 calibers ahead of the report’s. The report’s measurements agree with the report, so this is HPR Sim’s gap, not the report’s. The report doesn’t say how it continued past its limit. Carrying the pressure gradient on through the reduced elements comes closer at Mach 5.05 but further at Mach 6.28. The result doesn’t settle as elements are added. This is open (issue #81).
- Against the measurements (14 misses), in four groups:
- The fineness-7 cone on long cylinders (6). The report is already 0.07 to 0.15 high there, and HPR Sim, following the closed form, adds 0.06 to 0.19 more.
- Rows where the report is itself 0.20 to 0.22 off (3): the fineness-5 and fineness-3 cones’ CP at Mach 6.28 over 10 calibers. The third is the fineness-5 ogive’s at Mach 5.05 over 10.
- The fineness-3 ogive at Mach 5.05 (4): the limit above; the worst misses, −0.278 per radian and −0.540 calibers.
- The fineness-7 ogive’s CP at Mach 5.05 over 4 calibers (1): −0.206, just outside, where the report reads −0.13.
The Arcas Robin ([D4014], the wind tunnel of Normal force through Mach 1). The method needed a pointed tip when this comparison was made. The committed nose, behind the cap it now takes, is compared in Blunt tips. So here the nose is the secant ogive (a circular arc meeting the body at an angle) through the tip and base. It best fits the report’s coordinate table and is 4.17 calibers long. So the report’s Mach-over-fineness range of 0.4 to 2 covers Mach 1.67 to 8.3. The arc radius is 1.744 times a tangent ogive’s, the nose misses the table by 0.003 in rms, and its tip half-angle is 10.76°. HPR Sim’s committed design keeps its power-series nose, whose tip is blunt. The measured slope is the fins-off reading fitted over the plotted angles, as above. It includes the boattail, the lip behind it, and crossflow lift at those angles. The method has neither the lip nor crossflow at , and takes the boattail only by the report’s footnote 8. So the target is not applied here. It is applied to the body a flight flies, in The body alone, against the 15% target. This table is the method’s own; the body a flight flies since M1.8e6, with the boattail’s measured share, is compared below.
| model | Mach | measured, per rad | nose and cylinder, per rad | error | with boattail (footnote 8), per rad | error |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| short | 1.5 | 2.192 | 2.552 | +16.4% | 2.375 | +8.3% |
| short | 1.8 | 2.613 | 2.724 | +4.3% | 2.580 | −1.2% |
| short | 2.3 | 3.078 | 2.931 | −4.8% | 2.828 | −8.1% |
| short | 2.96 | 3.284 | 3.124 | −4.9% | 3.056 | −6.9% |
| short | 3.96 | 3.884 | 3.300 | −15.0% | 3.262 | −16.0% |
| short | 4.63 | 4.149 | 3.371 | −18.7% | 3.345 | −19.4% |
| long | 1.8 | 3.159 | 2.724 | −13.7% | 2.581 | −18.3% |
| long | 2.3 | 3.525 | 2.932 | −16.8% | 2.829 | −19.8% |
| long | 2.96 | 3.868 | 3.127 | −19.2% | 3.059 | −20.9% |
| long | 3.96 | 4.455 | 3.313 | −25.6% | 3.275 | −26.5% |
| long | 4.63 | 4.615 | 3.395 | −26.4% | 3.369 | −27.0% |
The method’s slope grows with Mach number, as the measurement does. On the short model it runs 2.55 to 3.37, where slender-body theory keeps its nose at 2. By the end of either cylinder the lift has died away, so the long model gets almost nothing more (3.313 against 3.300 at Mach 3.96). The long model’s measurement is 0.57 higher than the short model’s. That difference goes with the longer body’s larger side area, the mark of crossflow lift. The boattail column here is the report’s footnote 8, the method’s own rule. A flight used it from M1.8e4. Since M1.8e6 a flight takes Washington and Pettis’s measured share instead (the worked example under The body faster than sound in a flight).
The table above is the method alone, at . A flight also adds body lift, which grows as ; the table leaves it out, and the measured line includes it.
Most of that gap was the comparison, not missing lift.
M1.8e5 sized each cause of it on HPR Sim’s body model before
M1.8e6: Galejs’s body lift and footnote 8’s boattail.
The research note has the tables. The measurement is a straight line through points
from about −5° to +4°, and crossflow lift, which grows as , steepens it. HPR Sim’s body is fitted the same way
at the same angles. With its boattail and the body lift a flight added, it read 14.9%
to 73.2% high at every Mach number. The fixture is arcas-robin-gap.json, which
cargo xtask aero writes and aero_gap::tests::committed_fixture_is_current keeps current.
- Crossflow lift steepens that fitted line. In HPR Sim’s body lift it adds 1.40 to 2.09 per radian. In the tunnel’s own points (fitted with an term, the curvature) it adds 0.09 to 1.74. From Mach 2.3 the tunnel’s curvature matches body lift with a factor from 0.66 to 1.05, each ±0.18 to ±0.23 (one standard error). HPR Sim used 1.1 (Bodies of revolution). Jorgensen’s crossflow method ([J77] eq. 2.12, Fig. 4 and p. 15) gives about 0.9 for these bodies at small angles.
- The fit’s slope at and its curvature move together (their errors correlate at −0.95 to −0.96). So the readings can’t split HPR Sim’s excess between body lift and its slope at . With body lift at Jorgensen’s size alone, HPR Sim still reads 8.2% to 60.7% high.
- The one sized cause that size is the boattail’s share: TN 3527’s footnote 8, which a flight used, gives −0.177 to −0.026, slender-body theory −1.324. The lip, which the method can’t take, adds +0.178 by slender-body theory. A blunt tip like the tunnel’s, scaled from a blunter one measured, loses 0.015 to 0.07 past Mach 3. Below Mach 3 the tangent cones’ slopes are held at TN 3527’s Fig. 2 Mach 3 curve. There, Sims’s tables ([S64] Table 2, p. 20) move the nose and cylinder’s share by −0.031 to +0.056 at most. HPR Sim’s reading of issue #81 (how it continues the method where TN 3527’s relaxation condition fails) changes nothing on this body.
From then on the Arcas Robin is judged like for like, at the tunnel’s angles (ADR-036).
Crossflow’s size and the boattail’s share, together. Since M1.8e6 (ADR-037), body lift takes Jorgensen’s crossflow (Body lift). A boattail takes Washington and Pettis’s measured share (The body faster than sound in a flight). Fitted like for like, as the tunnel’s line is, the same body reads +3.4% to +41.0%. Each change takes about half of the old excess off. From Mach 3.96 both models are within 15%. From Mach 1.5 to 2.96 HPR Sim still reads 16% to 41% high. The columns are HPR Sim’s body model before M1.8e6, each change alone, and both. The last column is the current model’s slope at , which leaves body lift out. Slopes per radian on the body’s cross-section; the measured line’s standard error takes each reading’s accuracy as independent.
| model | Mach | measured, fitted, per rad | before, per rad | Jorgensen’s crossflow alone, per rad | measured boattail alone, per rad | both (current), per rad | current at , per rad |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| short | 1.5 | 2.19 ± 0.09 | 3.80 (+73.2%) | 3.53 (+61.2%) | 3.35 (+52.9%) | 3.09 (+41.0%) | 1.93 |
| short | 1.8 | 2.61 ± 0.09 | 3.98 (+52.2%) | 3.72 (+42.4%) | 3.57 (+36.6%) | 3.31 (+26.8%) | 2.17 |
| short | 2.3 | 3.08 ± 0.08 | 4.29 (+39.4%) | 4.03 (+30.8%) | 3.92 (+27.2%) | 3.65 (+18.6%) | 2.45 |
| short | 2.96 | 3.28 ± 0.08 | 4.54 (+38.1%) | 4.28 (+30.2%) | 4.20 (+27.8%) | 3.94 (+19.8%) | 2.72 |
| short | 3.96 | 3.88 ± 0.09 | 4.71 (+21.3%) | 4.47 (+15.0%) | 4.41 (+13.6%) | 4.17 (+7.3%) | 2.96 |
| short | 4.63 | 4.15 ± 0.09 | 4.79 (+15.5%) | 4.57 (+10.2%) | 4.51 (+8.7%) | 4.29 (+3.4%) | 3.06 |
| long | 1.8 | 3.16 ± 0.11 | 4.50 (+42.4%) | 4.20 (+33.0%) | 4.09 (+29.4%) | 3.79 (+20.0%) | 2.17 |
| long | 2.3 | 3.53 ± 0.11 | 4.80 (+36.1%) | 4.50 (+27.6%) | 4.42 (+25.5%) | 4.12 (+17.0%) | 2.45 |
| long | 2.96 | 3.87 ± 0.11 | 5.14 (+32.9%) | 4.84 (+25.1%) | 4.80 (+24.1%) | 4.50 (+16.3%) | 2.72 |
| long | 3.96 | 4.46 ± 0.11 | 5.23 (+17.3%) | 4.96 (+11.2%) | 4.92 (+10.5%) | 4.66 (+4.5%) | 2.97 |
| long | 4.63 | 4.62 ± 0.11 | 5.30 (+14.9%) | 5.06 (+9.7%) | 5.02 (+8.7%) | 4.78 (+3.5%) | 3.08 |
The rows are in
arcas-robin-crossflow.json,
which cargo xtask aero writes and aero_crossflow::tests::committed_fixture_is_current keeps
current; aero_crossflow::tests::the_guide_quotes_the_fixture checks this table against it cell
by cell. What is left at Mach 1.5 to 2.96 can’t be split between body lift and the slope at
from these readings, as M1.8e5 found. On the short
model at Mach 1.5 and 1.8 the tunnel’s points from −5° to +4° barely curve. The factors on body lift are 0.32 ± 0.24
and 0.07 ± 0.25, where HPR Sim uses about 0.9. HPR Sim’s slope at (1.93
and 2.17) lies within about one standard error of the tunnel’s. The tunnel’s values are 1.78 ± 0.32 and 2.52 ± 0.33, and HPR Sim’s is 1.1 standard errors below the second. There most of the excess is body lift. At 6° it is about half of HPR Sim’s normal force, and the points at 6° need a factor of 0.47 and 0.58 on it. From Mach 2.3 the points do curve. Their curvature gives factors of 0.66 to 1.05, each within about one standard error (±0.18 to ±0.23) of Jorgensen’s, five of the eight below it. The fixture also holds each of the 62 points above +4° and
the boattail’s share at under each rule. One caution on the long model: its points from
−5° to +4° are M1.8a’s reading. That reading may carry a skew of the
page that puts its slope 3% to 5% high
(issue #97). Its rows here depend on how that is
settled.
Where the body’s lift acts. A body model can match the slope with its lift in the wrong place.
So the body’s center of pressure is checked too. It comes from the tunnel’s fins-off pitching moment (read into
arcas-robin-fins-off-moment.json,
±0.02 to ±0.025 in ). Both are taken the way the tunnel’s are. They are straight lines through the
pitching moment and the normal force at the plotted angles up to ±4.5°, calibers from the nose
tip. The measured ones carry about ±0.5 calibers from the readings. The measured boattail share,
which takes lift off at the tail, moves HPR Sim’s center of pressure forward, toward the tunnel’s.
Before M1.8e6 HPR Sim put it 0.90 to 3.85 calibers aft of the tunnel’s on the short model and 0.59 to
1.94 on the long. Now it is −0.19 to +1.59 and −0.88 to −0.18. Five rows still miss by more than the
readings’ half a caliber. The largest are the short model at Mach 1.5 (+1.59), where the slope misses most too, and the long one at 3.96 (−0.88). The other three are the short model at Mach 1.8 and 2.96 and the long one at 2.96.
| model | Mach | measured, calibers from the tip | before, calibers | current, calibers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| short | 1.5 | 1.00 | 4.85 (+3.85) | 2.59 (+1.59) |
| short | 1.8 | 2.36 | 4.98 (+2.62) | 3.03 (+0.68) |
| short | 2.3 | 3.56 | 5.27 (+1.71) | 3.67 (+0.10) |
| short | 2.96 | 3.21 | 5.20 (+1.99) | 3.77 (+0.56) |
| short | 3.96 | 4.88 | 5.79 (+0.91) | 4.69 (−0.19) |
| short | 4.63 | 5.05 | 5.94 (+0.90) | 4.95 (−0.09) |
| long | 1.8 | 4.61 | 6.55 (+1.94) | 4.27 (−0.33) |
| long | 2.3 | 5.04 | 6.79 (+1.74) | 4.86 (−0.18) |
| long | 2.96 | 5.33 | 6.43 (+1.11) | 4.65 (−0.68) |
| long | 3.96 | 6.19 | 6.78 (+0.59) | 5.31 (−0.88) |
| long | 4.63 | 6.40 | 7.35 (+0.96) | 6.12 (−0.28) |
Drag verification
-
RocketPy’s drag curves at Mach 0.3 (
tests::rocketpy_drag_curves_at_mach_0_3, fixturevalidation/fixtures/aero/rocketpy-drag-curves.json, written bycargo xtask aerofromrefs/rocketpy). Every RocketPy example whose curve is labeled RASAero, at sea level in the 1976 standard atmosphere (USSA76). RASAero II computes its exports’ Reynolds numbers there. Tolerance 10%. The fixture holds only derived numbers: each curve’s value at Mach 0.3, HPR Sim’s and the error. The test recomputes HPR Sim’s and the errors from the committed designs, andcargo test -p xtaskreruns the comparison whenrefs/rocketpyis present.case curve HPR Sim drag coefficient error Calisto, 2018 fins RASAero II export, power-off 0.3821 +0.2% Calisto, getting-started fins (variant) (outside 10%) the same 0.3376 −11.5% Juno III (outside 10%) labeled RASAero II, 3-decimal table 0.3364 −10.3% Cavour, power-off labeled RASAero II, 3-decimal table 0.5034 −8.3% Cavour, power-on (outside 10%) the same, power-on 0.4487 −18.3% Valetudo, power-off (outside 10%) labeled RASAero, 3-decimal table 0.5566 −47.0% Valetudo, power-on (outside 10%) the same, power-on 0.5189 −50.4% Calisto, the getting-started variant and Juno III are boattailed: since ADR-362, the base held to the Hermes A-3A, their base keeps of the flat-base value below Mach 0.8, which took Calisto from +4.4% to +0.2% and the other two from −7.3% and −6.0% to outside 10%. One code against another sizes the difference; it doesn’t say which code is right.
- Inputs (ADR-009, the drag decision). The exports record none, so the designs follow one declared rule:
- RASAero II’s default smooth finish.
- A NACA 00xx airfoil file in the example gives an airfoil section that thick at the mean aerodynamic chord (Calisto’s getting-started fins).
- A published section is used. Juno III’s team placed second for a technical award, cited for “análise de aletas com perfil de aerofólio truncado” (an analysis of truncated-airfoil fins). It is taken as rounded at the placeholder thickness, since the citation gives no thickness.
- Otherwise the placeholder, square 3 mm (0.12 in, Calisto’s 2018 fins, Cavour, Valetudo).
- Rail buttons are as RocketPy defines them.
- Sensitivity. The fins’ section (square, rounded or airfoil), their thickness and the finish move Calisto’s rows within 10% by band as
tests::calistos_rows_by_fin_and_finishpins (below); the rail buttons move a case too, not re-measured since ADR-362. The check places HPR Sim near RASAero’s subsonic drag under a declared rule; without the inputs it can’t show agreement to 10%. - Power-on. Separate power-on curves are compared (Cavour’s and Valetudo’s). Subtracting the motor’s area ([N09] pp. 50–51) removes 42% of Cavour’s base drag and 29% of Valetudo’s at Mach 0.3. Cavour’s power-on table is within its 0.001 rounding of power-off from Mach 0.16 up (0.0001 at 0.3). Below Mach 0.16 it is 0.001 to 0.013 lower. Valetudo’s is 0.004 lower, about a ninth of HPR Sim’s relief. The designs’ motor diameter is the larger of the grain and nozzle exit diameters, since RocketPy gives no case. Cavour’s result depends on it: −8.3% with no relief and −14.8% at 54 mm (2.1 in). It is −18.3% at the design’s 67 mm (2.6 in) nozzle exit and −20.8% with the example’s 75 mm motor. The cause of that miss stays open. One candidate is Niskanen’s rule of taking the motor’s area off the base. Others are a RASAero run with little or no nozzle exit diameter, or tables sampled along a flight. Their uneven Mach spacing suggests the last (unconfirmed).
- Valetudo. Its table (1.05) is 1.44 times the OpenRocket export for the same rocket (0.728). With that file’s own inputs (60 µm, two 14 mm × 30 mm lugs, 3 mm (0.12 in) square fins), HPR Sim gives 0.714. That is 1.9% under the OpenRocket export and 32% under the table. As designed for this comparison, its 0.5566 is 23.5% under the export.
- Not compared.
- Calisto’s power-on curve, which equals its power-off curve (no nozzle exit diameter in RASAero).
- Juno III’s power-on drag, which RocketPy takes from the same file.
- The other examples, whose drag is a constant, CFD or of unknown origin.
- Inputs (ADR-009, the drag decision). The exports record none, so the designs follow one declared rule:
-
Loft lessons, each with what it concerns:
- L11, drag that changed with the order of the fin sets:
drag::tests::drag_invariant_to_fin_set_order - L12, uncited form-factor, friction and roughness constants:
drag::tests::form_factor_and_roughness_match_cited_values - L13, no relief of base drag while a motor burns:
drag::tests::power_on_base_drag_subtracts_thrusting_motor_area - L14, uncited launch-lug drag:
drag::tests::launch_lug_drag_matches_cited_hollow_tube_formula - L15, shoulder drag that jumped as its length went to zero:
drag::tests::shoulder_drag_continuous_as_transition_length_tends_to_zero - L16, a silent cap on the drag coefficient that hid bad geometry:
drag::tests::malformed_geometry_is_an_error_not_a_clamped_cd - L90, drag invariants, a check kept from Loft’s tests (skin friction’s published jumps, split fin sets, base drag at Mach 1):
drag::tests::skin_friction_follows_eq_3_81_and_drag_invariants_hold
- L11, drag that changed with the order of the fin sets:
-
Limits of every term (
drag::tests):- Friction below , at and to Mach 5.
- Stagnation pressure against the isentropic series and its limits either side of Mach 1.
- Base drag at rest, at Mach 1 and far above.
- The joint term from smooth to a step.
- The boattail factor’s three pieces and their joins.
- Fin pressure drag by cross-section with the leading edge’s joins at Mach 0.9 and 1 and the sweep.
- The angle-of-attack factor’s stated values and zero slopes, monotonicity and its sign-reversed mirror (and at 135°).
- Joint angles of cones and power-series, Haack and ogive noses.
- Curved boattails ending in blunt tips.
- A tail closing to a point.
- Leading-edge sweeps of trapezoids, kinked outlines and ellipses (against a quadrature to 1e-8).
- A whole rocket’s buildup written out by hand to 1e-12, its component sum, and override tables (rescaled to another reference diameter).
-
Drag through Mach 1 (
nose_drag::tests,drag::tests):drag::tests::leading_edge_and_cone_pressure_drag_have_supersonic_branchescovers Loft lesson L17: Loft’s fin leading-edge drag frozen at its Mach 1 value and nose drag with no Mach term.- A 3:1 cone by hand from rest through eq. B.4, with its joins smooth to 1e-5.
- The ogive factor at its ends and middle.
- Eq. B.9 through both its anchors.
- Eq. 3.87 meeting its lower bound and its fallback.
- A step from 0.8 to the flat face.
- Short cones tending to the step and meeting the closed form at fineness 1 (Loft lesson L15).
- Stoney’s curves reproduced at fineness 3, held past their ends and interpolated between shapes.
- The guide’s worked example.
- The 3:1 cone against Stoney’s measured one.
- Refused shapes.
- A property test: every shape at any fineness, joint angle and Mach number to 5 gives a finite, non-negative coefficient. The coefficient has no jump at .
-
Boattails faster than sound (
afterbody::tests):- The Prandtl-Meyer function against NACA Report 1135’s table and its limit of 130.45°, and its inverse.
- An expansion’s pressure by hand and at the vacuum limit.
- The chart giving back its readings, falling with and the area ratio, and reaching 0 at .
- Calisto’s boattail by hand (the guide’s worked example) with the joins at Mach 0.9, 1 and 1.2.
- The drag past the chart continuous at its end and closing on the 2D limit.
- Separation from 16° to 30°.
- The base-pressure ratio on Fig. 5-141’s line, and to Mach 0.8.
- Every boattail from 1° to 89° finite and non-negative to Mach 5.
- The comparison with measured boattails and Jack’s theory is
tests::boattails_against_measurements.
-
Boattails in parts, wakes and gaps (
drag::tests): a boattail split in two drags as one (a_boattail_split_in_two_drags_as_one). So does a straight cone of 0.5° to 7° in 2, 4 or 8 parts, where a part’s share is below 0 too (a_straight_cone_in_parts_is_one_cone). A corner keeps two parts apart and the merge is continuous in the turn (a_sharp_corner_keeps_its_boattails_apart). A pair drags between its two limits (soft_merges_stay_between_their_limits). A partial merge shares the flow (a_partial_merge_shares_the_flow). A change of in any radius or length behind 2° to 14° boattails moves the drag in proportion to (a_part_narrowing_by_nothing_is_a_tube_and_one_of_no_length_a_step). A lip’s wake is tested by its rise and its gaps (a_lip_in_a_boattails_wake_fades_with_its_rise,a_lip_drawn_as_a_step_up_is_a_lip,a_hairline_step_before_a_lip_changes_nothing). A retainer behind a step down is in its wake (a_retainer_behind_a_step_down_is_in_its_wake). A 40-part zigzag keeps its tails few (a_zigzag_boattail_keeps_its_tails_few). -
Tables (
table::tests): the tests parse RocketPy’s quirks (\r\n,01.05, a repeated row), a byte-order mark, quoted fields and trailing commas. They parse RASAero II’s header with rows at 2° and 4° skipped. They report malformed text (a bad first row, repeated or unsorted Mach numbers,nan) by line.
Base drag under power against the Hermes A-3A’s flight
This checks HPR Sim’s base drag below Mach 0.8, coasting and while a motor burns, against a measured flight rather than another program. NACA flew rocket-propelled models of the Hermes A-3A with the motor burning and then coasting, and measured the pressure on the base (Jackson 1955, NACA RM SL55F15, Fig. 20; an error believed to be less than ±0.005, and ±0.001 more for reading the figure). The model narrows to its 4.8 in base along a long 4.5° cone. Its motor, a nominal 5 in case, sits forward, and a blast tube carries the jet to a 3.0 in nozzle exit at the base, past fixed vanes.
- Under power, HPR Sim’s rule as it flies reads low. It takes the motor case’s area off the base, down to zero, and this case is wider than the base: it leaves no base drag, where the flight measured 0.0204 to 0.0270 on the model’s largest cross-section. Too little drag gives too high an apogee, the optimistic side for a target altitude (which error flatters).
- Given only the nozzle exit, the same rule comes within 0.007, from 0.0040 low to 0.0061 high. The whole base kept under power, the area OpenRocket 24.12 keeps, reads high by 0.0108 to 0.0230 on HPR Sim’s coefficient; on OpenRocket’s own, the flat-base rule with no relief behind a boattail, by 0.036 to 0.052 (the fixture’s flat-base column less the measured).
- Coasting, HPR Sim reads high: 3.0 to 5.1 times the measured base drag, high by 0.025 to 0.035. Behind a boattail below Mach 0.8 HPR Sim keeps of the flat-base value, here 0.6 ([S61] p. 11; since ADR-362, the base held to this flight); before, it gave no relief and read high by 0.050 to 0.064, 5.0 to 8.4 times the measured. Hoerner’s rule, which also takes the forebody’s friction into account, reads high by 0.012 to 0.016 ([H65] eq. 35).
- The jet more than doubled the measured base drag, where HPR Sim’s rule lowers it and the whole base keeps it. Neither rule moves the way the flight did.
The rows, a worked example and how far this carries to a hobby rocket are on the accuracy page
(the base under power, against a measured flight).
The rows are written by cargo xtask aero to
validation/fixtures/aero/base-drag-under-power.json,
also in the fixture report,
and which way each rule errs is held by tests
(xtask/src/aero_base_power/tests.rs).
The comparison with OpenRocket that points at this term splits the drag below Mach 0.8 by term
(the slowest band, by term).
Drag against the Arcas Robin wind tunnel
NASA measured the axial force on its half-scale Arcas Robin models, the same ones as the normal force above ([D4013], [D4014]). The runs covered Mach 0.6 to 4.63, with fins at 0° and fins off. The
models sat on a sting, so their base pressure isn’t a free flight’s. Both reports take the base apart. [D4013] plots the axial force “corrected for base axial force” (, Figs. 11–12). [D4014] plots the axial force and, separately, the force on the balance chamber inside the base
(, Figs. 4–6). What compares is the forebody. HPR Sim’s less its base drag (friction, pressure and parasitic drag) against the measured axial force with the base at the free stream’s pressure. For [D4014] that is , which takes the chamber’s pressure over
the whole base as [D4013]’s correction does. 1.383 is : the base’s diameter in inches
over the 1.250-inch cavity drawn in [D4014] Fig. 1(a), squared. The report states no chamber area. Taking the pressure over the chamber alone moves the measured values by 0.002 to 0.015, which
changes no row’s verdict. The readings are in
arcas-robin-wind-tunnel.json, read off the reports’ plots. Each has its figure, page and reading uncertainty (±0.002 in for most, against the reports’ own ±0.004).
HPR Sim flies the committed designs (Normal force through Mach 1) at
both tunnels’ Reynolds number, 3.0 million per foot. Two inputs are set for drag before measuring: the double-wedge fins take HPR Sim’s airfoil section, as Niskanen modeled them ([N09] p. 90). HPR Sim gives the machined steel models a polished finish, 0.5 µm, since the reports state none. The target, set
before measuring, was M1.8’s 10% for drag. cargo xtask aero writes
drag-vs-mach.json, each row with HPR Sim’s drag by part. tests::drag_against_mach recomputes it from the designs and pins the 2 rows of 44 within target.
The two input choices matter, and moved HPR Sim toward the tunnel. With square edges and the default
20 µm finish no row is within target. With the airfoil section alone none is, with the polished finish alone none is, and with both 2 are (tests::drag_against_mach_depends_on_the_fins_and_finish).
The airfoil section follows the drawings and Niskanen; the finish is a guess. Allowing each
reading its uncertainty and the reports’ ±0.004, neither of the 2 could fall the other side of
10%. Before
M1.8b3 modeled the boattail faster than sound and the lip
in its wake, 8 rows were within target. Six were within target because the lip’s 0.085 made up for the missing
wave drag. Forebody drag on the reference area, measured and HPR Sim’s, and HPR Sim’s error:
| Mach | fins | short: measured drag coefficient | HPR Sim drag coefficient | error | long: measured drag coefficient | HPR Sim drag coefficient | error |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.6 | on | 0.2987 | 0.3371 | +12.9% | 0.3455 | 0.3874 | +12.1% |
| 0.6 | off | 0.2217 | 0.2523 | +13.8% | 0.2477 | 0.3041 | +22.8% |
| 0.8 | on | 0.3299 | 0.4200 | +27.3% | 0.3706 | 0.4688 | +26.5% |
| 0.8 | off | 0.2308 | 0.2585 | +12.0% | 0.2517 | 0.3088 | +22.7% |
| 0.9 | on | 0.4202 | 0.6346 | +51.0% | 0.4510 | 0.6826 | +51.3% |
| 0.9 | off | 0.2610 | 0.3623 | +38.8% | 0.2671 | 0.4116 | +54.1% |
| 0.95 | on | 0.5680 | 0.6722 | +18.3% | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| 0.95 | off | 0.2916 | 0.4214 | +44.5% | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| 1.0 | on | 0.6858 | 0.7344 | +7.1% | 0.7247 | 0.7825 | +8.0% |
| 1.0 | off | 0.4194 | 0.5044 | +20.3% | 0.3674 | 0.5540 | +50.8% |
| 1.2 | on | 0.5935 | 0.7706 | +29.8% | 0.6245 | 0.8172 | +30.9% |
| 1.2 | off | 0.4311 | 0.5187 | +20.3% | 0.4220 | 0.5667 | +34.3% |
| 1.5 | on | 0.4932 | 0.6873 | +39.4% | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| 1.5 | off | 0.3401 | 0.4148 | +22.0% | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| 1.8 | on | 0.4260 | 0.6412 | +50.5% | 0.4543 | 0.6827 | +50.3% |
| 1.8 | off | 0.3142 | 0.3570 | +13.6% | 0.3267 | 0.3997 | +22.3% |
| 2.3 | on | 0.3328 | 0.5879 | +76.7% | 0.3730 | 0.6251 | +67.6% |
| 2.3 | off | 0.2474 | 0.2940 | +18.8% | 0.2927 | 0.3323 | +13.5% |
| 2.96 | on | 0.2639 | 0.5409 | +105.0% | 0.3010 | 0.5729 | +90.3% |
| 2.96 | off | 0.2030 | 0.2423 | +19.4% | 0.2362 | 0.2753 | +16.6% |
| 3.96 | on | 0.2056 | 0.4928 | +139.7% | 0.2342 | 0.5186 | +121.4% |
| 3.96 | off | 0.1554 | 0.1929 | +24.1% | 0.1894 | 0.2195 | +15.9% |
| 4.63 | on | 0.1850 | 0.4700 | +154.0% | 0.2113 | 0.4926 | +133.1% |
| 4.63 | off | 0.1390 | 0.1704 | +22.6% | 0.1648 | 0.1937 | +17.5% |
Why it misses, from the drag by part in the fixture:
- The fins past Mach 1.2. HPR Sim’s fins add about 0.30 from Mach 1.5 up. The measured fins-on less fins-off falls from 0.153 at Mach 1.5 to 0.046 at 4.63. HPR Sim’s increment is 78% above the measured increment at Mach 1.5 and 551% above it at 4.63 on the short model. The leading edge takes [N09]’s rounded-edge formula. Its value grows toward 1.2 on the fins’ frontal area, where a thin, sharp fin’s wave drag falls with Mach. Niskanen’s own comparison with this wind tunnel shows the same, his simulation about 80% high by Mach 3.96 ([N09] Fig. 6.6, p. 90). At Mach 0.6 HPR Sim’s fins are +10% and −15% of the measured increment. From 0.8 to 0.9 they rise sooner than the measured fins do.
- The boattail faster than sound. HPR Sim’s 15° boattail drags 0.285 from Mach 1.0 to 1.2, 0.196 at 1.5 and 0.037 at 4.63 (Boattails faster than sound). If the rest of HPR Sim’s forebody were right, the tunnel’s boattail would drag about 0.12 at Mach 1.5 and 0.08 to 0.11 at 1.8. That is 40% to 94% under HPR Sim. From Mach 3.96 it would drag next to nothing. Cubbage’s 16° boattails, in a boundary layer a fifth of the diameter thick, read high the same way, 26% to 54%. NASA reports the flow separating over this boattail at the higher Mach numbers ([D4014] p. 6). With the fins off HPR Sim reads +13.5% to +24.1% from Mach 1.5 (issue #72).
- The lip. The models end in a lip 1.3 mm (0.051 in) long. It flares from the boattail’s 33.2 mm (1.3 in) to the base’s 37.3 mm (1.5 in). It sits in the boattail’s wake, and HPR Sim gives it no pressure drag. Before M1.8b3 HPR Sim took it as a shoulder in the free stream, a stubby cone. It was worth 0.065 at Mach 0.6 and 0.084 to 0.086 from Mach 1.2. The short model keeps the fins’ raised root fairings with its fins off. HPR Sim leaves them out, and TN D-4013 blames them for its higher drag from Mach 0.975 to 1.2 (pp. 4–5).
- The boattail below Mach 1. [N09]’s boattail rule (eq. 3.88) gives the 15° boattail a pressure drag of 0.063 at Mach 0.6 (its 0.070 less its friction). The tunnel’s forebody holds that same pressure on the boattail’s surface. On the short model the whole forebody with its fins off measures 0.22 at Mach 0.6, against HPR Sim’s friction alone of 0.19. Little is left for the boattail’s pressure. The rule over-predicts this boattail, as Niskanen found against the same tunnel ([N09] p. 90). At Mach 0.6 and 0.8 HPR Sim’s forebody with its fins off is +12.0% to +22.8% high, most of it the boattail rule.
- Through Mach 1, where drag rises steeply, the short model’s measured forebody with fins off jumps from 0.29 to 0.42 between Mach 0.95 and 1.0. HPR Sim’s boattail rises from 0.076 at Mach 0.8 to 0.285 at 1.0, sooner than the tunnel’s. HPR Sim’s forebody with its fins off reads +38.8% to +54.1% from Mach 0.9 to 0.95 and +20.3% to +50.8% from Mach 1.0 to 1.2.
HPR Sim’s drag reads high for this rocket at every Mach number. From about Mach 1.2 the main cause is the thin, sharp fins, which HPR Sim takes as blunt. At every speed the steep boattail adds to it. The body alone reads +12.0% to +54.1%. Before HPR Sim modeled the boattail faster than sound, with the lip in it and no wave drag, it read −9.2% to +71.1%. The tunnel can’t measure HPR Sim’s base drag. It is compared with a calculation (Drag against MIL-HDBK-762’s sample calculation) and, behind boattails, with measured bases (Boattails faster than sound).
Drag through the speed of sound draws this comparison for a flier and marks the side that flatters. A drag that reads high reads the apogee low, as the test
a_higher_drag_reads_a_lower_apogee pins.
Drag against RASAero II through Mach 2
M1.8 asks for drag within 10% of the curves labeled RASAero in RocketPy’s example rockets from Mach 0.1 to 2.0, with the errors by band. HPR Sim doesn’t meet that. See ADR-029, the decision on this comparison, and ADR-030.
How it is compared. cargo xtask aero compares HPR Sim’s zero-lift
drag coefficient, , with each curve every 0.05 from
Mach 0.1 to 2.0, wherever the curve reaches. Each point is at sea level in the 1976 standard
atmosphere, at the Reynolds number for its Mach number, as
RASAero II computes its exports. The designs and their inputs are those of the Mach 0.3 check
above. Bands are Niskanen’s (Table 3.1): subsonic to Mach 0.8, transonic below 1.2, supersonic from
1.2. The fixture, rocketpy-drag-curves.json, holds HPR Sim’s value and the error
at every Mach number and each band’s summary. It doesn’t hold the curves, but the two numbers
give a curve’s value back at each Mach number.
drag::tests::supersonic_cd_against_rasaero_tables recomputes every row and pins the counts
(Loft lesson L18: Loft, the earlier simulator this project
learns from, used an invented transonic drag curve).
The curves don’t all reach Mach 2. Calisto’s, the one real RASAero II export, does (evidence row G26). Juno III’s is hand-edited past Mach 0.92. It climbs a constant step per row to Mach 1.0 and then drops to 0.001, so the comparison stops at 0.92. Cavour’s stop below Mach 0.93, and Valetudo’s at 1.53.
Rows within 10%, and the range of the errors, by band:
| case | to Mach | subsonic, to 0.8 | transonic | supersonic, from 1.2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Calisto, 2018 fins | 2 | 15 of 15: −1.7% to +3.3% | 5 of 7: −10.1% to +13.4% | 8 of 17: −14.9% to −5.1% |
| Calisto, getting-started fins (variant) | 2 | 8 of 15: −12.1% to +24.5% | 0 of 7: +13.5% to +62.3% | 0 of 17: +22.6% to +31.7% |
| Juno III | 0.9 | 12 of 15: −10.7% to +2.4% | 0 of 2: +14.0% to +28.3% | n/a |
| Cavour, power-off | 0.85 | 6 of 15: −12.6% to −2.2% | 0 of 1: −12.6% | n/a |
| Cavour, power-on | 0.9 | 1 of 15: −26.2% to −9.2% | 0 of 2: −27.0% to −26.7% | n/a |
| Valetudo, power-off | 1.5 | 0 of 15: −51.4% to −43.5% | 0 of 7: −53.3% to −50.9% | 0 of 7: −54.6% to −52.9% |
| Valetudo, power-on | 1.5 | 0 of 15: −55.6% to −46.6% | 0 of 7: −57.6% to −54.7% | 0 of 7: −57.8% to −56.2% |
The getting-started fins are a variant. RocketPy’s getting-started example gives Calisto larger fins with a thick NACA 0012 airfoil. But the export was made for the 2018 fins, whose normal force it matches. So the variant’s rows show how much the fins move drag, not a second agreement. Its thick fins now read 23% to 32% high faster than sound. Calisto on its 2018 fins is within 10% up to Mach 0.85, at 0.95 and 1.0, and from 1.1 to 1.55. It reads +13.4% at Mach 0.9, where its boattail’s rise starts sooner than RASAero II’s. It reads −10.1% at Mach 1.05. It falls below the curve from Mach 1.6, to −14.9% at 2.0. Valetudo’s curve is 1.44 times its own OpenRocket export, as the Mach 0.3 check found, and Cavour’s power-on miss is the same open question. Two misses are unexplained. Cavour’s power-off curve rises faster than HPR Sim’s through subsonic flow, from −8.3% at Mach 0.3 to −12.6% at 0.85. Juno III’s curve stays flat up to Mach 0.91. There HPR Sim’s has begun its rise, its nose’s and its boattail’s, +14.0% at Mach 0.85 and +28.3% at 0.9.
What the boattail’s wave drag changed. Calisto ends in a short, steep conical boattail: 0.47 calibers long, narrowing to 69% of the diameter, a slope of 18.4°. Until M1.8b3 HPR Sim gave it only a share of the base drag, 0.083 at Mach 1.2 and 0.050 at 2.0. HPR Sim read −29.8% to −24.4% from Mach 1.2. The boattail’s supersonic wave drag (Boattails faster than sound) is 0.283 at Mach 1.2, 0.190 at 1.5 and 0.120 at 2.0. Calisto’s base drag falls by a third. Together they close the gap from 0.204 to 0.035 at Mach 1.2 and from 0.128 to 0.077 at 2.0. RASAero II lists such drag as its own term, “other body wave” drag. Calisto’s 18.4° boattail is steeper than any attached boattail measured here. 16° boattails read 26% to 54% high. So this agreement is not support for the model at that angle. What is left grows with Mach number. Part of it is HPR Sim’s body, which reads 6% to 10% low faster than sound against a worked example with every input known (below).
The unrecorded inputs now span most of the rest. Calisto’s fins could be square, rounded or an
airfoil, 2 to 6.35 mm (0.079 to 0.25 in) thick, smooth or painted (tests::calistos_rows_by_fin_and_finish). The committed inputs are square, 3 mm (0.12 in) and smooth by the rule of the Mach 0.3 check. They have 15, 5 and 8 rows within 10% by band. Rounded fins 4.76 mm (0.19 in) thick, smooth, have 6, 5 and 14. Airfoil fins
6.35 mm (0.25 in) thick, smooth, have 3, 4 and 17. No combination has every row within 10%. Before the
wave drag no combination had rows within 10% both below Mach 0.8 and from Mach 1.2. HPR Sim keeps the stated rule rather than
picking the inputs that fit.
Drag against MIL-HDBK-762’s sample calculation
RASAero II’s curves can’t show which way HPR Sim leans, because their inputs are guessed. A reference with every input known can. MIL-HDBK-762 is the U.S. Army’s handbook for designing unguided rockets. It works one rocket’s drag through by its own methods, term by term, from Mach 0.5 to 3.2 ([762] Table 5-4, pp. 5-58 to 5-66). The rocket is 3.84 m (12.6 ft) long and 0.16 m (0.52 ft) across. It has a 3-caliber tangent ogive nose and a plain cylinder with no boattail. Its four fins are 0.32 m (1.0 ft) long, 51 mm (2.0 in) tall and 6.4 mm (0.25 in) thick. They are flush with the base (Fig. 5-155).
This is a calculation, not a measurement: it checks HPR Sim’s methods against another set of
methods, whose base drag comes from measured bases. The table is transcribed with its pages in
mil-hdbk-762-sample-drag.json, and every row sums to its printed total.
The rocket is validation/designs/mil-hdbk-762-sample-rocket.json, with a smooth finish, as the
handbook’s friction is. HPR Sim flies it at the table’s Reynolds numbers.
tests::drag_against_mil_hdbk_762_sample recomputes the comparison in
drag-vs-mach.json and pins the rows within 10%. The 10% target comes from
M1.8. HPR Sim’s numbers for this rocket were seen before it was
chosen as a reference, so this is not a blind test.
The fins are left out. The handbook draws each fin as a single wedge, sharp at the leading edge and blunt at the trailing edge. It gives the fins a thin wedge’s wave drag and the base drag of their trailing edges. HPR Sim has no such section. The design gives them square edges. HPR Sim charges their leading edges the pressure of air brought to a stop against them. The charge is 0.100 at Mach 2, against the handbook’s 0.016 for the whole fin. So each side’s fin pressure drag is shown but left out of the totals compared; the fins’ friction stays in.
Each term, the handbook’s first and then HPR Sim’s, on the reference area:
| Mach | handbook drag coefficient | HPR Sim drag coefficient | error | nose coefficient (handbook, HPR Sim) | base coefficient | friction coefficient | fins coefficient, left out (handbook, HPR Sim) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.5 | 0.423 | 0.379 | −10.3% | 0.000, 0.000 | 0.170, 0.152 | 0.253, 0.227 | 0.023, 0.069 |
| 0.7 | 0.405 | 0.401 | −1.1% | 0.000, 0.006 | 0.163, 0.184 | 0.242, 0.211 | 0.023, 0.075 |
| 0.9 | 0.393 | 0.484 | +23.1% | 0.007, 0.062 | 0.156, 0.225 | 0.230, 0.197 | 0.023, 0.082 |
| 0.95 | 0.404 | 0.533 | +31.9% | 0.011, 0.102 | 0.163, 0.237 | 0.230, 0.194 | 0.026, 0.085 |
| 1.0 | 0.465 | 0.609 | +31.0% | 0.052, 0.164 | 0.183, 0.250 | 0.230, 0.195 | 0.043, 0.087 |
| 1.1 | 0.542 | 0.651 | +20.1% | 0.109, 0.234 | 0.215, 0.227 | 0.218, 0.189 | 0.043, 0.089 |
| 1.2 | 0.528 | 0.593 | +12.3% | 0.117, 0.200 | 0.194, 0.208 | 0.217, 0.184 | 0.036, 0.091 |
| 1.6 | 0.472 | 0.444 | −6.0% | 0.109, 0.123 | 0.168, 0.156 | 0.195, 0.165 | 0.022, 0.097 |
| 2.0 | 0.415 | 0.377 | −9.2% | 0.095, 0.104 | 0.147, 0.125 | 0.173, 0.147 | 0.016, 0.100 |
| 2.4 | 0.363 | 0.331 | −8.9% | 0.089, 0.094 | 0.124, 0.104 | 0.150, 0.132 | 0.013, 0.102 |
| 2.8 | 0.328 | 0.296 | −9.6% | 0.085, 0.088 | 0.106, 0.089 | 0.137, 0.119 | 0.011, 0.103 |
| 3.2 | 0.298 | 0.269 | −9.6% | 0.083, 0.084 | 0.089, 0.078 | 0.126, 0.107 | 0.009, 0.103 |
Six of twelve rows are within 10%. HPR Sim reads +12.3% to +31.9% high from Mach 0.9 to 1.2, and −6.0% to −9.6% low from Mach 1.6:
- The nose through Mach 1. Niskanen’s ogive gives two to three times the handbook’s: 0.164 against 0.052 at Mach 1.0, and 0.234 against 0.109 at 1.1. Stoney’s measured 3:1 cone also sits under Niskanen’s closed form through the rise (Drag through Mach 1). From Mach 2 the two agree within 10%.
- The base. Niskanen’s base drag (eq. 3.94, after Fleeman’s missile design textbook) gives 0.250 at Mach 1.0 where the handbook reads 0.183 from measured bases. Faster than sound HPR Sim’s is the lower: 0.125 against 0.147 at Mach 2.
- Friction reads 10.4% to 15.9% lower in HPR Sim. The handbook takes a smooth flat plate’s friction and adds 15% on the body. HPR Sim’s body factor ([N09] eq. 3.85) adds 2% for this slender body, which accounts for about 11 points. The rest is unexplained; the two methods correct friction for Mach number differently.
So HPR Sim’s body reads high through Mach 1, from the nose and the base. It reads 6% to 10% low faster than sound, from friction and the base. That is the same sign as Calisto’s gap to RASAero II, which is −14.9% to −5.1% from Mach 1.2 to 2. This rocket has no boattail, so it says nothing about a boattail’s own drag.
A tangent ogive past Mach 1, beside OpenRocket 24.12
What is checked: the pressure drag HPR Sim gives a tangent ogive nose of fineness ratio 3 at Mach 1.3, 1.5 and 2, against the closed form of the method it follows, with OpenRocket 24.12’s beside it; and from Mach 1 to 1.3, every 0.01, beside OpenRocket 24.12’s. Pressure drag is the drag from the air’s pressure on the nose, mostly wave drag past Mach 1. The result: HPR Sim gives the method’s value. OpenRocket 24.12 gives under 1% of it at Mach 1.3, 1.5 and 2, and between 0.6% and 32.2% of it from Mach 1 to 1.3. This is one code against another, not a measurement. It shows where the two differ. It doesn’t show which matches a real nose.
The probe is an invented rocket: a nose 150 mm (5.9 in) long on a tube 50 mm (2.0 in) across, with a 500 mm (19.7 in) tube and three fins behind it.
The method is the one in Niskanen’s thesis ([N09], appendix B). It gives an ogive the drag of the cone with its length and base diameter, times (eq. B.8). Here is the tangent ogive’s arc radius over the nose’s own arc radius: 1 for a tangent ogive. The factor is then exactly 1, so the nose drags as that cone, its equivalent cone. The cone’s half-angle has for fineness ratio . From Mach 1.3 up, at Mach number , eq. B.4 gives it, on its base area,
At and , where and :
The nose’s pressure drag coefficient on its base area, at zero angle of attack:
| Mach | equivalent cone (coefficient) | HPR Sim, tangent ogive (coefficient) | OpenRocket 24.12, tangent ogive (coefficient) | OpenRocket 24.12, cone (coefficient) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.3 | 0.15571 | 0.15571 | 0.00098 | 0.15571 |
| 1.5 | 0.13028 | 0.13028 | 0.00073 | 0.13028 |
| 2 | 0.10421 | 0.10421 | 0.00047 | 0.10421 |
- HPR Sim’s number is its code’s output for the nose, not the formula. It agrees with the equivalent cone’s to .
- OpenRocket’s numbers are what OpenRocket’s own drag calculation reports for the nose, read from OpenRocket itself by a script.
- The control is the number headed “OpenRocket 24.12, cone”: the same rocket with a conical nose of the same length and base. OpenRocket 24.12 returns the closed form for it, within at Mach 1.5 and 2 and low at Mach 1.3. The cause of that small miss wasn’t examined. So the number read for a nose is the nose’s own pressure drag.
- The area. On this probe the tube is as wide as the nose’s base, so the rocket’s reference area is the nose’s base area and nothing is rescaled. A second control shows that OpenRocket’s number is on the reference area. With the body widened behind the nose to 80 mm (3.1 in), the reference area is 2.56 times the nose’s base, and OpenRocket’s number for the nose falls to 1/2.56 of the first control’s.
- OpenRocket 24.12’s tangent ogive is under 1% of the equivalent cone’s at each Mach number in this table. That is the defect OpenRocket’s issue #3391 reported on this shape. A maintainer confirmed it on November 2, 2026, and a fix was merged to OpenRocket’s development branch that day (pull request #3431). Above Mach 1, OpenRocket 24.12 fed the cone formula the angle at which the nose meets the body tube, where the method takes the equivalent cone’s half-angle. For a tangent ogive that angle is almost zero, and so is the drag. By November 14, 2026 no release carried the fix.
What follows: at Mach 1.3, 1.5 and 2, OpenRocket 24.12 gives this nose almost none of the pressure drag its own documented method gives.
From Mach 1 to 1.3. A second set of runs asks OpenRocket 24.12 the same two noses, the tangent ogive and its cone, at each of the 31 Mach numbers from 1 to 1.3, in steps of 0.01 (its record). Below Mach 1.3 eq. B.4 doesn’t apply. The method gives a cone at Mach 1, here , and joins it to eq. B.4’s value at Mach 1.3 by the cubic that meets both ends’ values and slopes ([N09] eq. B.3 to B.6). HPR Sim’s number is its code’s output, and it gives the tangent ogive exactly its equivalent cone’s value at every row. So its coefficient rises from 0.16440 at Mach 1 to 0.23428 at Mach 1.1, the highest of the 31 rows, and falls to 0.15571 at Mach 1.3. The nose’s pressure drag coefficient on its base area, at zero angle of attack, at seven of the 31 rows:
| Mach | HPR Sim, tangent ogive (coefficient) | OpenRocket 24.12, tangent ogive (coefficient) | OpenRocket 24.12, cone (coefficient) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 0.16440 | 0.00162 | 0.16440 |
| 1.05 | 0.21816 | 0.05858 | 0.21741 |
| 1.1 | 0.23428 | 0.07551 | 0.23427 |
| 1.15 | 0.22441 | 0.06354 | 0.22412 |
| 1.2 | 0.20024 | 0.03824 | 0.20024 |
| 1.25 | 0.17345 | 0.01294 | 0.17363 |
| 1.3 | 0.15571 | 0.00098 | 0.15571 |
- Which way they differ. OpenRocket 24.12’s tangent ogive is below HPR Sim’s at every row, by 0.155 to 0.163 in the coefficient. It is 1.0% of HPR Sim’s value at Mach 1, rises to 32.2% at Mach 1.1 and falls to 0.6% at Mach 1.3. Its curve has the shape of HPR Sim’s, a rise to Mach 1.1 and a fall, but from a start near zero, so it peaks at 0.0755 where HPR Sim’s peaks at 0.234. OpenRocket’s issue #3391 reports that peak as a false hump of about 0.075 near Mach 1.1.
- The control. OpenRocket 24.12’s cone matches HPR Sim’s cone within at every even hundredth (Mach 1.00, 1.02 and so on). So the number read is again the nose’s own pressure drag. At each odd hundredth, OpenRocket’s number for either nose is the mean of the two beside it, as if it read its curve every 0.02 and drew straight lines between. That leaves its cone within 0.00094 of HPR Sim’s, 0.53%, the most at Mach 1.01.
So from Mach 1 to 1.3, too, OpenRocket 24.12 gives this tangent ogive far less pressure drag than its documented method gives: 0.6% to 32.2% of HPR Sim’s. This is code against code, and it doesn’t show which matches a real nose.
What the two codes’ noses do to an apogee is sized, code against code, on the designs of 5 logged flights that pass Mach 1 with a tangent-ogive nose. They reach Mach 1.06 on average and none passes Mach 1.3, so they sit in the band of the runs from Mach 1 to 1.3. Flown with OpenRocket’s number for the nose above Mach 1 in place of its own, HPR Sim climbs higher by 1.28% of OpenRocket’s apogee on average (the tangent-ogive nose’s line, M2.3c13, which sized it). The design library’s report sizes a faster flight, on HPR Sim’s own thrust and mass rather than OpenRocket’s. On its one supersonic flight the swap alone moves the apogee from +13.60% to +31.73% of OpenRocket’s. With OpenRocket’s base rule as well, it comes to +0.45% (a supersonic flight).
What stays open: whether the equivalent cone’s value matches a measured tangent ogive (evidence row G40, the nose’s pressure drag past Mach 1, #222, the supersonic drag gap to OpenRocket, #616, the nose scored against measured tangent ogives). Published NACA and Air Force reports, read in a research note and not yet committed as data, lean one way near Mach 1.5. Their means put a nose of this shape at 0.110 to 0.119, against HPR Sim’s 0.130. One report’s four cases, as the note works them out, span 0.103 to 0.136. If the means hold, HPR Sim’s nose drag is high there, which lowers its apogee. From Mach 2 to 3 the reports disagree with each other by 10% to 20%, so nothing is settled there. The MIL-HDBK-762 sample calculation above works a 3-caliber tangent ogive by the handbook’s methods.
The records are
openrocket-nose-pressure-drag.json,
written by validation/oracles/openrocket/nose_pressure_drag.py, and
openrocket-nose-pressure-drag-transonic.json,
written by nose_pressure_drag_transonic.py beside it; both need the OpenRocket 24.12 jar to run
again. The tests
openrocket::tests::a_tangent_ogive_s_pressure_drag_past_mach_1_beside_openrocket_24_12_s and
a_tangent_ogive_s_pressure_drag_from_mach_1_to_1_3_beside_openrocket_24_12_s in
hpr-validate pin every number in the two tables
(ADR-349, the decision that set this probe up).
The Basic Finner’s normal force against DREV’s range
In short: on the Basic Finner, HPR Sim’s normal-force slope reads 9.3% to 24.9% below the measured one from Mach 1.08 to 3.15, and its center of pressure lies 0.03 to 0.34 calibers forward of the measured one. Forward is the side that understates stability. The cause is not found.
What is checked: HPR Sim’s slope and center of pressure at a small angle of attack, against fits of free flights in the aeroballistic range of Canada’s DREV ([DREV] Table IX, PDF pp. 48–49). The model is the Basic Finner, a standard test body: a cone of 10° half-angle on a cylinder, 10 calibers long in all, with four fins at the base, each a square one caliber in chord and span ([DREV] Fig. 2, PDF p. 53). Each row is one six-degree-of-freedom fit of two to four flights of 30 mm (1.2 in) models at one Mach number.
DREV’s Table IX has eight rows. The six at or below Mach 3.5, the top of the envelope, are typed
into the reference, and the model is a committed design. cargo xtask aero writes the comparison to
the report, and hpr_aero::tests::basic_finner_normal_force_against_drev recomputes
every figure in it. The increment that added it set no
target.
The measured center of pressure is worked out, not printed. The report gives the slope and the pitching-moment slope , both per radian on the body’s cross-section, the moment about a point 5.50 calibers from the nose tip. It does not state the moment’s reference length. The body’s diameter is taken (the decision that set this comparison up, decision 4). A force that acts aft of that point turns the nose down, a negative moment, so the center of pressure, in calibers from the nose tip, is
For example, at Mach 1.832 the table gives and , so the center of pressure is from the nose tip, in calibers. Its probable error is the ratio’s, with the two slopes’ errors taken as independent. The table gives 4% for the slope and prints 0% for the moment, taken here as 0.5%. Together they are 4.03% of the 2.37-caliber arm, 0.10 calibers.
The slope. HPR Sim’s is the sum of its body’s part and its fins’, the fins’ with their interference with the body. The report measured the whole model only. The error is HPR Sim’s less DREV’s, as a share of DREV’s, worked from the unrounded figures, so a negative one is low.
| Mach | DREV’s , per rad (probable error) | HPR Sim’s body, per rad | HPR Sim’s fins, per rad | HPR Sim’s , per rad | error |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.077 | 18.47 (2%) | 2.00 | 11.86 | 13.86 | −24.9% |
| 1.293 | 18.27 (3%) | 2.20 | 11.52 | 13.71 | −24.9% |
| 1.832 | 11.78 (4%) | 3.05 | 7.41 | 10.46 | −11.2% |
| 2.375 | 10.52 (2%) | 3.25 | 5.57 | 8.83 | −16.1% |
| 2.718 | 9.01 (2%) | 3.33 | 4.84 | 8.17 | −9.3% |
| 3.147 | 8.69 (1%) | 3.39 | 4.17 | 7.56 | −13.0% |
The center of pressure, in calibers from the nose tip. DREV’s is the one worked out above from its two slopes, with its probable error in parentheses. The error is HPR Sim’s less DREV’s, so a negative one is forward.
| Mach | DREV’s, calibers (probable error) | HPR Sim’s, calibers | error, calibers |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.077 | 8.35 (0.06) | 8.28 | −0.07 |
| 1.293 | 8.29 (0.08) | 8.26 | −0.03 |
| 1.832 | 7.87 (0.10) | 7.54 | −0.34 |
| 2.375 | 7.30 (0.04) | 7.12 | −0.18 |
| 2.718 | 7.19 (0.03) | 6.91 | −0.27 |
| 3.147 | 6.93 (0.02) | 6.70 | −0.23 |
By band. From Mach 1.5 to 2.5, the band this comparison was added for, the slope reads 11.2% and 16.1% low and the center of pressure 0.34 and 0.18 calibers forward. Below Mach 1.5 the slope reads 24.9% low at both Mach numbers, with the center of pressure 0.07 and 0.03 calibers forward. From Mach 2.5 to 3.5 the slope reads 9.3% and 13.0% low, and the center of pressure 0.27 and 0.23 calibers forward.
At each fit’s root-mean-square yaw. The table’s mean squared yaw is read here as the mean square of the whole angle of attack. On these six rows the fits hold at zero the terms that grow with the cube of that angle, so each measured slope is a straight-line fit over the angles the models flew. The table gives each fit’s mean squared yaw, 0.7 to 1.9 square degrees. HPR Sim’s body lift grows with the angle, so at an angle its is above its small-angle slope. At each fit’s root-mean-square yaw the slope’s miss is 0.8 to 2.4 percentage points smaller, and the center of pressure 0.02 to 0.04 calibers further forward:
| Mach | root-mean-square yaw, degrees | HPR Sim’s there, per rad | error | center-of-pressure error, calibers |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.077 | 0.95 | 14.01 | −24.1% | −0.10 |
| 1.293 | 1.22 | 13.91 | −23.9% | −0.07 |
| 1.832 | 0.84 | 10.59 | −10.1% | −0.36 |
| 2.375 | 1.00 | 8.98 | −14.6% | −0.21 |
| 2.718 | 1.38 | 8.39 | −6.9% | −0.31 |
| 3.147 | 1.14 | 7.74 | −10.9% | −0.26 |
This is nearer like for like, not like for like. A straight line fitted over a spread of angles leans toward the larger ones: the fit weights them more, and the part of the lift that grows with the square of the angle is largest there. So the root-mean-square yaw is a low reading of the angle a fit stands for. At a larger one HPR Sim’s miss in the slope would be smaller again and, by the trend of the table above, its miss in the center of pressure larger.
Under each mean squared yaw, DREV’s table prints a second figure, headed ABARM. The report defines no such symbol. It defines AMAX, the maximum angle of attack, but the table does not give it. So the comparison stops at the root-mean-square yaw.
What it means. HPR Sim’s slope is low on every row, by more than the fit’s probable error. Its center of pressure is forward on every row, and by more than the probable error on all but Mach 1.293: narrowly at Mach 1.077, 0.07 against 0.06 calibers, and by more than three times it from Mach 1.832 up. Both hold at a small angle and at each fit’s root-mean-square yaw. On this body, then, HPR Sim understates the stability margin: with the models’ center of gravity at 5.50 calibers, where the report’s drawing puts it and the fits take their moments, the measured margin at Mach 1.832 is 2.37 calibers and HPR Sim’s is 2.04. The test pins each row’s sign and size, so a change to the model that moved the center of pressure aft of the measured one would fail it.
The direction is this body’s and does not carry to another rocket. Faster than sound, a small change of shape can take a body off the shock-expansion method and onto slender-body theory: the switches (The body faster than sound in a flight). At four of them (a step in radius, a flare too long for its boattail’s wake, a pointed tip steeper than 30°, and a vertical tip steeper than the cap’s handover) HPR Sim’s center of pressure then lies aft of where the shock-expansion method puts it, the side that overstates stability. At the fifth, a lip longer than its boattail’s drop, it lies forward. Those are jumps between two of HPR Sim’s own methods, not errors against a measurement, so which way the center of pressure moves on a given rocket depends on its body.
The cause is not found (#1502). The measurement can’t say whether the missing lift is the fins’ or the body’s, since it has no fins-off flights. The row at Mach 1.077 goes to the transonic increment, where the long Arcas Robin model’s slope reads both ways, from 8.8% low to 27.1% high (Normal force through Mach 1). The rows from Mach 1.293 to 2.375 go to the supersonic increment, and the two above Mach 2.5 to the extended band’s. An earlier issue, #619, tracks the two rows below Mach 1.5.
What it leaves out.
- The fins’ section. The report draws each fin as a single wedge, sharp at the leading edge and 0.08 calibers thick at the trailing edge. HPR Sim has no such section, and its fin lift uses the planform alone, so the design gives them a square section of that thickness. The lift a wedge’s thickness adds is not modeled.
- Spin. The models’ fins were canted 0°, 2° or 4°, and the fits pool flights of all three where they could, so some models rolled. The design’s fins are not canted.
- Drag and pitch damping. The same table gives both. The next section compares them.
- The rows past Mach 3.5. The table’s last two, at Mach 3.734 and 4.300, are outside the envelope and are not typed.
The Basic Finner’s drag and pitch damping against DREV’s range
In short: on the Basic Finner, with the drag of its wedge fins, which HPR Sim can’t draw, added from published figures, HPR Sim’s zero-lift drag reads 16.5% to 21.3% below the measured one from Mach 1.83 to 3.15, and its pitch damping 24.7% to 39.6% below it. Below Mach 1.5 the drag reads 10.1% high at Mach 1.077, in a band that reaches below the measured one, and 3.5% low at 1.293; the damping reads 25.4% high and 16.8% low. Less damping than measured lets a swing in pitch die away more slowly than it does, so the rocket looks less steady than it is: the side that does not flatter. More, at Mach 1.077, is the side that does. The cause of the drag’s miss is not found.
What is checked: HPR Sim’s drag coefficient at zero angle of attack, , against the
axial-force coefficient of the same range fits as
the normal force above ([DREV] Table IX,
PDF pp. 48–49), and its pitch damping, the moment that resists a rate of pitch, against their
.
Both are on the body’s cross-section, the damping about the same point, 5.50 calibers from the
nose tip. The six rows, each shot’s own drag from the single fits (Table VIII, PDF pp. 44–46) and
its Reynolds number (Table V, PDF p. 41) are in the reference. HPR Sim’s drag on each row is taken at the mean of its shots’
Reynolds numbers, 23.8 to 70.2 million per meter. cargo xtask aero
writes the report, and hpr_aero::tests::basic_finner_drag_and_damping_against_drev
recomputes every figure in it. The increment that added it
set no target.
The drag. The models’ fins are single wedges, sharp at the leading edge and 0.08 calibers thick at the trailing edge. HPR Sim has no such section, so the design draws them square, 0.08 calibers thick. A square fin’s blunt leading edge meets the air at its stagnation pressure, so as drawn HPR Sim’s drag reads 34.5% to 138.1% above DREV’s, which says nothing about the rest of the body. So the report takes out the square edges’ two terms, the leading edge’s and HPR Sim’s trailing-edge rule, and puts in the wedge’s two, from cited sources (the wedge note, its figures):
- The faces. Each face turns the flow by , half the 0.08-caliber thickness over the one-caliber chord. From Mach 1.293 up the shock stands attached at the sharp edge, and the face pressure is the oblique shock’s (NACA Report 1135 eqs. 128 and 138). At Mach 1.077 the shock stands off; there the faces take Vincenti and Wagoner’s transonic value (NACA Report 1095 Fig. 7). That two-dimensional value is “an approximate upper bound” for a wing of finite span (p. 11), and nothing bounds it from below, so the band’s high end adds its reading error and its low end takes the faces at zero.
- The trailing edges. Their base drag is a two-dimensional base’s with a turbulent boundary layer, a band read from Hoerner’s measurements and Love’s compilation (NACA TN 3819 Fig. 5). It lies 1.3 to 3.1 times above HPR Sim’s own trailing-edge rule, which is a rocket base’s (#1514).
For example, at Mach 2.375 the buildup as drawn is 0.934. Of that, its square leading edge is 0.592 and its trailing-edge rule 0.043, which leaves 0.299 for the body, the nose, the friction and the body’s base. The wedge’s faces add 0.016 and its trailing edges 0.065 to 0.073, so HPR Sim’s is 0.384, from 0.380 to 0.388. DREV’s is 0.484, so HPR Sim reads 20.6% low.
| Mach | DREV’s (coefficient) | its shots’ drag coefficient | HPR Sim’s drag coefficient, square edges out (coefficient) | the wedge faces’ drag coefficient | the wedge trailing edges’ drag coefficient | HPR Sim’s (coefficient; band) | error (band) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.077 | 0.863 | 0.854 to 0.868 | 0.606 | 0.110 | 0.175 to 0.293 | 0.950 (0.781 to 1.011) | +10.1% (−9.5% to +17.1%) |
| 1.293 | 0.731 | 0.701 to 0.760 | 0.487 | 0.043 | 0.151 to 0.200 | 0.706 (0.681 to 0.730) | −3.5% (−6.8% to −0.1%) |
| 1.832 | 0.585 | 0.567 to 0.598 | 0.362 | 0.022 | 0.098 to 0.110 | 0.488 (0.482 to 0.494) | −16.5% (−17.6% to −15.5%) |
| 2.375 | 0.484 | 0.473 to 0.500 | 0.299 | 0.016 | 0.065 to 0.073 | 0.384 (0.380 to 0.388) | −20.6% (−21.4% to −19.7%) |
| 2.718 | 0.435 | 0.400 to 0.452 | 0.272 | 0.014 | 0.053 to 0.061 | 0.342 (0.338 to 0.346) | −21.3% (−22.2% to −20.4%) |
| 3.147 | 0.373 | 0.350 to 0.385 | 0.244 | 0.012 | 0.041 to 0.049 | 0.301 (0.297 to 0.305) | −19.3% (−20.4% to −18.2%) |
The table’s has a printed probable error only at the first two rows, under 0.5%. At the other four, each shot was fitted its own (DREV’s section 5.2), and every shot’s fit prints under 0.5% too; the shots column gives their spread. The error is HPR Sim’s over DREV’s, less 1, from unrounded values, and the band takes both ends of the wedge’s figures.
The pitch damping. A free flight measures how fast the model’s swing in pitch dies away. HPR Sim’s damping is not a coefficient it adds: the flight engine takes each part’s force in its own local flow, which the rotation changes. Pitching at a rate about the reference point tilts the flow at a part behind it by , with the airspeed and the body’s diameter. That part’s slope times that angle is a force, and the force times again is the damping moment. As a coefficient per radian of , summed over the parts,
where, strictly, is a part’s arm to where the engine takes its flow times its arm to
its own center of pressure (hpr_aero::AeroModel::pitch_damping; a test in hpr_sim holds the engine’s moment to it within
0.01%). DREV’s equation for the damping rate, eq. [1] (PDF p. 28), implies the same convention:
with no spin it reduces to the rate of a swing damped by and by per
. A free flight can’t part from , the moment from the rate of
change of the angle of attack, so DREV’s figure is their sum. HPR Sim has no , so
its is the whole of its damping.
For example, at Mach 2.375 HPR Sim’s fins lift 5.573 per radian at 3.978 calibers behind the reference point, which gives . With the body’s −49.85 it is −226.2, against DREV’s −306.5: 26.2% less damping.
| Mach | DREV’s , per rad (probable error) | HPR Sim’s body, per rad | HPR Sim’s fins, per rad | HPR Sim’s , per rad | error |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.077 | −322.4 (5%) | −52.0 | −352.3 | −404.3 | +25.4% |
| 1.293 | −487.4 (6%) | −50.5 | −355.1 | −405.6 | −16.8% |
| 1.832 | −377.7 (4%) | −51.1 | −233.2 | −284.3 | −24.7% |
| 2.375 | −306.5 (4%) | −49.9 | −176.4 | −226.2 | −26.2% |
| 2.718 | −335.5 (3%) | −49.2 | −153.5 | −202.7 | −39.6% |
| 3.147 | −260.1 (3%) | −48.6 | −132.4 | −181.0 | −30.4% |
A positive error is more damping than measured. DREV’s report notes that its damping scatters more than its other coefficients and that the multiple fit near Mach 2.4 is off the trend.
By band. From Mach 1.5 to 2.5, the band this comparison was added for, the drag reads 16.5% and 20.6% low and the damping 24.7% and 26.2% low. Below Mach 1.5 the drag reads 10.1% high and 3.5% low, and the damping 25.4% high and 16.8% low. From Mach 2.5 to 3.5 the drag reads 21.3% and 19.3% low and the damping 39.6% and 30.4% low.
What it means. From Mach 1.832 up HPR Sim’s drag is below every shot of its row at both ends of the wedge’s band. It stays below DREV’s even with the trailing edges at a vacuum, the most a base can add: so the miss is not the wedge’s base. Its cause is not found (#1513). The candidates are the body’s base, the friction and how the fins’ bases share the body’s wake, and none is measured here. On this body a drag that low would, other things equal, put a simulated apogee too high. At Mach 1.293 the drag is inside the shots’ spread. At Mach 1.077 the value with the faces at that upper bound and the trailing edges at their band’s middle reads 10.1% high, above every shot, but its low end reads 9.5% low: the faces’ figure is an upper bound with nothing below it, the trailing edges rest on one steep figure, and the row’s three shots flew from Mach 1.056 to 1.116, where that figure moves fast. So the sign there is not settled. A drag that reads high puts a simulated apogee too low, the side that flatters when it is held against an altitude waiver’s ceiling.
The damping is low in size wherever the shock stands attached, by 2.8 to 13.2 times the fit’s probable error: HPR Sim lets this body’s swing in pitch last longer than it did, the side that does not flatter. Part of that is the lift: from Mach 1.83 up HPR Sim’s slope reads 9.3% to 16.1% low (above; #1502). Part may be the that HPR Sim leaves out; nothing here parts the two. At Mach 1.077 HPR Sim overstates the damping by 25.4%, five times the fit’s probable error. The test pins each row’s sign and size, for the drag and the damping.
What it leaves out.
- The wedge’s base beside the body’s. The fins end flush with the body’s base. No source read here measures a fin’s base pressure there, so the band is a free two-dimensional base’s.
- Spin. The fits pool models with fins canted 0°, 2° and 4°. The design’s fins are not canted, and the drag of rolling is not modeled.
- The drag’s growth with angle. The table’s is not compared; HPR Sim’s is at zero angle.
Roll against the Arcas Robin and the Basic Finner
What is checked: HPR Sim’s roll forcing against NASA’s measured roll effectiveness of the two Arcas Robin models, Mach 1.5 to 4.63 ([D4014] Fig. 14). HPR Sim’s roll damping is checked against the Basic Finner’s measured in NOL’s wind tunnel from Mach 1.53 to 2.76 ([N6652] Table 2; Mach 2.76 from Table 1, where Table 2 prints 2.70), and against DREV’s free-flight range fits from Mach 1.83 to 3.15 ([DREV] Table IX). It is also checked against Barrowman’s own computed value at Mach 0.07
([B67] Figs. 5-6 and 5-7). The readings are in the wind-tunnel fixture and
the Basic Finner’s; cargo xtask aero writes the comparison to
the roll fixture, and hpr_aero::tests::roll_against_mach recomputes every row.
The roadmap set no target.
The forcing. per degree of cant, on the body’s cross-section and diameter, at an angle of attack of 0. The reports’ symbol is per degree, and the models’ fins were canted 2°:
| Mach | model | measured , per degree (the report’s) | HPR Sim’s , per degree | error |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.5 | short | 0.1684 | 0.2489 | +47.8% |
| 1.8 | short | 0.1722 | 0.1968 | +14.3% |
| 1.8 | long | 0.1670 | 0.1968 | +17.8% |
| 2.3 | short | 0.1449 | 0.1495 | +3.2% |
| 2.3 | long | 0.1460 | 0.1495 | +2.4% |
| 2.96 | short | 0.1152 | 0.1151 | −0.1% |
| 2.96 | long | 0.1140 | 0.1151 | +1.0% |
| 3.96 | short | 0.0874 | 0.0861 | −1.4% |
| 3.96 | long | 0.0870 | 0.0861 | −1.0% |
| 4.63 | short | 0.0721 | 0.0739 | +2.5% |
| 4.63 | long | 0.0780 | 0.0739 | −5.3% |
The two models differ only in the body’s length ahead of the fins, which HPR Sim’s forcing doesn’t see. The measured values differ by up to 0.006 per degree (8%, at Mach 4.63). The report calls the effectiveness “about the same for either vehicle” ([D4014] p. 6). The short model’s readings were corrected when roll was added. The first reading had put each of its panels’ zeros 0.005 to 0.007 above the grid line it lies on (ADR-031). From Mach 2.3 all 8 are within 5.3%. At Mach 1.5 and 1.8 HPR Sim reads high, as Barrowman found for another sounding rocket. HPR Sim reads high because linear theory’s load climbs toward Mach 1 faster than the fins’ does. Without the body factor (0.935 here) every value would be 7% higher.
The damping. of the Basic Finner, four square fins one diameter in chord and span on a body one diameter across, per unit of on . The scored reference is NOL’s wind tunnel: models spun at 50 to 150 rev/s and left to slow, at an angle of attack of 0 ([N6652] Table 2, PDF p. 17, its average column). NOL prints its coefficient on one fin panel and the 3 d span. Times it is on the body’s cross-section and diameter, a factor two other reports confirm (research note). For example, at Mach 1.53 NOL prints 0.532, so ; HPR Sim gives −31.08, 27.5% more damping.
| Mach | reference | reference’s damping coefficient | HPR Sim’s damping coefficient | error |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.07 | Barrowman’s computed curve (chose the method; not a validation) | −34.21 | −33.53 | −2.0% |
| 1.53 | NOL wind tunnel | −24.39 | −31.08 | +27.5% |
| 2.03 | NOL wind tunnel | −19.34 | −22.53 | +16.5% |
| 2.27 | NOL wind tunnel | −17.01 | −20.12 | +18.3% |
| 2.54 | NOL wind tunnel | −16.13 | −18.02 | +11.7% |
| 2.76 | NOL wind tunnel | −14.44 | −16.63 | +15.2% |
Against DREV’s range, free flights of 30 mm (1.2 in) models fitted several rounds at a time ([DREV] Table IX,
PDF pp. 48–49), HPR Sim reads high too. In the core band (Mach 1.83 and 2.38) it reads 8.8% high on
average and 12.4% at most; in the extended band (2.72 and 3.15), 5.0% on average and 8.7% at most.
cargo xtask roll-drev flies this from the report’s readings cached outside the repository and
commits only these statistics (the DREV statistics); the gate’s refs step checks them.
Barrowman’s Fig. 5-7 points are no longer scored. They read −33.60, −27.45, −23.48, −20.92 and −18.32 at Mach 1.51, 1.82, 2.27, 2.60 and 3.00, and HPR Sim reads 5.9% to 16.2% below them. They sit a flat 1.27 times BRL Report 799’s free-flight range data as NOL replots it, which fits a slip in convention rather than a difference in the air (research note). They stay in the Basic Finner’s fixture as a disputed set.
HPR Sim reads high faster than sound, most near Mach 1.5. The likely cause there, an inference not shown: linear theory’s load rises as toward Mach 1 faster than the fins’ does, as in the forcing above. That doesn’t explain the 11.7% to 18.3% left from Mach 2.03 to 2.76. Part of it may be NOL’s own: its tunnel values “fell slightly below” the free-flight data it plotted beside them ([N6652] PDF p. 13), and against DREV’s free flights HPR Sim reads closer. The fins’ 8% thickness is unlikely to be the cause (an inference). BRL Report 711 flew the same shape (a 3 d span on a 1 d body) with thicker wedges, 16% at the trailing edge. They read 21% above its linear theory, which has no body factor; taking out HPR Sim’s of 1.167 for that shape leaves about 4%. Its linear lift for such a wedge is about 15% below exact theory’s near Mach 1.7. Both point the same way: a thickness term would raise the damping, not lower it. With the forcing right, a damping 11.7% to 27.5% high makes the steady spin about 10% to 22% low (). Near Mach 1.5 the forcing reads high too, on the Arcas Robin: errors from two bodies that partly cancel. Barrowman’s own curve comes from Busemann’s third-order expansion ([B67] eq. 3-7), which counts the fins’ thickness. His text gives 5.68% between it and the Fig. 5-7 points without saying how it is taken ([B67] p. 66); read off the figure, the gap is 2% to 7%. At Mach 0.07 HPR Sim gives his computed value within 2.0%. That is how HPR Sim’s reading of his damping method, the fin’s own slope over the strips, was checked (above).
The flight (hpr_sim::tests::canted_fins_spin_to_the_analytic_balance): Valetudo with 1° of
cant at 100 m/s (328 ft/s), with no drag or gravity, settles on the steady roll rate. The worked example’s closed-form rate is −16.948 rad/s, and the flight is within 1e-6 of it (the test’s bound; 1e-11 measured). One time constant in, the roll rate is within 1e-5 of the exponential approach (2e-10 measured). No pitch or yaw appears.
The pieces (hpr_aero::fins::tests): the polygon’s span moments against the trapezoid’s and the
ellipse’s integrals ([N09] eq. 3.70–3.71). Supersonic forcing and damping within 1e-7 of a 20,000-strip sum of the same load on the Arcas Robin’s swept fin, from Mach 1.5 to 4.63. The subsonic ones against Barrowman’s closed forms, and both continuous at Mach 0.8 and . against its integral (eq. 3-121) by Simpson’s rule within 1e-10.